Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Minimal dimensions for stability?

Posts

Minimal dimensions for stability?

#1

Minimal dimensions for stability?

ILYA Z

I finished this natural edge cherry bowl today. It turned out OK but I am not completely satisfied with the result.

This started out as a regular natural-edge deep "bowl-shaped bowl". However, it developed a huge crack while drying so I had to turn it into a shallower bowl with a foot:


I wanted to make the neck thinner but I was not sure how thin I can make it before the bowl loses stability and/or structural integrity (i.e. if something heavy gets put into the bowl, the neck snaps).

So my question is this: given the height of the bowl, its diameter, its ratio of the upper diameter to lower diameter (the blue lines in the photo), type of wood, thickness of bowl, weather in Florida, price of tea, my wife's mood etc etc, is there any rule-of-thumb formula for the minimal width and height of the neck (the red lines) that would make the bowl stable and structurally sound?

So I am essentially talking about the shape of the bowl in terms of its stability not aesthetics.

Thanks much!

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

#2

Richard Allen

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

Richard Allen

Wood is strong stuff. 1/2" in the thin part of the pedestal would be more than enough wood to support the bowl.

The issue becomes warping while drying vs checking while drying.

The base size looks about right but you could go a LOT thinner in the "waste" of the pedestal.

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

#3

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

john lucas

I'm not sure exactly what your asking but when I turn a bowl shaped like that I hollow the stem and base as well. Doing this usually stops it from checking although I still put it in a paper bag for the first week of drying.

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

#4

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

Doc Green

First, the stability (resistance to tipping over) will be determined by the diameter of the base where it contacts the table top. The diameter of the neck does not enter into this. I think you have it as small as it needs to be, perhaps a tad smaller, even.

The grain of the wood in the neck is horizontal, which means a fracture line in the neck area would be parallel to the wood fibers. This is the "weak" direction. So, my thinking is that the neck, also, is as small as it needs to be.

Consider this example. Take a strip of wood 2" wide, 3/4" thick, and 10" long. If the grain runs parallel to the length, it will be hard to break. However, if the strip is taken from the end of a board so that the grain runs perpendicular to the length, it will break easily.

Of course, the properties of this particular piece of wood must be considered. When you were turning it, did is seem hard, tough, solid, . . . strong? If so, you can go for a smaller diameter.

FWIW ~Doc

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

#5

Walt Bennett

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

Walt Bennett

I'd also narrow the neck and hollow the foot some (I'll typically put a bead or some sort of decorative addition as well inside it).

Worrying about what someone would do with a piece like that is something I've managed to get over (after about five years of 'mothering' everything I made). What I do now is first use a waterproof finish (tung oil or Waterlox) on just about everything and simply point out whatever there is about a piece that could be problematic in everyday use to a new owner (worm holes, potential imbalance, etc.). From that point it's up to them to use some common sense.

Re: Minimal dimensions for stability?

#6

my take...

GaryG in MD

Ilya,

In the end, it's a matter not of strength or balance, but what artistic shape you like. OTOH, it could be a matter of cracking -- forms like this will crack easily because of the thickness of the base. FWIW, I would call this shape a "compote" or "tazza" -- particularly if the stem is thinner. With a very thick stem like this, you might also call it a "chalice".

There are many possible answers depending on what you like and what you "see", but here's my personal reaction.

1) I like the foot base diameter at 1/3 of the top rim diameter, as you have made it.

2) I think the stem is too tall for the diameter at this width. To me it seems a tad awkward. This is just my personal preference. If you were to make the stem really thin (I mean REALLY thin, like a finial shape), then this height might be appropriate.

3) I prefer a much smaller foot "neck" diameter right under the bowl -- instead of having it taper downward to smaller diameters as you have here, I would cut under the bowl to a significantly smaller diameter and then either keep it roughly the same (with a very subtle taper) or let it gradually expand more obviously into the foot.

4) You can chose to keep a smooth flow underneath or to add some kind of accent line where the stem meets the bowl.

As one possible example, the attached photo is an old one I had chucked up years ago -- I don't have a decent photo of the finished form that shows the underneath base shape clearly. I could bring it to the next meeting if you'd like to see and hold it.

...Gary