Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

If you sell to woodworkers, your customers are already here

WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

Posts

WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#1

WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

Ed Moore in SW VA

Another tragic accident at the lathe should have us begin by praying for and wishing Joan Kelly a rapid and complete recovery. I do not know this lady, but a valued friend, Emmett Manley, speaks very highly of her.

In answer to the subject question I am aware of two possible answers.

1. Lathe speed! The rotational speed of the lathe exceeds some critical value and the centrifugal force generated by this rotational speed is greater than the force holding the piece together. Unseen defects may be the culprit here.

2. The bowl has been shaped on the outside and then is shaped on the inside. The removal of the material inside the bowl relieves some of the stresses and the bowl is able to warp. A place that wasn't a high spot a few moments ago becomes a new high spot. The turner decides to clean up a place on the inside of the bowl near the rim using a shear scrape with the bowl gouge. The high spot is grabbed by the bowl gouge and disaster occurs. One of the best demonstrators I have seen stresses that one should NEVER shear scrape the rim of the inside of a bowl after the mass of material has been removed. Sanding becomes the only option to remove the offending defect at this stage of the game.

QUESTION: What other things can cause a bowl to blow up?

Ed

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#2

Re: WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

Doug Thompson near Cleveland

I'm sorry to read this news...

The latest trend is SPEED... almost a sense of pride to see who could turn at the fastest RPM's. It's safe until the wood has a crack then boom. Slower speeds take a bit longer to turn but it's safe.

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#3

Re: WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

john lucas

Ed Most of the people that I have known that have been hurt by a bowl blowing up, are experienced turners. Sometimes very experienced. I suspect an awful lot of it is simply turning at higher speeds as we all do after wet really comfortable with out tools. Wood can have hidden defects. My close call came on a piece that appeared to be very solid. I had turned the outside and was hollowing the inside. It was still quite thick, maybe 3/4 to an inch. I did not get a catch and was not even taking a deep cut. All of the sudden there was nothing left on the lathe and a pretty substantial dent was left in my Jointer stand which is very heavy steel. Had I been standing in line with it I probably would have been hit.

As far as shear scraping on the inside. I've done that many many times. If the bowl has started to warp you can't do it but as long as it's running true you can. I don't know what happened the other night other than the Bradford Pear either being too fragile or possibly having a hidden check.

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#4

Re: WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

woodspinner-Harry robinette

Ed

Relieving stress in the wood, I know everyone says this but what happens. The way it was explained to me

was: The wood as we know cracks when it wants,the wood also grows in stress as we know from flat work that is air dried,it well twist,crack,bend and bow as soon as you cut it. It's the same with turning we relieve the stress and bang it blows up. Hope this helps or at less makes sense.

I've had bowls that looked perfect slit and fall off the lathe as soon as I started to cut,and I've had them go till they were almost finished and bang. Speed is still always a problem.

As always just my $.02

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#5

Re: WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

robo hippy

I can't say that I have ever had one blow up from anything except a catch, except for one time. I had a piece of madrone that had some nice color lines in it, the kind that radiate out from the center, but don't follow the growth lines. Well, there was a crack in one of those color lines, and the bowl blank came apart at about 1500 rpm. About 40% of it went into the wall, and the rest bounced on the ways a few times and took off in the opposite direction. I have learned to stand out of the line of fire from the practice of turning sloppy wet wood.

As far as shear cuts with a scraper, I do it all the time. On larger bowls, I do it in stages, on smaller ones, I do it from center to rim some times. I will never use a scraper flat on the tool rest to clean up the inside rim of a bowl.

The only woods I turn at high speeds are ones that I have checked closely for checking. Never if there is any bark. Never if there is any rot or punky wood.

robo hippy

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#6

Re: WHY?  Pushing the limits

Steve Criscenzo

I spend a good part of my time doing safety training and unfortunately root cause analysis to determine the cause of an incident. Very often the person had the proper safety equipment and did not use it or use it properly. More common, the person usually knew (or at least had a feeling ) that am operation was not safe and elected to do it anyway.

Often the victim is experienced and was hurt not due to complaintancy but due to their comfort in pushing the limits.

The more experienced we get the more we push. We turn larger items at higher speeds. We turn off center and out of balance. We strive to make the wall just a little bit thinner or the finish a bit smoother.

When I do a daily brief I leave me crews with these questions. Have I identified the hazards. Have I taken the steps to minimize the hazards. Am I comfortable with the task at hand. And then the most basic of rules. If things change stop and reevaluate and if in doubt STOP.

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#7

Re: WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

George Van Beynen

I had a spalted maple bowl blow up last year. A bug had bored a hole throug the side and tenon and centrifugal force pulled the bowl apart. I could not see evidence of the damage until the bowl separated.

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#8

Dick Hines

Re: WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

Dick Hines

Unseen cracks from unknown damage to the tree can be a real problem. Everyting is going just great until the bowl get thin enough to expose the crack and bamm!

In the last year or so I have started to turn at faster speeds. When I did I started to wear my face mask. I keep it hanging on the tail stock so I don't forget to put it on.

I feel safe turning hollow forms with out a mask but I guess it would be a good idea to use it then also

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#9

Steven Antonucci

Physics of the system and strength of materials

steven antonucci

When a bowl is spinning, there is a force pushing radially outward. Across the grain is never a problem, but along the grain is short grain on the end grain. As we get thinner and thinner, the force required to separate that bond becomes pretty small.

When you apply a tool to that spinning wood, you are applying a force in the direction that will go across that grain. That force varies as the wood flexes away as it gets thinner. Some woods flex substanitially across the grain vs along the grain. This sets up harmonics in the wood (aka... that pattern in the top of the bowl that you can't sand out). Push to hard, and you can violate the mechanical properties of the wood.

I see people making the same sized cuts with the same unsharpened tools at the rim like they were still roughing wood from the blank all of the time. Most bowl failures occur because the turner tried to cut too much wood for the situation at hand. Smaller cuts can be achieved by slowing down the lathe or just reducing the edge that you engage.

When I demo cutting a bowl, I typically cut the inside one handed to illustrate "the pace" of the cut. My mantra is that there is "No penalty for going slowly".

My 2 cents

S

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#10

Me too, George

Adrien

Rough turning a twelve inch diameter bowl. Got it down to about one and a half inches thick and suddenly one half went behind me into the wall and the other through the window, out about forty feet into the yard. I keep the half in the yard as a reminder. The window got replaced. Apparently there was a hidden crack in the wood.

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#11

O'Tool's Law is most often the culprit......

JamieDonaldson

..in any bad situation, and O'Tool is the guy who thought Murphy was an optimist. Murphy's Law is basically stated that if something can go wrong it will, but O'Tool Law states that something has already gone wrong but you just don't know it yet! That's the one I live by! :D

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#12

"Murphy was an optimist"

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

I thought that was Cohen's Corollary :D

[Have to jot down O'Tool, though, as he/she may just have it dialed in. ;) ]

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#13

Re: WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

robo hippy

The Oregon coastal Myrtle wood turners prefer to turn their bowls at very high rpm. One master, not retired preferred about 4,000 rpm. He said that Myrtle was able to flex, and has the elasticity to take the strains of that kind of speed, but that most other woods were not able to stand it. They used the Big Ugly tool, which was similar to the carbide tipped tools now available (3/4 inch bar stock with tantung steel silver soldered onto each end of the tool, and sharpenable on standard grinders). So, it can be done safely. I guess the decision is the proverbial "professional driver on closed course, DO NOT ATTEMPT" situation. Maybe more properly said, know your limits.

Like Steve, on finish cuts on the inside, I do turn it out with no left hand pressure. This allows you to 'feel' the wood. I also use this on the outside a lot. The handle hand is the throttle, controlling the amount being taken off, and the left or other hand just holds the tool on the tool rest, which isn't much of a job since the pressure of the spinning wood does that just fine. I guess a secondary job for the left hand is to keep the tool from going off the end of your tool rest, or past center on the inside of the bowl (brakes if you will). You steer by moving/pivoting your body. I seldom have my hand on the tool rest except during roughing.

robo hippy

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#14

Re: WHY?  Why do bowls blow up?

Peter Toch

Ed has posed one his typical taunting open ended questions, such is the nature of a good teacher to get one to think. Unfortunately, there are too many reasons/variables that may cause a bowl to blow up on the lathe. I don't know of any matrix that could be constructed that will give you a definitive answer as to whether a particular piece a wood is going blow up or not when turned under a given set of conditions. This is where experience and caution must come in. It's usually the unseen defects or unexpected events such a catch that cause the problems. In short, we as turners always put ourselves at some degree of risk every time we turn on the lathe. Like driving a car, one must approach turning defensively. If one is turning a piece and standing in front of the lathe (in the plane on the centrifugal force) then one would be foolish, no actually stupid, not to wear a good quality face shield. Note the emphasis on good quality face shield. Just one trip to the ER will cost you the price of many good quality face shields, plus the pain of getting your face rearranged. Turning always has it's risks, but you can minimize the probability of getting hurt by following the safe practices of turning which can be found in many places and forums. Always think before you start your lathe and carefully look for anything that looks, feels, or even sounds out of the ordinary. An old woodworking friend of mine told me something many years ago, "woodworking tools are extremely patient, they will wait years to get you!" The more you think and practice safety, the better your chances of beating the odds.

Peter

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#15

Peter- I like that example you stated....

JamieDonaldson

..about tools lying in wait to strike like a snake, as that is a really accurate truism. Many of us become complacent about safety concerns due to long term experience with those potential weapons. :(

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#16

Signs of trouble..

Carole Valentine

Yesterday I was working on shaping the outside of what was to be a winged hollow form. No hollowing at that point - had not even reversed it to put it in the chuck yet. I expect green wood to move, but this was fairly dry maple with no defects that I could see. Even though the wood was dry enough for the shavings to be very hot against my hand, it just would NOT stay round. Removed it from the lathe and upon closer inspection with a lens found that it had developed several almost invisible hairline cracks along the grain from the tenon to about half way up the vessel. Dripped a bit of thin CA on the side of the tenon and it wicked completely through to the other side in a crack that I could not even see. That piece is now in the burn barrel. If wood is behaving even slightly abnormally - unexpected movement, change in sound, etc. - stop and check it out.

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#17

Re: Signs of trouble..

robo hippy

I have never trusted super glue as a repair device. It can fill cracks, but does little to improve structural integrity.

robo hippy

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#18

Re: Signs of trouble..

Barry L Elder

I hope Ms Kelly recovers quickly. And as to why bowls blow up, sometimes I believe it's just that a particular piece of wood dislikes you! :b

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#19

Re: Signs of trouble..

Carole Valentine

I don't trust it as a repair either. I only used it out of curiosity to see how far it would wick in the crack...had already decided the wood was burn material. It wicked a LOT further than the crack was visible to my eye!

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#20

Re: Signs of trouble..

robo hippy

Carole,

I often use thin CA glue that way as well, to see how much of a crack is there. I do remember a story about some one that tried to reinforce a bark inclusion with CA glue and it still blew up on them.

robo hippy

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#21

Steven Antonucci

CA glue wicking opens another danger

steven antonucci

Violent agreement on CA being a repair, but CA gle that wicks into the crack that far also poses another danger- that you'll cut through the cured stuff down to stuff that isn't cured!

Having done this and then turning on the lathe without any eye protection, I can tell you that you don't want to experience a chemical burn on your eyeball. It is one of the most painful things I ever endured.

Good threads on safety!

S

Re: WHY? Why do bowls blow up?

#22

Brad Vietje

Cracks; High RPM; Catches; Poor Technique

Brad Vietje

I suspect most "explosions" come from unseen cracks (they can be all but invisible), excess speed, accidental catches, and poor technique. I've had accidents where I turned to look at something or responded to a loud sound, and that can be a real no-NO.

Some folks have used a tool inappropriately, or tried something new to make a cut they'd never made before.

Another huge source of operator error -- though not quite the same as a bowl blow-up -- is a poorly shaped tenon for scroll chuck jaws that allows a bowl to come right off the lathe. The same sort of thing can happen when a tenon is cut into wet sapwood, and the wood separates right at the base of the tenon. We should be careful to remember that green wood crushes somewhat, so the jaws have to be tightened every now and again.

Do be careful, folks -- accidents can happen to any of us.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT