Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

Posts

Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

#1

Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

John Lucas

A quicky before my day kicks off and my first customer comes in. I had time Sunday night to turn a piece of that Bradford Pear. I earned it after cutting on the stuff all day Saturday and Sunday. Anyway, I wanted to play with the EWT again. I'm trying to learn the pro's and cons.

I started with a crotch area that was really out of round would end up with a long and narrow natural edge sort of piece. These interrupted cuts (meaning that I'm turning more air than wood) have always been a pain. So I'm always searching for an easier way. I switched back and forth between the EWT and a 1/2" Thompson V bowl gouge.

At this early stage of turning both require some skill. The EWT can be pushed it too far very easily and tries to catch or stops the wood. You have to really control the depth of cut and it's kind of hard to do because you can't run the lathe very fast due to imbalance of the piece. With the bowl gouge what I do is use my left hand as a fulcrum. I start the cut away from the wood and then move the handle like a lever to feed the tool through an arc in the wood. This is very controlled so can take off a known amount of wood and seems to fight me much less than other methods. Now I'm talking about the wood only hitting the tool once per revolution on this cut so it's can be really hard on you if you just stick the tool in.

Now as the wood gets closer to round and I have about 3 or 4 places hitting the tool I can start the bowl gouge in the same fashion but once it's started I have the bevel on the wood and can control the depth of cut so it doesn't beat me up so much. The EWT is definitely easier to use at this point but I don't think it's easier than the bowl gouge. At least in experienced hands. You still have to be really careful about not pushing in and taking too big of a bite. It also throws the shaving right back into your face so the deflector shield or a face shield is an absolute necessity. With the bowl gouge you can sort aim the chips a little depending on how you orient the flute.

OK now it's basically round but oval shaped. About 5" wide 12" long. In the areas where there is solid wood the EWT is very easy to use. Just stick it in and wood flies. However you still have to control the shape of the vessel purely by how hard you push or try to glide the tool. With the Bowl gouge once I start the cut I have great control of the shape using the handle as a lever to guide the bevel in the direction I want to go. On this wood both gave about the same quality of cut although with the EWT it didn't seem to matter which direction the grain was running. With the Bowl gouge I had to learn the direction. On this piece I turned from the rim to the foot which is the opposite that I usually do on what appears to be a side grain bowl.

Once I got out onto the "wings" of the bowl the difference in the tools was greater. I had a very hard time getting a smooth line with the EWT. If you even breathed hard you could stick the tool in too far and leave much deeper tool mark that had to be removed with a second or third pass. This really took some control using my body. With the bowl gouge it's quite a bit easier as long as you don't push on the bevel (which makes it want to drop into the void or interrupted cut. Use light pressure on the bevel and control the direction of cut with the handle and you can control the shape much better.

I did sharpen my bowl gouge once (it took all of maybe 30 seconds) and of course did not sharpen the EWT.

Personally I want everyone to have fun with their turning and most importantly, finish the project they are working on. I'm not worried about what tool you use to do it, be it a sharpened file or screwdriver (please anneal the file first) or state of the art razor sharp bowl gouges. I'm just trying to look at some of the new tools and report what I find to hopefully make it easier for you to select a tool. I will be turning more with these two tools along with another one that may hit the market soon. I'll report what I find.

Re: Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

#2

Alan Zenreich

Re: Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

Alan Zenreich

John,

A couple of tips for those not used to the EWT tools

1. Faster rpms (within safety constraints) make for a better/easier cut. Sometimes the difference in quality is quite surprising.

2. With any of the square shaped cutters, try cutting with a small portion near the front of the left or right side of the cutter instead of using the front face. This cutting to the left (or right) allows very fine control over the cut.

Hope this helps those who are experimenting with these tools.

Re: Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

#3

Re: Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

John Lucas

Alan Faster is definitely better for these tools but simply wasn't possible on the piece of wood I was turning. Thanks for your comments.

Re: Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

#4

Re: Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

Scott Hurley in N VA

I've had the same issues with the EWT. There's definitely a learning curve. I'm still much more comfortable with a bowl gouge.

Re: Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

#5

Re: Easy wood tool vs bowl gouge

woodspinner-Harry Robinette

Own both square and round EWT ,they stay on the cart and I use my Thompson bowl gouges.

Better control and less going back over.