Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Accidents: Statistically speaking

Posts

Accidents: Statistically speaking

#1

Steven Antonucci

Accidents: Statistically speaking

steven antonucci

With the posting of another lathe accident, I was wondering if there was any data on shop safety that was available to the general public?

For instance, does the average machine see more accidents as the experience of the person using it goes up because they get complacent?

What are the top machines that cause injuries? What are the top machines that cause fatalities? Statistically, is woodworking more dangerous than metalworking? Ceramics?

I'm just wondering if there is a correlation between the recent growth in woodturning, the expansion of information via the internet, and the number of accidents being reported- or has it always been 1 out of 1000, but we just never heard about it?

Thoughts?

Steve

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#2

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

Barry Irby

I don't have any statistics, but I have heard there are more Table Saw accidents than with any other tool. I suspect that is because there are more table saws in shops than other tools and they get more use than most other tools.

It would be interesting to know some facts. How many accidents per tool and a breakdown of hours of use and severity.

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#3

Re: Accidents: The Internet

George Guadiane

I don't have any facts to add, but YIKES, some of the stuff we have ssn on the internet scares the crap out of me.

And untrained, unsuspecting beginners could easily get badly hurt trying some of that stuff... The people making the videos are L U C K Y not to have been injured or killed with some of that junk.

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#4

Jointers and Table Saws are tops

Jorge Casta�eda

in accidents, but usually they just take a finger or a hand, not a life as the lathe does now and then. The band saw is supposed to be very safe, but I have witness several accidents in my boatyards days.

also the lowly utility knife with razor blades is a bit culprit. Carving tools as well.

I bet there are more, those are the ones I know of.

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#5

Keith Tompkins

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

keith tompkins

HI Steve, I have seen the stats on woodworking accidents. Injuries occur most commonly to two categories of woodworkers...beginners, and the most experienced. It's easy to explain the beginners, but possibly the most experienced just get complacent, or attempt procedures that most operators would never dream of doing. I believe the table saw is number one in operator injury, followed by the jointer. My feeling is many attempt to work alone on large items that requires an assistant. The jointer is surprising...with the proper guards in place, I consider it a very safe machine. You have to do something stupid to get hurt on a jointer... I witnessed a person lose their entire hand on a 20" jointer while attempting to mill a piece far too short... attempting to make a stop for a radial saw. Big shapers scare the hell out of me...with good reason. Don't laugh...a drill press will kill you too.

I just finished writing an article on bandsaw safety that I believe is far overdue. It should be published sometime in August. When I teach a turning class, it has reached the point where nobody except myself is allowed to operate the bandsaw unless they are under my direct supervision. I feel woodturning is growing rapidly, and is attracting many who have no woodworking experience at all, and little aptitude for operating, let alone setting up and maintaining a piece of equipment. If you cannot change a bandsaw blade, and properly tension, track, and adjust it, you shouldn't be operating the saw. There is a recent article in a turning mag. where the author is attempting to cut a slot on the bandsaw while the piece is hanging out the lathe chuck! How many people will now attempt the same thing? The current Fine Woodworking mag. COVER shows a guy cutting dovetails on the bandsaw with the guard fully raised. (yeah, they'll say it was raised for clarity). Where are these people learning this stuff? It's surprising there aren't MORE accidents.

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#6

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

woodspinner-Harry robinette

I think that everything stated so far is correct. I also see that woodworking and wood turning is the fastest

growing hobby in the USA and possibly the Industrial world.

You tube is nothing but accidents waiting to happen.

Beginners try to be pro's in a week,everyone knows everything if they watch a dvd or worst watch YOU TUBE .No one wants to put in the time,I have guys in my classes all the time trying to do things that I just started doing a couple years ago and ask them how long the been turning and the say proudly 3 months.

I try to teach them that TIME ON THE LATHE is what makes you a better turner and I mean years not 4 hours on Saturday for 3 months.I think all of us whom teach or demo or mentor or whatever should tell these new turners that it takes TIME to be a good turner not speed.

As always just my $.02.

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#7

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

Alan Trout

Having had a jointer accident I can attest that it is not as much complacency as doing something that I knew that I should not have been doing. I was jointing something way to short on a 12 euro jointer that I had to move the guard out of the way to do. I remember thinking as I was doing it that I really should not be doing this. All of a sudden the part chattered and kicked out. I lost a 1/2" off of my middle finger and peeled back the tissue to bone all the way back to my first knuckle on my index finger which of course severed that nerve. I know have two numb fingers needless to say.

I am very experienced in the shop as I was raised by a shop teacher and have been doing this all my life. Called my dad the next day and told him about the incident all he said was you dumb a** which I fully agreed with him.

By the way I was using the jointer the next day. A very hard lesson learned but I still get chills up my spine thinking how much worse it could have been.

Alan

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#8

Steven Antonucci

So far what seems to be consensus

steven antonucci

Bandsaws take a lot of fingers if you do something stupid, but they can be reattached.

Jointers take a lot of fingers if you do something stupid, but you can't reattach what's left of them.

Tablesaws cause the most accidents, but we haven't figured out why.

Lathes can kill you if you are standing in the wrong spot.

...

I can see someone being struck by a piece that got kicked back by a tablesaw if they were standing in the wrong spot, but aside from that, I can't really see another way?

The turners other mainstay is the chainsaw. Is it as deadly as the lathe? I know that logging is one of the most deadly professions that there is, but I wonder how many chainsaw accidents there are among turners? Dropping a tree on yourself will ruin your day.

S

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#9

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

Scott in Falcon

No statistics here, but a lot of good reading if you want to see what not to do:

http://www.woodworking.org/AccidentSurvey/search.htm

Scott

Re: Accidents: Statistically speaking

#10

Leo Cuellar

Re: So far what seems to be consensus

Leo Cuellar

Steve, just a guess, but I believe a lot of table saw accidents probably happen on the "portable" variety. Not having it secured properly & trying to run too heavy a piece of stock through it. Male bravado is probably another factor. People afraid to admit they don't know how to do something because they might be made fun of. People also don't seem to take the time or have the skills even to read directions on a tool they buy and attempt to use for the first time.

Caught an electrician at work trying to freehand a piece of plywood through a table saw. I stopped him & gave him a lesson in saw safety. He is 70 years old & a really great guy. No one had ever shown him the proper way to use one before!!!