Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

Posts

Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#1

Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

JamieDonaldson

.. a view showing the difference in the amount of metal that supports the shallow flutes. These are both 1/2" gouges, measuring the diameter of the shafts. Each has it's own applications, but can often be used interchangeably. The extra strength of the detail gouge(L) allows use way over the tool rest for applications such as eccentric turning, and the spindle gouge(R) can access tiny spaces for items like finial details. I grind the same bevel angle on both in a Wolverine jig, then freehand the grinding away of the heels to a rounded profile, giving better access for cuts into a restricted space.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#2

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

David Walser

Thanks for sharing. I'll have to try that.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#3

Leo Cuellar

Thanks for the show & tell.

Leo Cuellar

Nice photo, Jamie. They usually don't show that kind of stuff when you're trying to order something. Since I tend to do more eccentric stuff I'll have to go for some detail gouges.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#4

Dang, I should have sharpened ....

JamieDonaldson

...them before taking the photo, didn't realize the spindle gouge bevel was so dirty until it was enlarged! :b

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#5

Walt Bennett

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

Walt Bennett

Someone told me a couple weeks ago that the 'detail' gouge was born when a manufacturer had a big batch of steel blanks that were supposed to become bowl gouges get ground way shallow. Instead of going back and doing them right (maybe they were done in China?), the manufacturer's marketing department came up with the name. I'm not casting dispersions as I've one myself that I use fairly often - just goes to show how sometimes new tools can be made from mistakes.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#6

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

Bill Noce in Northeast Ohio

Jamie,

I have the 7/16" Detail Gouge as Quoted from Doug's site...."The 7/16" detail gouge was designed by turner, writer and teacher King Heiple, the flute is slightly shallower with a larger radius. This is also know as the Heiple detail gouge." King Heiple is a member of Northcoast Woodturners in Cleveland,Ohio. I like this one the best of the others of which the 1/4" & 3/8".

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#7

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

brian.mcinturff

Interesting comment on how the detail gouge was invented then. I've got an older Glaser 1/4" detail gouge that would've been from the 80's or early 90's then a few of Doug's details. I keep my sharpen pretty much the same. One of the most versatile gouges in the arsenal of turning tools.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#8

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

Bill Noce in Northeast Ohio

Yes, I have 2 Glaser 1/4" unhandled detail gouges and 3/8" handled detail that I purchased also I believe sometime in the late 90's. I also have Doug's 1/4" that I purchased in the last couple of years. And the 3/8" detail that I purchase after Doug had several of his gouges at Northcoast Woodturners meeting in Cleveland Ohio Meeting when he first started making gouges to try an I liked and purchased it an the rest is history.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#9

Jamie, This grind can go .....

Dale Miner

Almost anywhere a skew can go. 7/16" detail gouge. The primary bevel is about 30 degrees, and it has a secondary and tertiary bevel to allow for getting in narrow areas and making smooth sweeping coves. The pointy tip can be rolled for making very small beads and details, and the wings used for making a skew like cut. It is ground with a varigrind type jig for all three bevels.

It is only scary for a while.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#10

My Thompson Detail and Spindle gouge

john lucas

Here is a photo of mine. The detail gouge is on the top and the spindle gouge on the bottom. Both are 1/2". They are both ground with the Wolverine jig set at the same angle. They both have a 35 degree angle. As you can see the detail gouge has a narrower tip. With the sharpening angle being the same I can reach into the same tight areas but the narrower tip lets me reach into smaller areas when I'm not using the tool with the flute perfectly sideways. Since I grind my skew at a 35 degree also I can reach into the same tight areas with these tools as I can with the skew. However I do have some tricks with the skew that let me do some things these can't do.

The detail gouge is 70 thousandths thicker. That doesn't seem like much but it does make a difference when hanging the tool over the tool rest very far.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#11

Re: My Thompson Detail and Spindle gouge

john lucas

I must have been too tired from a long day of work. I should have measured the amount of steel from the bottom of the flute to the bottom of the tool, not outside diameter, duh. The spindle gouge thickness is .270, the detail gouge is .400 That's .130" or almost half again what the total thickness of the detail gouge is.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#12

Re: My Thompson Detail and Spindle gouge

Dale Miner

Hi John,

You've a much better pic, but essentially we have our detail gouges ground the same. Including the triple bevel. The 7/16" has just a bit more pointy nose than the 1/2". The only tools I have that will get in where the detail gouge won't is a skew ground with a very acute angle, and a special made detail gouge with a 20 degree bevel that gets used about once every six months or so.

Couldn't get by without the detail gouge.

Re: Detail vs spindle gouges- here is ....

#13

Dick Hines

Re: Dang, I should have sharpened ....

Dick Hines

That's what I was thinking Jamie. The gouges look like someone has been chewing on their finger nails.