Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Let's suppose that we work for ...

Posts

Let's suppose that we work for ...

#1

Let's suppose that we work for ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

a tool manufacturer and that we have been tasked with choosing the woodturning tools we would select for a kit where the target purchasers own mini or midi lathes, such as a Jet 1220. The objective of the manufacturer is to maximize the sales of these kits. Tools will not be sold individually. Assume that excellent steel will be used to make the tools.

Questions:

1. How many tools would you put in a kit?

2. Which tools would you select?

3. Would you choose regular sized tools or so-called mini-tools?

Remember, your job depends on the sales of the kits.

Ed

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#2

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Mike Stafford

I will take a stab at this....

I will make an assumption that a lot of the people interested in this package deal are newcomers to turning.

My tools would be a 3/8" bowl gouge, a 1/2" spindle gouge, a 1/8" parting tool, a 3/4" spindle roughing gouge, a 3/4" roundnose scraper and a 1/2" skew chisel. All tools would be full sized.

With these tools a turner can turn a bowl, do some spindle work, turn pens, turn a box and much, much more.

I figure that out of your tool stash you could build somewhere around 75 of these kits....

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#3

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

I think that your answer is excellent. I think that I might add one more tool and I am not sure whether it would be a 1/2" square-nosed scraper, a 3/8" bedan, or a 3/8" beading tool.

And as to your last statement, what do I do with the other 30 kits? :b :D

Ed

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#4

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Mike Stafford

I considered the 1/2" square scraper because I use one a lot for boxes but I know that some of the operations I use it for can just as easily be done with a parting tool.

Gail came out to the shop after dinner and said, "How many of these tools do you really use? Do you need all of them?"

I am very worried...... :(

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#5

JL

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

JL

Seven tools.

Flat scraper

Parting tool

Round nose scraper

3/4" skew

Spindle gouge (3/8)

Bowl gouge (3/8)

Roughing gouge (3/4)

If you want to make it eight, you could add a bedan.

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#6

Richard Allen

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Richard Allen

Time they are a changing. When I started the kit was:

1/2" spindle gouge

3/8" deep fluted bowl gouge

1/8" parting tool

3/4" spindle roughing gouge

3/8" beading/parting tool

1" skew

Now days the kit would more likely be

Hunter tool (not sure the number) but a mid sized one

Easy wood tools, One round and one "square".

A fluted parting tool

Lee Valley spring loaded caliper

A 3/8" bowl gouge

A 3/8" detail gouge

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#7

You guys are funny and make me Laugh!!!

jake Niedling

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#8

Richard, that is an ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

interesting list. And it does reflect what is going on today.

Ed

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#9

Steven Antonucci

Never a mini tool!

steven antonucci

Short handles encourage bad technique and are hard to get good curves with...

A skew (1")

A detail gouge (5/16")

A spindle gouge (3/8")

a Bowl gouge (1/2")

a half round scraper (1")

and I suppose a parting tool

If I was aiming at a the end grain market, I would throw in a hook tool.

If I am packing to demonstrate ANYTHING except hollowing, this is what I bring. If I am doing a lot of spindle roughing, I pack a spindle roughing gouge to save the wings on my bowl gouge.

And I would stop making those stupid wooden boxes that they sell them in and make a high quality tool roll instead.

Steve

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#10

Re: Why the Skew

Steve Criscenzo

I think I would leave out the skew for a beginner package. Start with the basics and add the skew later. (Can't wait to see where this goes )

Steve

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#11

How would they open cans of finish?

Barry Irby

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#12

Re: Why the Skew

john lucas

Nick Cook has started teaching the skew as the first tool. Because it is easier for the student to understand the bevel and how it controls the shape of the cut. You can easily imagine now confusing the multiple angles of the bowl gouge bevel can be. With the skew it's pretty easy. Lift the handle and it cuts deeper. Lower the handle and it stops cutting. It's just a small step see how it will follow a curve. Now he doesn't start them out turning beads which admittedly is difficult. He starts them with a garden dibble which is basially just a long barrel shape. Then they progress to a spindle gouge to work on the cove.

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#13

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Philip Duffy

Mike has the right answer but I would add a drop nose scrapper al la Myron Curtis - -extremely useful in many applications, including end grain removal, spindle work, decoratative beads, etc. Phil

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#14

Steven Antonucci

If you can dodge a wrench, you can dodge a...

steven antonucci

dodgeball. (Ben Stiller movie)

Why do towns that give out tickets for 2 mph over the speed limit have fewer speeders? Because the rules are enforced.

The concept I think is pretty simple. All turning tools have the exact same set of rules, but the skew enforces them. If you get a little bit off bevel with a gouge, it will still cut, although you can pass a point of cutting start scraping. Beginners don't see this as being such a big deal because they don't understand what the bevel is nor what it does for them.

Learn the skew, and the other tools are almost automatic...

S

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#15

Re: Why the Skew

Stuart Johnson

For what it's worth the skew is the one tool I can pick up with complete confidence of using without some stupid mistake. I'm guaranteed to make at least one bad entry with the bowl gouge and need to re smooth the face. I'll make a nice cove on the the side of a vase when using a spindle gouge. My theory is both the bowl and spindle gouge are easier to use so I don't pay as much attention as is required. They also both make such nice shavings it is easy to get carried away watching them just peel away. While with the skew just an instance lapse will give some rather dramatic spirals.

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#16

Steve Kubien

Re: Why the Skew

Steve Kubien

I'm not a teacher but this makes total sense to me. Get comfortable with a skew and a lot of things become easier. I'm no whiz with it but I do more roughing with it than my SRG.

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#17

Mike Stafford

Re: Why the Skew

Mike Stafford

John, I think it is important to introduce the concept of a negative rake scraper and the skew is the perfect tool for that.... :b :b :b :D

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#18

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Mike Stafford

Phillip I have several of the Myron Curtis drop nosed scrapers in my inventory now and use them frequently when the need arises. A truly wonderful tool. I have them in a variety of sizes.

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#19

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Peter Toch

There goes Ed Moore again throwing out another one of his taunting open ended questions. It's been interesting to read the varied responses to his question considering the caveats he has attached to it. Everyone forged ahead to state the tools they would recommend for this fictitious "boxed kit." In order to better answer the question one must first have a firm understanding of the goal of the tool manufacturer, that is presumably to maximize overall sales (note, I did NOT say maximize sales of "boxed kits") and profits. The second part of the question has to do with an understanding of your intended customers. Ed stated that these folks are mini/midi lathe owners and since they are possibly considering a boxed set that they do not already have any turning tools. A further conclusion can be that these folks are beginners at turning. Yet a further conclusion is that most of these mini/midi lathe owners are on a budget, whether by necessity or by choice. The "boxed kits" that have be been proposed thus far contain 6-8 turning tools. Since one of Ed's caveats is that these tools are good quality steel, a 6-8 tool kit can range in price between $200 to $400 (not including the Harbor Freight 8 piece set of HS lumps of metal stuffed into holes in the ends of small branches that sells for ~$60). A hefty, if not prohibitive, sum for most mini/midi lathe owners. The price of these "boxed sets" will automatically limit the volume of sales...counter to the tool manufacturer's goal.

I've have been known at times to be somewhat of a dissident, so let me propose that we think outside of the "box," pun intended. The ideal would be to sell the tools individually to accommodate the specific needs of the individual turners, however Ed's caveat, my words not his, is that selling the tools individually is not in the current corporate culture so we need to come up with a scheme that is attractive to the customer, enough so that he is willing to purchase a "boxed kit." Thus far all of the responses seem to be aimed at a "boxed kit" that will satisfy the needs of all turners, that is turners who wish to make bowls, AND turners who wish to turn spindles, AND turners who want to make pens, AND etc. The greater the number fields of turning you wish accommodate, the greater the number of tools you would have to bundle into your "boxed kit," thus the higher the price and thus lower the volume of sales. Not the goal!

Question, for a turner who wishes to start off by turning only bowls or boxes, of what value is a skew, spindle roughing gouge, or a spindle gouge to him that you propose to put into the "boxed kit?" Same type of question, of what value are most of the proposed tools to the fellow that wants to do pens exclusively? Point is that different fields of turning are best accomplished with different set of tools. You do the turner a disservice by selling him tools that he does not need and trying to force him to pay more than he wants to. With this tactic by the tool manufacturer the risk is high that the intended customer will turn to another manufacturer that gives him a "better deal." A tool manufacturer must take the long range approach that if they provide the needs of the customer at a modest price and builds a positive rapport with the customer, he will come back to them when he is in the market to purchase additional tools as he expands his turning interests over time.

Okay, where is this all leading? If I were given the stated assignment, considering all of the above background and reasoning, my recommendation to management for maximizing total sales and set the stage for future sales would be to establish "boxed kits" that caters to the following groups of novice turners which contain the minimum number of tools to accomplish to desired tasks at a modest cost per kit. Thus I would propose the following:

Bowl and Box Maker's Kit:

3/8" fingernail bowl gouge

1/8" parting tool

1" or 1-1/4" heavy duty bowl scraper

Box scraper (can also serve as a square nosed scraper)

An instructional DVD on bowl and box making (contract a well known turner to make exclusive DVD)

Spindle and Faceplate Maker's kit:

3/4" spindle roughing gouge

1/8" parting tool

Shallow spindle gouge

1" skew, radius ground, (rectangular cross-section, NOT oval)

Instructional DVD on spindle and faceplate turning.

Pen Maker's Kit:

1/2" shallow spindle gouge

1/4" round nose scraper

Instructional DVD

For those who still insist on the mega number of tool kits, Ed Moore would be glad to give you his credit card number, that is, to all except to Mike Stafford.

If you were able to stay awake throughout this rambling post, please let me know how you did it so that I can learn to do the same.

Thanks, Peter Toch

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#20

Peter, your approach just ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

might optimize sales.

I am glad that my question has generated some mental gymnastics on your part. If nothing else, you have shown that there are more parameters than I listed originally - and, that this is not a simple problem.

Ed

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#21

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Mike Stafford

That is certainly an interesting list of tools Peter. I have never used a bowl gouge while turning boxes. I hollow with a spindle or detail gouge my preference being a bluntly ground Thompson 1/2" detail gouge.

One of the reasons I find these forums so interesting is that I learn so much from them. Obviously there is more than one way to skin every cat or turn every box.

I have enjoyed seeing the responses.

Even if Ed was buying the tools I would be afraid to put them in my shop after my wife's question the other night... When woman questions man's toys it is time to go to the jewelry store.....

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#22

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Peter Toch

Hi Mike:

If you speak kindly about Ed, he may even cover the trip to jewelery store. Let us know how you make out?

Peter

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#23

Ken Vaughan

What the answer might be for mobility impaired

Ken Vaughan

If you were to be specific to those with limited mobility --

It probably looks more like

Hunter #3 with the 3/8 shank to fit the handle below

Easy tools Midi rougher and finisher 3/8 by 7 shiz unhandled

1/16 thin parting tool

5/8 spindle roughing gouge - with full round shank (or similar size) with removable handle 12 inch

Maybe a second handle

Why --

If you sit at the lathe and at the grinder, you will need to have shorter handles and better at the grinder -- no handles.

Try sitting on a stool and grinding a long handle tool without leaving the stool. Yup, it can be done, but not easily or comfortably.

If you are sitting while turning, you are using upper body and long handles are almost always in the way --- and the interchangable handles let you "choke up" when needed.

Just a different perspective that commonly is not seen by many.....

3/8 gouges (v bowl gouge, spindle gouge, detail gouge) in a 12 inch removable handle (one handle for the three gouges

that is a

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#24

Re: Peter, your approach just ...

Peter Toch

Hi Ed:

The mental gymnastics, as you put it, was done many years ago and over a period of years. I guess my background as a scientist and engineering manager responsible for the development of new products was helpful to me in objectively observing the purchasing habits and thought processes of customers. One of the most valuable lessons learned was to "listen to the voice of the customer." What is it that the customer wants and is willing to pay for. Many times products fail in the marketplace because they either do not satisfy the needs of the customer or the customer finds a solution to his problem that is better and/or cheaper. I applied these same lessons when I became involved in the retail sales of tools. I was always opposed to the "boxed set" of turning tools, for the reasons I previously stated, and when a customer was looking to buy tools I would first ask them what it was they wanted to accomplish. Then I would direct them toward the highest quality individual tools they could afford, or be willing to pay for, that were best suited for the work they wanted to do. This usually resulted in the purchasing of only 2-4 "good" tools that would serve them well. This built a personal relationship in that most customers who I advised in this manner would not purchase additional tools as their skills developed until they first conferred with me. I simply applied my past experiences to respond to your question. It's not really that complex a problem when broken down to answer the goals which must first be well defined.

Peter Toch

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

#25

Mike Stafford

Re: Let's suppose that we work for ...

Mike Stafford

Peter, I think that Ed is the reason for my wife's concern about the number of tools I have. I have been reflecting on why she made her statement when she was in the shop and it dawned on me that recently Ed wrote and told me about a truckload of tools that he received. In that note he mentioned that his wife was somewhat upset with the size of his tool budget. I read this note to my wife and we had a good laugh. I fear the seed was planted and she is now critically assessing my tool collection.....

Ed is a bad influence when it comes to tool buying. :b There is an old expression, "You can never be too thin or too rich." It is possible our wives might think you can have too many tools..... :D