Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Turning Education Survey

Posts

Turning Education Survey

#1

Steven Antonucci

Turning Education Survey

steven antonucci

So I was thinking with all of the recent discussions on safety, how do we learn to turn? Where do we pick up the right way to do things? How do we learn to turn in general?

I have personally read dozens of books.

I have attended dozens of demos.

I have 10000 hours or more at the lathe.

I have taken one class.

I have taught probably 10 classes.

I read and post on several forums.

So the question is: How did you get to where you are today? Which things do you think have had the quickest returns? Which ones have had the best long term return?

Feel free to extend the list.

Steve

Re: Turning Education Survey

#2

Re: Turning Education Survey

John Lucas

Steve I learned by books and magazines and stuggled. When I moved to cookeville I met Joe Looper who had studied under a lot of the greats when they were at the Craft Center. He helped me a lot. then I found the local club and the AAW. Watching the Demo's helped tremendously. I didn't attend a symposium for a long time because they were too expensive but when they started having the mini symposiums I was able to attend and learn more.

I've only taken maybe 3 classes and that was after I was actually teaching them myself.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#3

Re: Turning Education Survey

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

I learned mostly by Trial and Error. I got the very basics from two videos and went from there. The Del Stubbs video and one of the Raffin vids. I have no idea how many hours I have spent on the lathe, but it is way more than 1000 but less than 10,000. I have only been turning for 9 years.

A HUGE learning resource was Badger Pond (web site) and now Wood Central. These two sites are incredible resources.

I have never taken a class, but have taught several people the basics of how to turn.

I have a dozen or so books on turning that I have read and which have helped immensely.

Interesting idea for a topic!!

Mike

Ready for the weekend and turning time in Apex, NC!!

Re: Turning Education Survey

#4

Re: Turning Education Survey

Stuart Johnson

Without a doubt my greatest education has come from WoodCentral. I try to read every post and usually get something out of every topic. Sometime what I get is bewilderment, sometimes disgust but usually a small light bulb comes on and gets filed away. I wish we had a better search function so finding those bits of wisdom weren't hidden so deep.

The next thing is the abundance of videos available. For segmented turning Malcolm Tibbetts leads the pack followed by Curt Theobald. Bill Grumbine, Mike Mahoney and Jimmy Clewes along with others have all taught me so much. Now there is YouTube. Even the bad and dangerous videos make good teaching tools when we have WC to discuss them.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#5

Re: Turning Education Survey

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

Started by visiting WC as my first source of turning knowledge in ~2002. Quickly joined one of the biggest and best clubs in the USA. Attended and volunteered at Louisville in year three. Taken two classes at Arrowmont and three put on by the demonstrators of our club. Went to Five Barns 2008 and FBarns Lite last fall. Attended 3 symposiums in FL, one in VA, two in Greensboro, NC, one at each GA, visited other clubs in TN and Charlotte. All of these have been valuable to my turning life. I now visit WC first, then SMC, AAW, Woodworker's Resource. Woodturning Online, and NC Woodworkers.

Sometimes a demo will yield only a fifteen second new tip, but that still makes it worthwhile. We get Woodturning Design, AAW mag, British Woodturning, Fred Holder's mag. I never had a school shop class, made my living for over forty years as an industrial maintenance mechanic.

Attended a symposium demo several years ago (Louisville?) done by a medical doctor. It showed VERY gory pictures of turning accidents. It should be REQUIRED ATTENDANCE FOR ALL WOODWORKERS!

Re: Turning Education Survey

#6

JL

Re: Turning Education Survey

JL

Books - probably a half dozen or so.

Classes

Five Saturday classes with Nick Cook.

Two weekend classes at Highland Hardware

Symposiums/Demos

John Jordan demo

Terry Daniels "Gathering" a few years back

Hours turning- who the heck knows.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#7

Re: Turning Education Survey

Wally Dickerman in Arizona

I started turning in 1936 at age 15 and didn't meet another turner until 1983. During that time I had no instruction because I didn't know where to find any. There were no classes, clubs, very few books and none on bowl turning until I got Dale Nish's first book in about 1980.

I have never taken a class

I have no idea how many hours of turning I have. A lot in over 70 years of turning.

I have attended at least 10 AAW symposiums and several at Provo.

I have demo'd at Provo, AAW and at quite a few clubs on the West Coast

I Have taught nearly 500 students in over 20 years of teaching. It's interesting how much I learn myself while teaching.

Since I was brought reluctantly into the computer world I have been addicted to several web sites such as WC, WoW, SMC and Badger Pond. I am continually learning just about every time I visit.

What a wonderful lifetime hobby woodturning has been!!

Re: Turning Education Survey

#8

Re: Turning Education Survey

Don at Central Illinois

Mentor, W. Keith Adams, Decatur, IL; DVD's & books from Santa; Ellsworth demo, John Jordan demo and hands on class; plenty of trial and error.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#9

Re: Turning Education Survey

Bill Howatt

Self taught for a few years then joined a club. Learned a lot from demos and club activities - more than I would have thought since I had been turning a while.

Badger Pond/WoodCentral and other forums have added tremendously to my knowlege. I have seen only a couple of DVDs but I can't say they have added a whole lot to my knowlege compared to the club and forums. Possibly because they tend to be one person's opinion.

I have taken a couple of short courses which were also quite beneficial - having an instructor right there to show you personally how and explain why in an environment that is more conducive to learning than a demo.

The safety issue is compounded because there are relatively few turners compared to tablesaw users so accidents aren't heard about as in general gossip as the neighbour who cut his finger off. Lathes look very safe compared to a tablesaw with an exposed blade and nobody really thinks a chunk of wood can kill you.

Bill

Re: Turning Education Survey

#10

Dick Hines

Re: Turning Education Survey

Dick Hines

I turned in high school just after the pole lathes went out of style. My father had a lathe in his shop that I played around with some.

Read a lot of books and watched demos and took on class last fall. other than that I tell every one I learned for the blood letting method.

The more blood I lost the more I learned.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#11

Re: Turning Education Survey

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

BOY, ARE YOU OLD!

Re: Turning Education Survey

#12

Mike Stafford

Re: Turning Education Survey

Mike Stafford

Just as I figured most of the respondees so far in this thread have far more experience than I do.

I started turning by accident and I am primarily self taught having the misfortune of a bad teacher and a not too bright student.

I learned from books. I bought books on subjects that I was interested in and went home and tried to learn how to do it. No doubt the biggest mistake of my turning career was my failure to join a turning club or get some good turning instruction.

I actually taught classes on how to turn boxes before I ever saw anyone turn a box. The first person I ever saw turn a box was one of my students until I saw demos at the Richmond symposium.

My skills are still limited in certain areas of the craft as I continue to play catchup. I feel reasonably confident in my ability to turn bowls and platters having had good instruction in those areas from Jamie Donaldson, Frank Penta, Alan Leland and Nick Cook. During my one day session with Nick Cook I made great progress on bowl gouge techniques thanks to his one-on-one instruction. Having been in a class with my buddy Ed Moore was also instrumental in my skill development. Ed was also kind enough to offer suggestions through e-mails about my design and execution flaws. Mike Schwing also corresponded with me back in the beginning and was kind enough to offer constructive criticism. Thanks to the aforementioned I improved my skills and the appearance of my work. Almost forgot, Pam Reilly also corresponded with me and helped me quite a bit.

I am sure experienced skilled turners must shudder when they see me turn because of how I do things. I continue to learn and like to think I am getting better. I have good analytical skills and can listen and follow directions so when other turners who I respect offer advice I do try to implement what they are teaching.

I have attended a few dozen demos and although I enjoy them immensely I don't know that they are the best teaching venue for me as I find it difficult to see the hand placement and tool manipulation nuances that I think make the difference between an average turner and a great turner. In the classes I have attended with the gentlemen I mentioned these nuances were demonstrated and practiced under their watchful eye.

I think books are helpful and so may be demos. But for me the instruction of a good teacher or the viewing of a well done video has done for my skill improvement than anything else.

If I had it to do over again I would have taken a one week basic turning class with Alan Leland and then take the same classes I have taken from Jamie, Ed and Frank. All of these gentlemen are fabulous teachers. I don't think any beginning turner can go wrong with good basic instruction.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#13

Re: Turning Education Survey

Terry Fox

I got lucky! I decided to turn wood like my Dad so I bought a lathe and some cheap tools, then looked for a local class. I signed up for a weekend with some guy in Quakertown - I'd never heard of him - name of David Ellsworth. That was all I needed! Talk about a good start

One AAA symposium (Richmond) and one Totally Turning, attending all possible demos. I learned something from each one of them, even if it was that I had no interest in doing whatever it was that was being demo'd.

One week at John C. Campbell Craft School.

Demos and 'Show and Tells' at my local club.

15 to 20 hours per week on the lathe for the last five or six years.

A daily fix of wit, wisdom and inspiration from WoodCentral - priceless!

My goal - to do in a year what Terry Scott does in a week.

Thanks to all of you.

Terry Fox

Re: Turning Education Survey

#14

Thanks Mike!!

Jorge Casta�eda

Mike,

You were my first bowl turning teacher in a gathering at 5 barns, thank you!!

You and another fellow, which name I don't remember also thought me how to sharpen a bowl gouge. That was 817 pieces ago!! Thanks again.

The following year I took a class from Bill Grumbine. The only book I've read is Richard Raffan's and a few dvd's.

Most of my learning has been by doing and greatly improved by watching others in our club meetings and in turners gatherings.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#15

Re: Turning Education Survey

Chris Hoehle

I got started woodturning almost 3 years ago at Red Rocks Community College in Lakewood (Denver) CO. The college has an outstanding fine woodworking and lutherie program including 3 semesters of woodturning. The second semester dealt mostly with natural edge bowls and hollow forms and I enjoyed it so much I took it twice so I got in 4 semesters total.

All of my instructors at Red Rocks were great and I definitely learned a lot from all of them (Sean Gillespie, Mark Malek, and Mark Duvall), but Mark Malek deserves special mention for his ability to very clearly describe and demo good gouge control and cutting techniques. Mark also continually stressed the importance of good design and got many of us over the hurdle of those first couple "dog dish" bowls and on to better designs featuring flowing curves and graceful ogees. One thing he was always saying that has stuck with me was something along the lines of "don't be one of those woodturners who falls in love with the wood, stops cutting too soon and sacrifices a good design to keep some detail like a bit of figure or burl; fall in love with form instead and make creating a good form your primary goal even if it means cutting away the figure etc. that you really liked." In other words, if the form wasn't pleasing, it didn't matter how pretty the wood was. He also encouraged us to keep sketchbooks and try out our ideas in poplar or something similar first, and he was a proponent of cutting hollow forms and boxes in half to see how things looked inside.

I don't think I realized at first just how fortunate I was to be receiving such good instruction right off the bat, but since then (and/or concurrently) I've been to the 2009 and 2010 Rocky Mountain Woodturning Symposia, and I got to go to Anderson Ranch last summer for a week with Christian Burchard, and the solid foundation I received at Red Rocks has really helped me to get the most out of these other educational opportunities.

The week with Christian at Anderson Ranch was everything I had hoped it would be. He brought some Madrone for us to play with and expanded my creative horizons with bleaching, burning, carving, and warping, and all kinds of crazy fun things! I really can't say enough good things about both the top-notch facility at the Ranch- it would be hard to not be inspired there. The symposia were great too for being exposed to a lot of cool new ideas. It was really fun to meet David Marks last year after having seen him on DIY woodworks, and I'll be incorporating some gilding and patinas into my work soon thanks to his demos.

I've also gotten a lot out of joining Front Range Woodturners and seeing the demos, visiting other woodturner's workspaces during the shop tours, and checking out materials from our extensive library.

Sorry if this got a little long, but I am a big believer in the value of taking classes. On some of the forums, when the topic of what lathe to buy comes up, there is usually a posting along the lines of "Buy the Jet/Nova instead of the Powermatic and use the difference to pay for a week at Anderson Ranch or Arrowmont" and I wholeheartedly agree with this sentiment. In fact, up until now, I've only had a Rikon mini lathe at home and have spent my extra $$ on education instead, and I think that has been the way to go. (Though of course, because of the college I had access to Vicmarc and Woodfast lathes so that made having the mini at home a little easier to work around).

Re: Turning Education Survey

#16

I often suggest that a potential turner .....

JamieDonaldson

...take a class such as are offered at the Folk School before they buy anything turning related. This experience will either suck them into the vortex or show them that they should be potters. Many of us had some exposure in school shop classes, an opportunity seldom available in school systems today. Hands on classes are by far the most efficient learning opportunities, and I was fortunate to be able to study with many top turners as I was beginning to turn 25 yrs. ago. Teaching is most often also a learning experience for an instructor, and closely held information has no value.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#17

Re: Turning Education Survey

Bernie Weishapl

Pretty much self taught. Have a few books and lot of DVD's. I learn better if I can see a process rather than read it. I wish I had a club close but don't. I have been to two symposiums and the last was in Richmond, Va. I learn a lot at each one of the demo's.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#18

Steven Antonucci

Ranking my personal learning

steven antonucci

I bought a bunch of books that all seemed to describe the same thing, but it didn't sink in...

I read a bunch online and it was still unclear.

I took a class with a well known turner, and it began to click. And I was an "advanced turner" at that point...or so I thought! (probably an intermediate in my current nomenclature)

I really started to learn when I started teaching. Someone asked me how I did something at a class I was teaching in my shop, and I couldn't answer him. I could do it, but I didn't really know why. Knowing why and how was when it all came together.

I have seen lots of demos. Dozens. I no longer go for why or how, but to see how others teach and how their information is processed by the audience. If I can understand when something isn't clear, I probably know how to do it and why it works!

I can honestly say that I am still learning things every time I attend a demo, read a post/book, or teach a class. That's what makes it fun.

Steve

Re: Turning Education Survey

#19

Re: Turning Education Survey

Mike Foster

Started learning by the school of hard knocks. Got tired of chasing my dancing Shopsmith around the shop and decided to take a class. Spent a weekend with Russ Zimmerman when I was still a rank beginner (I still have the piece I made with him). I read several turning books to help increase my knowledge

.

I then moved to Phoenix and joined the local club. Went to an all day demo by Richard Raffan. It was perfect timing because at the time I was in a residency program and I found that the perfect antidote to a stressful day at the hospital was to come home a turn a box. I turned a lot of boxes that year.

Moved to the 4 corners region and acquired a long-bed Woodfast with riser blocks. Turned my first segmented piece from plans in Wood magazine. Did an extensive search on segmented turning, and really came up with just a couple of articles on the process. One by Ray Allen, the other by a couple but I can't remember their names. I did a lot of figuring out of the process on my own as there just wasn't a Malcolm Tibbets book to be had. I attended my first AAW symposium when it was in Fort Collins, CO. Comparing that symposium to the last one in Hartford is like night and day.

Since then I have attended a number of symposia for the comradarie, and I find that I always learn something. Even if it a little tidbit.

I think there is something to say for Malcolm Gladwell's concept of 10,000 hours. He believes it takes that long at doing something till you become a master (read the book Outliers, it is really a great read).

I also think Steve and others here are right about teaching. I have not had the time to do formal teaching, but have taught several friends and acquaintances how to turn and it makes me think about why I do something that is automatic. converting it from the action to thought is a teaching experience on it's own. I have not really done demo's, as I have a mild case of stage fright and don't really feel comfortable in front of a large group. I imagine that doing demo's would be a good way to learn as well.

Mike

Re: Turning Education Survey

#20

Steven Antonucci

Good point on demos

steven antonucci

I've done a lot of demos for my two clubs and I remember the first one (head down focused on getting the project done in an hour while answering questions: FAIL)

A demo forces you to think back through your own experiences and what questions you needed answered to get to where you are. It focuses you on clarifying what is needed to complete a process, or even more so, the process itself. I am always amazed at the questions that come up that I didn't think of, and even though I usually can answer them, I typically ask the person WHY they asked it.

My best learning experiences are always from a broad perspective.

Steve

Re: Turning Education Survey

#21

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Turning Education Survey

Katherine Kowalski

I'm surprised by the responses in this thread. My experience has been fairly different from others, so I'd like to relate it here:

The same month I bought my first lathe, I took a class from an "experienced" local turner... someone, (who I now recognize) knew zero technique, and communicated same. Discouraging.

Luckily I took a second class a couple months later with Allan Batty, and the experience was eye-opening and inspiring. Within six months of beginning turning, I was able to quit my job and become a full-time turner.

Later I took a two-day class and five-day class with Cindy Drozda, three days with Stuart Batty, a day with Stuart Mortimer, and then three days with Jimmy Clewes. After learning diligently from these most excellent turners, I have a full arsenal of technique at my disposal, and am able to turn anything I can imagine.

As to artistic inspiration, form, etc., my life has always been focused on art of all types, most especially indigenous folk arts of various cultures. However, I knew nothing about "good form" in turning/pottery/etc. until I came to woodturning. The easiest way to learn about good form, I found, was to "learn by osmosis" in a manner of speaking. Having objects of excellent form in my home, which I see 15 times a day as I pass by them, serves as an almost visual mantra; a subconscious intake of information.

(I have a small collection of Cindy's work -- she can make some gorgeous curves! Other woodturnings from various artists also add to this effect.)

This constant exposure to 3-dimensional art forms has given me the ability to recognize aesthetically-pleasing proportions and create same on my work. (Seeing pictures in a book is not the same). (In way, it is a philosophy of "you are what you eat..." "You become what is around you.")

I too have seen many many demonstrations, and the value of attending a club meeting and symposia cannot be overrated! I also enjoy seeing the various DVDs that turners produce. Teaching and demonstrating has also increased my turning knowledge, and honed my ability to communicate to others the technical aspects of woodturning.

My Conclusion: Taking a class from a professional woodturner is probably the best gift you can give yourself. (Be careful about spending money on lessons from less-known people -- sometimes it's hard to distinguish admiration of the person's character from turning ability. Pros are celebrated for a reason -- they're very experienced and excellent at their chosen craft.) I agree with Chris -- the investment in education is worth more than a lathe.

When you do decide to take a class -- one note of advice: Pay attention. Take copious notes. Listen to the instructor. Even if you don't always agree with what the person is saying -- take in their point of view, and your landscape of turning technique will be richer.

Careful observation of their techniques will advance you in turning MUCH faster than simple dogged practice, trying to learn on your own. (There's no need to re-invent the wheel!)

My thoughts,

Katherine

Re: Turning Education Survey

#22

Re: Thanks Mike!!

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Jorge,

I remember working with you at the lathe at Bill's picnic, but I did not remember that it was your first time. Wow. When I look at the great pieces you have posted, I am very flattered that you consider me a teacher and more than a little humbled that I helped you along the way.

I hope all is well in Maine, we are getting a nice spring shower here today.

Take care,

Mike

Re: Turning Education Survey

#23

Re: Thanks Mike!!

Jorge Casta�eda

Mike,

It was a day of firsts, I was proficient with the skew already, but it was my first witnessing of how to make a bowl! My brand spanking new bowl gouge from Hamlet, came with a square end and grinding it to a fingernail shape was a project in itself that another fellow kindly showed me how, and of course I saw Bill Grumbine turn quite fast, too fast for me to digest, a big yellow wood bowl earlier, but seeing you working in the small lathe was really my first bowl experience, at a pace I could grasp... so I luck out with a good teacher!! ;o)

And of course WoodCentral has been and it is my main source.

Thanks WoodCentral!!

Re: Turning Education Survey

#24

Barb Siddiqui

Re: Turning Education Survey

Barb Siddiqui

Personally, I've been limited to book learning with very few mentors. Initially, it was Dave Smith of Vancouver WA who put lathe tools in my hand and instructed me how to turn an egg cup. Granted, he did most of it for me because I was so inept, but the demonstration was thorough and the final product encouraging. He is a good teacher and I wish he lived closer. Other than Dave, I spent a weekend with Russ Fairfield, and it was priceless. At home, I've watched several DVDs, but never seen a symposium demonstration. Pretty isolated, I guess. No club anywhere near me. Wood Central has been a prime source of information for questions and guidance.The 'Tool Grinds' page has been a bonus I refer to often.

The conclusion is, learning is a process that can be approached from many angles, but one-on-one mentoring is obviously the best. There is just no substitute for being 'shown' in person, and being able to ask questions on the spot.

Re: Turning Education Survey

#25

Keith Tompkins

Re: Turning Education Survey

keith tompkins

Hey Steve, sorry I missed you this weekend!Just got home from teaching my first class at Peter's Valley in New Jersey. I learned to turn in high school. I had two good teachers. I worked in a cabinet shop, and learned some bad habits from the old-timers there. (They finished their cove cuts with a file, for example).I spent 9 years at that place, till I moved on. I've been responsible for training all new employees at several shops. As a self-employed furniture maker, I did lots of custom lathe work, including all the turning for other local custom shops that didn't turn. My biggest clients were architects and designers, all work was done to their specs. I lived and worked in two craft villages, got to know many craftspeople in all fields. I read a lot....I have almost every FineWoodworking mag. from the first year until the mid 80's. I began turning seriously in the late 90's, and did my first demo at the national level in 2004. This year will be my fourth time as a presenter (panel discussion) at that level. I've attended only one formal class...with David Ellsworth. Just because I wanted to. I've either demo'd or taught in about 20 states, and will be doing several new ones this year, including Hawaii :) I've taught at Brookfield craft center for 7 or 8 years on a regular basis. I am a certified industrial instructor for N.Y. state.