When I saw Mike Stafford's pheasantwood box here a few weeks ago, I really admired the grain of the wood. I was able to get a couple chunks of it and finally got around to turning a little vase yesterday. I really like the transitional wood between the sap and the heart.
My question is, what do you think of the little foot on this pot? I almost always carry the curve all the way around the bottom, with just the smallest flat for a base and no added foot, but this time I left a tiny vestige of a foot that you can really only see when you view it from eye level. I wonder if it's too much.
To foot or not to foot, that is the question. And as the answers tend to be highly subjective they are also usually split about equally both ways. Then we also know what is said about opinions so here is mine. While I'd say that this pot would look just fine without the foot I don't find this one the least objectionable. It's diameter and height are keeping with the overall dimensions of the pot...which is very nicely done also.
If the vase is to stand on a mantle, I'd take it off. If on a table, I'd keep it. It's a bit like crown molding, in my opinion, you alter the angle depending on where your eyes will hit it. Like you, I'm often conflicted about the foot. Great piece, though. I love the wood.
While the piece looks great the way it is, and you have such perfect and graceful lines going on here, I'd like to see the curve complete itself. Excellent work!
Ellis that is a wonderfully voluptuous shape. I don't mind the little foot at all. It sort of acts as a subtle pedestal for the piece. Great piece of wood too. I've never heard of it before.
I think the piece is excellent! Take a straight-edge and slide it up from below on the picture. I sort of liked it when it cut the bottom third off the foot.
I am not firmly in either the foot or no-foot camp as a general rule. I think this piece is so fine that it works with the foot and likely would without as well.
This is a lovely piece of wood Ellis and if you are like me it is a pleasure uncovering the beauty of its grain as you are turning. I think that is a great deal of the appeal to our hobby. We enjoy unwrapping nature's presents.
For what it's worth, I would like to have seen the bottom curve on your beautiful little vase carried to its completion which I believe would have left a little flat upon which the vase could sit that would still have displayed the curves at the bottom and given the same lift as the foot without being as conspicuous. A little concavity in the flat would help provide stability and provide a space for the maker's mark.
Don't you just love looking at pheasantwood. My wife has kept every piece I have turned.
Feet are always contentious things, but ... where would we be without them? A species of stumpies? I nearly always trust the artist and his judgement when it comes to feet. As long as the feet compliment rather than distract from the main subject.
The diameter of the foot is (as far as I can tell) identical to the diameter of the lip. I wouldn't change a thing. Certainly woldn't make the foot smaller than the lip.
ellis ithink feet usually are the way. beautiful job. i probably would have reduced the size about 1/3 and depth also. i think rounding with no foot would be wrong
Seems like the jury is divided, as am I. When viewed from above, you can't see the foot, so it doesn't matter From head-on, it is a mixed blessing visually for me. I guess I'll have to make another one without the foot and see if I prefer one over the other.
I really like this piece a lot. Just by looking at it you cannot tell if it is 2 inches tall or 20 inches tall. To me, that means the shape is spot on. I have to admit, though, that I think I would have preferred it without the pedestal foot, but it is still a wonderful piece. I like that wood a lot.