Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Combination Press Plough Plane

Spindle or Detail

Posts

Spindle or Detail

#1

Spindle or Detail

James Pittman

I am getting ready to buy a gouge to do boxes and tops and finials should I buy a spindle or a detail gouge and what size would be best. Thanks Jim

Re: Spindle or Detail

#2

Doug Thompson's 1/2" detail gouge....

JamieDonaldson

...is my weapon of choice for all such work. The cutting edge is better supported with metal under the shallow flute, and allows better support when extended over the tool rest than a standard spindle gouge. Grind away some of the heel to a nice round shape that will allow cutting in very close quarters, like finial details.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#3

Re: Doug Thompson's 1/2" detail gouge....

woodspinner-Harry Robinette

I'll go along with Jamie except I use a 3/8,I cut the bottom back the same way but to me the 3/8 is easyer to control in tight places.Also I really like the smaller one for finials.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#4

Ken Vaughan

Detail  3/8 and 1/4

Ken Vaughan

Doug Thompson's detail gouges have become a love affair -- the 1/4 is great for ornaments and finials and the 3/8 works for larger. Then comes the 1/2 inch --

One of each is the correct answer.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#5

Re: Spindle or Detail

john lucas

Well I have to agree with the others. I have a spindle gouge and detail gouge. I prefer the detail gouge for 95% of the work. I really only use the spindle gouge for larger spindles and often use the detail gouge for those. My choice is the 3/8". I can turn really small or larger work with it. I do use the 1/2". Mostly use it when i have to hand the tool over the tool rest really far. That was the main reason I got them but they are so functional for general work I use them all the time.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#6

OK Harry, I have to confess that.....

JamieDonaldson

...I also have and use the Thompson 3/8" detail gouge. Can't have too many tools for specialty use!

Re: Spindle or Detail

#7

Re: Spindle or Detail

James Pittman

I look on Doug's web site and he had two differant detail gouge one with the flute 20% and one 33% which is best. Thanks Jim

Re: Spindle or Detail

#8

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Spindle or Detail

Katherine Kowalski

I have to admit, I find no use for a detail gouge. A 3/8" spindle gouge is my tool of choice for just about everything in spindlework, (including boxes).

In a "detail" gouge, I find that the thickness of metal gets in my way, and takes longer to grind off, (especially when shortening the bevel). It also prevents getting into details. (I really have no idea why this tool is named as such). However, I suppose "detail" may be a relative term.

For true details I use a pointy-grind spindle gouge, (ala Cindy Drozda), which is ultra-useful for fine work.

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Spindle or Detail

#9

Re: Spindle or Detail

john lucas

Grind a secondary bevel so the main bevel is short. The detail gouge will the get into the tightest areas. I think it's called a detail gouge because of the narrow tip. As I mentioned above the detail gouge is so strong because it's thick. I get a lot less chatter on certain cuts using the detail gouge vs the spindle gouge.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#10

Re: Spindle or Detail

john lucas

Can't say which is best. As Doug says in the website.

The 3/8 and 1/2 inch Shallow Detail Gouge has a flute depth of 20% of the diameter with a larger radius. The strongest of all the spindle tools, this can extend far over the tool rest and has a skew type cut.

consequently I have to assume that this tool is stiffer and will chatter less. I'm not sure what I have, I've had them for years. Mine are pretty thick. I think the thicker the better but as Katherine has pointed out. You have to do something to the bevel. The thicker tool has a very long bevel and will be inhibitive for some cuts. That's why I grind a secondary bevel. It removes metal that would get in the way when turning some details. Since there is less metal on the primary bevel sharpening is faster.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#11

Keith Tompkins

Re: Spindle or Detail

keith tompkins

Hi James, I use both. I initially bought the detail gouge for end-grain hollowing, since there is more metal to support the cut. I have ground my DT detail gouge so the bevel is almost round, removing a lot of material under the cutting edge. I use both gouges on their side, flute 90 degrees to the cut...no need to grind a pointy tip.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#12

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Spindle or Detail

Katherine Kowalski

Grind a secondary bevel so the main bevel is short.


That's what I said.... grinding both bevels takes much longer. I use a 1-2 mm bevel on my gouges, and having all that tool steel in the way is a pain and takes too much time.

The detail gouge will the get into the tightest areas. I think it's called a detail gouge because of the narrow tip. As I mentioned above the detail gouge is so strong because it's thick. I get a lot less chatter on certain cuts using the detail gouge vs the spindle gouge.

I have to disagree -- the detail gouge will NOT get into the tightest areas. Any details are best made with a pointy spindle gouge. A narrow tip can be ground on any tool.

Putting the tool rest closer to the work will control chatter equally as well as a thicker tool. (I never have situations where any sort of spindle gouge needs to be over the tool rest more than an absolute maximum of 1/2". What situations are you running into?)

It may also depend on one's turning style -- I like my tool rest close to the work, and I do highly-detailed, fine work. If one is turning larger diameter stock, and is forced to make a deep detail..... well... let me recommend a bowl gouge or a skew....

Katherine

Re: Spindle or Detail

#13

Mike Stafford

Re: Spindle or Detail

Mike Stafford

James, I use both a detail gouge and a spindle gouge for my boxes. I like the Thompson 1/2" detail for hollowing end grain because the extra steel under the flute really provides great support when reaching over the tool rest into a box. The Thompson detail gouge seems to hold an edge for a long time.

When shaping the exterior I like the Thompson 1/2" spindle gouge. I sharpen with swept back wings and love the way it peels wood off when going from face grain to end grain when rounding over areas on my boxes.

I have 3/8" Thompson detail and spindle gouges also and they work great on smaller boxes and detail work. I use them exclusively on my birdhouse and seashell ornaments.

These Thompson tools seem to hold an extremely sharp edge for a long time.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#14

Re: Spindle or Detail

Gordon Seto

Katherine,

Try multi-axis turning and pulling the tool rest close is not always possible. Extending the tool 1 to 2 inches over the tool rest is not uncommon.

I think how tight a space a gouge can get to depends on the primary bevel angle.

A shallow detail gouge has narrower flute, it won't be able to be shaped as wide a fingernail as a spindle gouge. A shallow detail gouge has more steel under the flute; it can extend over the tool rest further without chattering. A spindle gouge is easier to control on a long sweeping curve. I think all 3 have compromises and their function overlaps a little. It all depends on what I am turning.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#15

Katherine Kowalski

Re: Spindle or Detail

Katherine Kowalski

Gordon,

Thank you for reminding me of that -- it's been a long time since I've done much multi-axis turning. (I generally reach for my bowl gouge for this).

You are correct -- the tightness of the space does depend on the angle of the primary bevel to a large degree. However, it also depends on the grind of the tip. (A narrow, pointy grind will allow the tool to get in close without damaging details on the opposite side of a tight v-groove, for instance). I find the more-slender profile of a spindle gouge to work better for my purposes.

To each his/her own.

Katherine

Re: Spindle or Detail

#16

Re: Spindle or Detail

john lucas

Another problem I have with chatter is when I undercut the opening of my hand mirrors. I don't have the tool very far off the tool rest. I place the tool flute out against the back of the mirror and push it into what will be the V groove to undercut this lip. The I simply rotate the bottom lip of the gouge out which cuts the groove. With a standard spindle gouge it screams and makes a lot of noise. With the Thompson detail gouge of the same size, no noise just a nice clean cut.

When hollowing boxes I can't get the tool rest close. I can hog of wood much faster with the detail gouge and still get a decent cut because it doesn't chatter at all. On inside out turnings of course you can't get tool rest close. I used to use a bowl gouge for these because it chattered less than a spindle gouge but how I use the detail gouge.

As far as the grinding the second bevel, that litterally takes me maybe 5 seconds. I grind the first bevel, then just move the Wolverined jig forward and grind the second one. Since the second one doesn't do anything accuracy is not an issue, just grind.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#17

Re: Spindle or Detail

john lucas

Katherine I imagine you and I would turn the same small details using our own tools simply because we know what we are doing with them. You are obviously highly skilled since your work shows it. I do a demo for the club sometimes using my 1/2" detail gouge which looks like I'm turning with a large stick. Since it has the same 35 degree bevel as my smaller tools I can turn the same tiny details. It's all in how you use the tool.

Re: Spindle or Detail

#18

In the other hand...

Jorge Casta�eda

the long bevel of the detail gauges is an asset when shaping the outside of a bowl or vase, so I keep some long and some with the heel rounded.