Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Back To The Safety Cage Question...

Posts

Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#1

Brad Vietje

Back To The Safety Cage Question...

Brad Vietje

The conversation Keith started got carried off on a bit of a tangent, and I'm hoping we can pick that up again... I think the question boils down to this: Can we, the active turning community, help lathe manufacturers design a safety guard or cage that we actually would use?

I'm not going to guarantee that I will actually use the thing, but we have some very smart and very creative people here, so maybe we could come up with at least a tolerable guard -- maybe one we would be willing to use for roughing work, bark-included pieces, coring, etc... What'cha say, can you help design something better than the one hanging on my barn wall?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#2

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

Toney Robertson

No, I seriously don't think that a cage can be invented that will not have enough drawbacks to make most people quit using it. Heavy wire obstructs views and casts shadows. Plexiglass does not obstruct your view but gets dusty and then you have to clean it. Not to mention that an effective cage has to wrap around the front of the piece as far as possible to protect the turner's head and body.

As Katherine said before "Of course, practically speaking, it would be quite a difficult thing to design any contraption to hold the piece and allow sufficient access/view to the form."

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#3

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

Jorge Casta�eda

Anti static Plexiglas with air blown to it so dust cannot build

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#4

Thinking outside the Box.....

Barry Irby

How about some sort of ACTIVE device to protect my face and head?

Lots of manufacturing processes use cameras to identify substandard items and then air pressure to blow them out of the assembly line. Some of them "watch" bottles going by and if they are empty a plunger flicks the empty out of the process.

How about a Sawstop Mechanism type thing that would fire a piece of Kevlar blanket between you and the lathe?

Or a cable attached to your helmet could snatch your head back out of the way. With a really good cable and helmet it could probably jerk your head clean off, but leave it in good condition for the funeral.

I know that went a little silly, but there is an idea in there somewhere.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#5

Re: Thinking outside the Box.....

wayne kuhn

You may be onto something with the sawstop idea. For instance if the drive spindle detect a sudden loss of mass it will shut the lathe down. I know the horse is out of the barn at that point, but it would be a start. Actually it would be a stop.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#6

Re: Thinking outside the Box.....

Galen Vetterick

Wayne

From your detector, that's when the air bag is triggered that is either deployed from your face shield or from the lathe bed for those who forget or do not wear a face shield.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#7

Brian McKearney

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

Brian McKearney

Instead of thinking along the lines of a cage for the lathe, perhaps we should be thinking in terms of a better face shield that more turners would wear? I generally wear mine just like a seat belt when driving, but I recall a recent thread discussing face shields where many folks admitted that they don't wear theirs as often as they maybe should.

What is it about face shields that turns people away? Visibility? Comfort? And will a face shield really provide adequate protection in the event of a catastrophe?

Just my two cents...

Brian

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#8

Keith Tompkins

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

keith tompkins

Hi Brad, I'm glad you re-opened the topic. Yeah, the first post went awry (again, I apologize) but the topic is an important one. Let's examine woodworking machinery in general...can we name ONE industrial/commercial grade machine that comes equipped WITHOUT a guard or shield? Tablesaw? Shaper? Bandsaw? Panel saw or Edge bander? Even a chopsaw comes equipped with a blade guard. Your GRINDER? No, it's Federal LAW. No wonder Powermatic equips its lathes with a shield...after all, why should the lathe be any different? Who can sue them for injury incurred on their lathe if the shield was hanging on the wall? Their shield meets the bare legal letter of the law, nothing more. Little thought was given to its function in the real world, and it shows...... nobody uses it.

What IF someone developed a shield that actually worked? Would you purchase it? Would you use it if it didn't obstruct your view of the work? Do you think it would be too difficult to dream up or produce? What would happen if someone truly tackled the problem and actually solved it? But, if nobody ever uses their shield anyway, why would any company waste their time and resources in producing a product that nobody will buy?

I almost forgot...Yeah, I already knew before I asked how many people used their shield. Nobody. And, I already know how a proper shield can be produced.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#9

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

Peter Toch

Hi Keith:

I read you post with interest and was particularly intrigued by your last statement, "And, I already know how a proper shield can be produced." Question I have is, what is your definition of a proper shield? Seems to me that if your definition of a proper shield is the same as that of turners in general, you should immediately file a patent on it as it would be a tremendous seller. So, please let us know what are the properties (specifications) of what you consider a proper shield and do you have any cost projections?

Thanks, Peter Toch

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#10

Agreed, do tell.

Toney Robertson

I would bet most woodworkers use the guards provided on their machines when they are not a pain to use and they actually function as designed. I can not imagine the vast majority of woodturners being any different but I am skeptical that a guard for a lathe can be designed that would provide adequate protection and also be invisible. When I say invisible, I mean totally unobtrusive to what you are doing.

Most machines in the shop can be used without the operator needing to see the actual cutting while in progress. I do not need to see the blade of my table saw cut the wood, same goes for the jointer, planer, and drum sander. The lathe is one of, if not the only stationary power tool where the operator holds the cutting tool. Unique tool, unique problems.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#11

Face Shield - Back To The Safety Cage Question...

Ed Larson

Presently a face shield is a much more cost effective safety device that an expensive metal cage that is removed from the lathe and never used 99.99 % of the time. I just purchased the Unex S8510 for $35. The lathe manufactures would provide more safety by providing a $35 face shield with each lathe rather than an expensive cage that is never used.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#12

Steve Kubien

Another consideration perhaps...

Steve Kubien

When I think of the pieces I have orbited or experienced PDS with, I usually come to view either my tenon was faulty or the chuck jaws were too tight and deformed the tenon some how. ALL of these have occurred when using a dovetail-shaped jaw set and the break is always at the junction between the tenon and the blank itself. These jaws bite into the tenon right at this junction whereas the Oneway profiled jaws have a more even grip along their depth so....

I wonder if part of the problem is that deeper contact point/bite between the tenon and the blank? Lots of folks know more physics than me so shoot down this theory at your will.

Another possibility is the question of speed and torque... Are today's bigger lathe just too powerful for what a lot of people to with them? The big pattern-makers lathes if old had more power but did turn at thousands of rpm's?

Of course, none of this changes what happened to Joan, a very experienced turner by all accounts. It also doesn't factor into blanks shattering but perhaps we should re-examine the tools we use and how we use them.

Just my 2 cents.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#13

Ed- explain that to OHSA!!!

JamieDonaldson

:b

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Another consideration perhaps...

Brad Vietje

Good questions, Steve...

Here are a few others to ponder:

1. I suspect the safety record for lathes is not all that bad, considering how many people have gotten into the sport is the past 20 years.

2. When a hobby grows almost exponentially, there are bound to be a lot of newbies out there on their own learning curve.

3. With the concurrent rise of the internet, a lot of people seem to be skipping the traditional learning process of one-on-one mentoring, or bothering to join a club to learn more. We have a whole new generation that trusts Google and YouTube to teach them everything.

4. There are a lot of very aggressive turners out there. Some people brag about how they remove wood so rapidly that they would stall a 2 hp lathe, so they want a 5 hp... I know there are a very small percentage of turners who really do need a 5 hp lathe, but in my sometimes-not-too-humble opinion, if you are working in the 1" to 24" range, and you routinely stall a 2 hp lathe, you are probably doing something wrong. Either you need better technique, sharper tools, or maybe a little less coffee -- what's the big freakin' hurry, anyway???? I have a friend who has made all sorts of huge, 3' and 4' diameter Am. Elm bowls with thick, carved rims, natural edges, etc..., as well as thousands of cored burls up to about 48" in diameter, and he uses a 1.5 hp motor to drive his home-made bowl lathe.

5. Lathe envy. I know people who want to go big -- bigger -- biggest, and they end up using bigger equipment and attempting bigger pieces than they are ready for.

6. All of the above can, at times, combine to contribute to a few safety issues. When someone jumps right from 8" bowls to coring big burls and making 24" pieces without also mastering the subtleties of proper tenon formation, knowing when a face-plate would be a better choice, and without enough respect for the power of a big hunk of spinning wood, accidents can -- and will -- happen.

If we can create a better guard -- or a better turning helmet -- as well as posting more warnings on YouTube, we will have done the world a service.

Keep the ideas flowing, team!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#15

Keith Tompkins

Re: Face Shield - Back To The Safety Cage Question

keith tompkins

Hi Ed, With all due respect, I wouldn't trust my life to your face shield. Try this: Put on your face shield, and secure it snugly. Now, find a volunteer to give the shield a good whack with a baseball bat. That's about the equivalent of getting hit in the face with a 50 pound turning blank at 800 rpm.. Get back to me how you make out. (You know I'm only trying to make a point)

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#16

Keith Tompkins

Re: Agreed, do tell.

keith tompkins

Hi Toney, Very often, shop workers remove the guards from various machines. It's impossible to cut tenons, or raise a panel on the table saw with guard in place. It's actually more dangerous to cut thin pieces on the table saw with the guard in place than without it. Using a sled on the table saw requires the guard's removal. Cutting rabbets on the jointer also requires the removal of the guard. The idea is, the guard often gets in the way. That's the compelling thing about the lathe...we can watch the form develop with nothing more than a hand-held tool and skill. We MUST see the cut. So, it's imperitive that we have an unobstructed view of the work. A proper guard must fulfill that basic requirement. The powermatic guard tries to be both a spindle guard and a bowl guard, and succeeds at neither.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#17

Keith Tompkins

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

keith tompkins

Hi Peter,Here is the definition of a proper guard, from my perspective:

1. The purpose of the guard is to prevent catastophic injury. Flying bark, wood chips, etc. can be dealt with by wearing a face shield. Eye protection is required for ANY wood or metal working operation, no matter how many guards are in place.

2. It must perform the task it is intended to do. It must prevent a bowl blank from reaching the operator and causing severe injury.

3. It must be easy to operate and adjust. It must not inhibit the operator's view of the work. My version of the guard does not need to be removed from the lathe in order to mount a chuck, reverse a blank, etc., yet can be moved back into place in seconds. When not needed, for example while sanding or finishing, it is completely unobtrusive.

4. It must be cost effective... otherwise, nobody will buy it.

5. There must be a large enough market to justify its production. I believe there is...ideally, this guard could be integrated into the lathe by the manufacturer. Similar to the SawStop in one respect...if the technology is available, and it works, why would other manufacturers not apply it to their equipment? That has become a legal issue with the sawstop technology.

6. It's a natural progression...look at the advances made in the field of turning. From chucks, to better steels, advanced tool designs, etc...A better guard HAS to be produced. Think of all the kids learning to turn. Think of all the school shops who could benefit from a safer lathe. Consider the thousands and thousands of turners out there with questionable skills.How many injuries can be prevented.

7.Maybe I can make a difference in this world, even a small one. A story...my dad could seemingly do anything. He was the foreman for the company that built the first nuclear missle silos in Plattsburg, NY. He spent 20 years underground, digging the tunnels from upstate NY reservoirs to NY city. He seemed to know just about anything about concrete and construction. He became a NYS safety inspector, and was selected as one of only 7 people chosen to write the OSHA safety laws. That took five years. He used to come home with horror stories about accidents he had seen. I know he took pride in preventing even more. Even simple ideas can make a huge difference; he submitted an idea to NYS dept. of transportation, a very simple one. Install a time-delay relay in traffic signals at all intersections. I still have the letter from the commissioner thanking him for coming up with an idea that would save countless lives.

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

#18

Re: Back To The Safety Cage Question...

Peter Toch

Hi Kieth:

Going back to your statement, "And, I already know how a proper shield can be produced," the word "produced" to me strongly implies that you already have a design in mind. Something you can make a drawing of and give to a machinist to have him make a prototype. Is this what you meant? What you have described in your above post are the properties of what this safety device should possess, which I and virtually all turners would agree with totally, but what does it look like? How does it function? Does it prevent the wood from coming off the lathe altogether? Does it deflect or trap an errant piece of wood from reaching the turner? Or what, how?

Peter Toch