Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Do you hone your tools?

Posts

Do you hone your tools?

#1

Do you hone your tools?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

In the previous thread about tools, many grits of grinder wheels were preferred. 60, 100, 120, 180 and 1000 on the Tormek. I hone after every trip to the grinder and many times in-between. I use the Tormek honing disc, or a Lacer diamond hone, or aluminum oxide tubes that are industrial waste. I have several diameters of the tubes that match the inside of the flutes on my gouges. I have given many of these tubes away over the last 6 years at symposiums from FL to Bill G's in PA. Unfortunately I no longer have a source.

If you hone, when do you do it, all the time or only the final finish cut? Does in-between honing prevent a sooner trip to the grinder? If it does save steel or time, why don't more turners do it? If you own a Tormek, do you always use the honing wheel? Do you get better finishes because you hone? Why do non-honers MAKE fun of honers?

Please try to support your feelings with facts or examples.

Bill

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#2

Re: Do you hone your tools?

john lucas

Bill I only hone before a final cut or if I have problem areas. I have not been able to tell that the edge lasts any longer than straight from the grinder. Maybe that's just me. I originally tried honing thinking it would save metal I think I end up rounding the edge slightly. After several honings It seems I have to go the grinder and take off as much or more metal getting the edge back to my original grind.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#3

Re: Do you hone your tools?

woodspinner-Harry Robinette

Bill

I've been honing sense seeing Michael Lee at Turning 2003 in Cincinnati.I do believe that if you hone the burr off it gives you a sharper edge to start with.The adage that the burr breaks off when I hit the wood doesn't seem right to me cause I can't figure out how to break the steel sharp.I hone after each grinding and during my turning instead of going back to the grinder.Before last cut I always go to the grinder and then hone for a very sharp and shaped edge.My Jet wet sharpener and power hone I only use on flat tools

all my gouges are sharpened on the slow speed grinder. It's always been AO 60 grit and 120 grit but now I'm using Norton 3X SG Ceramic wheels which I believe are FAR better then the AO's but I still hone.

Hone - Red DMT Fine 600 grit.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#4

Re: Do you hone your tools?

robo hippy

I have tried it a few times, and didn't notice any real difference. Main reason would be to keep from having to go back to the grinder as often. Since I use scrapers for my roughing, and have maybe 10 gouges, I rough first then use a gouge for a bowl or two, and when it is dull, pick up another one. Then, sharpen all at once.

robo hippy

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#5

Jesper, Denmark

Re: Do you hone your tools?

Jesper, Denmark

I only hone the skew.

Baldor 8" slow speed grinder with one blue and one white wheel, both 100 -120 grit. It is even slower than intended, as running on 50 Hertz, so around 1425 rpm.

Gouges are sharpened often, using a Oneway jig.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#6

JL

Re: Do you hone your tools?

JL

I use my Tormek to hone my gouges for finish cuts. I rarely hone my skew. I also have a honing "stone" that I got from John Jordan that I use from time to time.

Honestly speaking - I hone the gouges when I'm doing tricky cuts on my spindles that I don't want to sand. The places where sanding causes the detail to get lost.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#7

Re: Do you hone your tools?

Greg Haugen

I use skews a lot in my spindle turning. Honing is essential. My skews only go to the grinder after my "honing lines" are getting pretty wide or heaven forbid I drop a skew. I'll hone with 600 grit diamond hones (DMT or Lacer) and if I have a problematic area I'll power hone on a mdf wheel and compound to a mirrored surface.

I will hone my gouges from time to time before going to the grinder, especially if I'm in a production run. I will hone a gouge for problematic areas or switch to a skew to clean it up.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#8

ebd

Re: Do you hone your tools?

ebd

Personally, I hone (touch up) an edge with a diamond card when it starts to get less than really sharp. It seems to bring the fine cut back and takes less effort than going back to the wheel. It also uses less steel. I don't hone after sharpening. I use fine enough wheels that makes that unnecessary. If you sharpen when you first need to (long before you completely dull the tool) you don't have to remove much and so can use finer grinding stones. THen using a diamond hone extends the sharpening cycle.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#9

Walt Bennett

Re: Do you hone your tools?

Walt Bennett

Everyone seems to hone with diamond slips - I hone with an old high speed grinder with sewn buffing wheels and white diamond rouge. It doesn't seem to matter much when roughing, but having a really smooth and sharp edge does help when finishing a piece.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#10

Dick Hines

Re: Do you hone your tools?

Dick Hines

Only my skews, Bill.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#11

Re: Do you hone your tools?

Jennifer Indy.USA

I only hone my skew. I found that for me most other honeing is just a waste of time. The skew is the one tool that I find that needs the sharpest edge possible for a finish that doesn't need sanding. In order to get that I have to hone it when it comes off the grinder. Bowl gouges and detail gouges I don't bother with. It's too easy to make the edge worse by rolling it over with the hone and I don't seem to be able to see a difference with these tools when I hone or if I don't.

My 2 cents.

Jen

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#12

Re: Do you hone your tools?

Doug Turner

I power hone my skew right after grinding using an 8" mdf wheel and stainless steel honing compound. I then touch up between grindings with a 600 grit diamond paddle. I usually don't hone gouges , the exception is before the final shear scrape pass -it saves sanding time.

Re: Do you hone your tools?

#13

Steven Antonucci

You know I do

steven antonucci

If I am fresh off the wheel and coming to round, I do not hone gouges.

I hone gouges in between trips to the Tormek to bring back a cutting edge and conserve metal and time. I like the little DMT finger paddles because they are easy to lock on the bevels with one finger.

Lastly, if I am making a cut that truly matters, I resharpen on the Tormek, hone with diamonds, and then strop with leather charged with a cutting compound like the stuff you can use on the Tormek wheel. I have cut myself before where I saw it before I felt it...

Finally, nobody has mentioned WHAT they hone. If you look at the flutes of most gouges, there are mill marks from when they cut the flute. I am not just cutting away the burr, but over time, working on polishing the flute to a mirror finish also... A sharp edge is the intersection of TWO highly refined surfaces!

Steve