Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

'tiz a puzzle...

Posts

'tiz a puzzle...

#1

'tiz a puzzle...

GaryG in MD

The topic is chucking.

I have a small Aussie burl turning square with a natural edge (sharp points) top.

It's nominally a stopper blank, but that's not what I want to do with it.

I want to make a small box out of it (to hold a tooth or pill, or whatever).

I planned to chuck it up and part it into two pieces. I've seen squares chucked in a 4-jaw scroll chuck with the corners between the jaws.

The problem is that this "square" is not. So two jaws hit first, and not the other two.

So it's wiggly and unturnable.

I don't want to try to mess with a planer or sander to try to make it exactly square.

There must be a way to hold this thing, but it's not coming to me.

I can't put it between centers to turn a small tenon because of the NE top.

Ideas would be welcome. TIA, Gary

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#2

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

Dale Miner

Cut two thin slats of scrap wood that are 1/2 half the thickness difference between the large dimension and the small dimension. Tape or hold the slats on the narrow sides of the blank when chucking.

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#3

thanks Dale...

GaryG in MD

That thought did cross my mind. I was hoping for something more "elegant", but maybe that's what it will come down to. ...Gary

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#4

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

Emmett Manley, Lakeland, TN

I'm having a little difficulty visualizing the shape of your burl, but I seem to be able to mount about anything (small) via a glue block or a Glaser screw chuck.

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#5

CA glue it to a round waste block.

JamieDonaldson

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#6

Brad Vietje

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

Brad Vietje

Gary,

I like Dale's idea, but how big is the "square"? To turn this between centers, you might also be able to push the natural edge up against a piece of blue board insulation on a piece of scrap wood.

One option when turning small bits is to turn one end to a short, round cylinder or tenon, and turn a mating recess in a piece of scrap wood that fits your chuck. If the friction fit is good, you may be able to complete the turning with nothing but "scrunch", but a little CA or hot glue will keep it from popping out. If the diameter of the thing is too small for your jaws once rounded up, you may need to fashion some sort of wooden colett chuck to hold it, or flatten one end to be parallel to the natural edge, and glue that end to a waste block.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#7

continuing dialog...

GaryG in MD

Thanks Emmett, Jamie, and Brad for your thoughts -- and Dale earlier. You've given me some good ideas.

To be a bit more precise, this is a small piece of a burl cap, about 4" long and 1" "square" with one flat end and the "top" end being the burl points sloped at an angle of about 40 degrees from side to side. My intent is to leave the outside "square", part off about 1/3 for the top section (hopefully without chipping the corners), hollow the bottom section a bit, and put a tenon on the top section to fit into the top of the cavity in the bottom section. If I can figure out how to hold the top section, I'll do a little decorative work on the inside of the tenon -- or at least make it concave.

Clearly, I don't want to damage the burl end with a tail center point. Because of the aspect ratio, I'm a little concerned about putting it on a glue block, but that might work. I obviously can't use a steady of any kind, and I can't bring up a live center point for support. The idea of embedding the burl end in a piece of "insulation" is intriguing. A piece of high-density foam might work to provide the needed support without damaging the points. That and a glue block should be enough to handle it.

OTOH, Dale's idea of making a couple of thin shims still has merit too. It's not off by much, so it might just take a couple pieces of thin metal sheeting to do the job. The problem there is it will never be quite exact and may vibrate, and I don't want to squeeze the chuck down too tight and make compression marks on the two sides of the burl. Trying to center it inside 4 surrounding pieces of thin wooden shims may be the best answer. That way I don't have to worry about compression marks or popping the glue joint, and I wouldn't have to deal with the tail end at all.

So it looks like I have two pretty good methods, thanks to you all.

I'm still open to more thoughts...

Thanks for your contributions guys, Gary

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#8

Re: continuing dialog...

john lucas

Gary Here's what I would do. I make pill boxes and sewing kits that are similar to what you are doing. I part the wood, then drill out the top using my 4 jaw chuck to hold the work. Then I put the bottom in and drill it smaller. I turn a tenon to hold the lid. Install the lid and turn the whole thing.

You can't do that is sounds like. I would first glue a waste block to the bottom. This should be allow the wood to stick out. If you think you will have trouble alinging it temporarily glue some waste material to the narrow side and true these up until it is square and matches your waste block. These can be removed once the waste block is glued. Use epoxy to blue the waste block. This is an end grain to end grain joint and it won't hold well with other glues and will be quite weak even then.

Then I would start the parting of the lid with the toe of a skew. This will keep from chipping the corners. Make 2 cuts spaced the thickness of your parting tool. Cut down to where the wood is round then you can use the parting tool to do the rest.

Since the wood is so short I would add some length for the tenon. What I would do is drill the top and set it aside. Now drill the bottom with the same drill. Glue a dowel into the bottom that is the same size as the drill. Now drill out the center of the dowel using a bit that is at least 1/8" smaller. YOu may want to put tape around the tenon while drilling and go very slow to keep from breaking it. Once this is done remove the tape and check the tenon for fit to the lid. If it's too tight turn a little off. If it's too loose put some medium CA on it to build it up and turn that down. That doesn't look very good but does work. I usually dye the tenon with india ink if I have to use the CA.

Now the 2 halves should fit together. Part or turn off the bottom and your ready to sand.

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#9

Steven Antonucci

If I understand the requirement correctly

steven antonucci

You want a "square" box with a natural edge. The only thing "turned in it is the hole on the inside?

I would use a tablesaw to cut the box in half, giving me a top with a natural edge. I would hold this in a wood screw and CAREFULLY drill it with a forstner bit to whatever finished depth, and then turn a decorative plug to glue over the hole I drilled.

Next, I'd mount it in the lathe so that I was drilling the inside of the bottom as closely as possible to the same line as the top. Turn a small tenon with the tailstock for support. Make sure it fits the way you want.

Lastly, with this process, I'd expect that you'd have minor variances in centering, so you can align the grain and lap the four flat surfaces on a belt sander or a flat plate with sandpaper.

Done.

Steve

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#10

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

Lan Brady

Gary,

The 2 corners that are hitting the jaws first.

Can you saw off these little corners until the wood hits all 4 jaws?

Lan

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#11

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

GaryG in MD

Lan, Thanks for your thought. In this case, the corners are in between the jaws -- it's the sides that are held by the jaws. Holding the corners would dent them and not give a firm purchase. ...Gary

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#12

Thanks John...

GaryG in MD

John, Lots of good ideas here. I'm sure to use some. Your comment about using the skew toe is right on. Steve's comment about using a table saw is also good -- we sometimes insist on using the lathe for everything where other tools might do a better job. In this case, I don't have a table saw, so... Glue on the end may work, because it's a burl -- no end grain. That's a great idea about using a tenon of a different wood too -- would keep whatever grain match there is, but I'm not sure I want a dissimilar wood in there. I'll have to think about that one. The bottom isn't quite straight/flat either, so I may use Dale's waste wood on the sides to true that up first. Anyway, you've certainly given me lots of techniques to select from. Thanks, Gary

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#13

Thanks Steve...

GaryG in MD

Steve, Yes, that's right... only the inside will be turned -- a tenon to hold it together, cleaning up the bottom of the drilled hole, and doing something subtle with the inside bottom of the top section. I think it will look better, and be easier to make, with the tenon on the top part.

Your comment about the table saw is right on -- except I don't have one. :-)

I'd rather not have to plug a hole -- I think that would be a visual distraction.

I'm sure you're right about the final alignment -- I have a disc sander that will take care of that, as you recommend. And I expect there'll be a preferred direction for the rotation of the top -- not sure how I'm going to indicate that at this point -- maybe I can part it at a natural flaw to make it obvious.

Thanks for your thoughts, Gary

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#14

Steven Antonucci

Might be helpful to post pictures

steven antonucci

sometimes, it's hard to visualize what we're talking about. I have a pretty good idea, but I still wonder if I have it right.

If you don't have a tablesaw or other shop equipment available, that also might be a good bit of info to post. Suggesting that you use the fleeznitz discombobulator doesn't help if you don't own one.

If I only had a lathe and a chuck, I might make a long set of wooden jaws like a collet with a square opening to fit the blank. You could glue it together around the blank to make it a perfect fit, and then run some bandsaw (handsaw) kerfs and a hoseclamp to grab your work...

Steve

Re: 'tiz a puzzle...

#15

Re: Might be helpful to post pictures

GaryG in MD

Steve, I think Dale had it covered -- surround the burl with shims of a somewhat softer wood -- two slightly thicker than the other pair so the assembly can be clamped firmly in the 4-jaw scroll chuck with alligator jaws. That should work for the whole thing to part off the top, and then for each section separately too. (At least in my head -- the real world sometimes begs to differ.) Final alignment may end up a bit "off", but your belt sander suggestion will take care of a little problem like that (hopefully).

I'll let you know what happens when I can get around to it -- no time for turning right now...

Thanks, Gary