Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
Dale Jablonski
I have a question, do all bowl coring systems produce grain tear out? I have a "Bowl Saver" from Woodcut and have noticed that it tends to produce grain tear out.
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
Dale Jablonski
I have a question, do all bowl coring systems produce grain tear out? I have a "Bowl Saver" from Woodcut and have noticed that it tends to produce grain tear out.
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
Ralph Lindberg
AFAIK, yup. They all "cut" the same way, since that's a scrape....
Green wood doesn't tear out as bad, also it cores easier
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
Bernie Weishapl
Yep my oneway does the same but not to bad. I never worry about it since I am going to dry them and return them to the lathe to finish.
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
Steve Kubien
I have used all three major systems and yes, they all tear out. In my experience, the Oneway produces the least but it is still significant. Remember though, this is effectively roughing out the bowl so I don't see where it makes a big difference (unless you are doing nested sets like Mike Mahoney does).
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
Carole Valentine
A coring system is not a finish tool, it's a roughing tool, so you should expect a some tearout, especially on dry wood. I don't get deep tearout with my McNaughton system unless it is punky wood. I do keep my tips sharp. Keep your cutter sharp and try squirting some WD-40 into the kerf.
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
robo hippy
Like Ralph said, they are scrapers, and scraping cuts in a bowl leave more tear out. Finish cuts are needed. Tear out also depends a bit on the wood as some woods are more prone to it than others.
robo hippy
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
Dale Jablonski
thanks everyone, that is what I figured...hoping to grow creatively AND educationally as a wood turner. This confirmed my suspicions. Another lesson confirmed. 
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
woodspinner- harry robinette
Carol
I use 60/40 Anchor seal/water in a spray bottle works great and no silicone in my wood. I actually don't allow WD-40 in my shop it stays in the garage.Silicone and wood finish don't mix.
Just my $.02
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
Carole Valentine
WD-40 does not contain silicone. I have found that it has no effect on my finish (Waterlox)
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
John Lucas
Don't know what WD-40 has in it but it hasn't affected my wood finishes. It's also not a good lubricant even though people use it as such.
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out
John Lucas
I am still very new at coring. However I have a cutter from Mike Hunter that I was trying before my wife passed away and had to stop for a while. the carbide cutter seemed to tear out less although with my limited skills I was more concerned about simply saving the bowl and blowing though one of them. I hope to try it out again in the next month and I will pay attention to the cutting action a little more and report what I find.
Some trivia
Carole Valentine
WD-40 stands for "Water Displacer - 40th attempt"
From the WD-40 MSDS:
Product Use: Lubricant, Penetrant, Drives Out Moisture, Removes and Protects Surfaces From Corrosion
Aliphatic Hydrocarbon 40-50% (Stoddards solvent? mineral spirits?)
Petroleum Base Oil <25% (mineral oil?)
LVP Aliphatic Hydrocarbon 12-18%
Proprietary Surfactant <2%
Re: Bowl Coring Systems & tear out *LINK*
Brad Vietje
Hey Dale,
For all but the most high-volume production shops the tear-out isn't much of a problem. It also depends on whether you want round bowls or oval bowls.
Round bowls are turned twice -- roughed out of green wood and left a little thick, then finish turned after seasoning to true them up and leave a round finished product. I usually re-turn the cored bowls, both inside and out, before setting them aside to air dry, so the tear-out is removed at that time. Thus, the quality of the cut doesn't really bother me. Production bowl mills often produce oval, once-turned bowls to save time and money, so they try for the best finish off the tool during the green turning.
See video link to one way of doing it -- the Holland Bowl Mill in Michigan. If you look closely, they have a little sharp metal loop on the end of the curved knife, and a hook tool that cuts the outside of the inner bowls. The Granville and Weston bowl mills in Vermont were doing this over a hundred years earlier.
The nested sets of fairly thin bowls, like Mike Mahoney and a few others have perfected, may be a whole 'nuther deal, but I have not attempted multiple cores as thin as that.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Bowl Mill Video