Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Youtube video

Posts

Youtube video

#1

Steven Antonucci

Youtube video

steven antonucci


Lots of things to talk about...

S

Re: Youtube video

#2

Re: Youtube video

Michael Mocho

So confident .... so clueless.

Re: Youtube video

#3

Re: Youtube video

Dick Wilson

I turned it off just as he was facing the top of the bowl with a scraper.

I presume he had the bowl on a face plate. He could have used the tail stock for safety reasons until he had it turned to shape. Other than that no real safety issues. I don't know what species wood he was turning but his gouges seemed dull. Very little in the way of shavings - mostly powder. He obviously is a big scraper user. The bowl profile looks like it would be very difficult to use a bowl gouge for the finishing cuts on the interior. I suspect that he does a lot of scraping. He makes a lot of work for himself. Just my 2 cents.

Re: Youtube video

#4

Re: Youtube video

brian.mcinturff

I was thinking the same thing. Seems every tool he used, he used as a scraper. At least when he got to the inside he did make a few curls. But, then went right back to the scraper to take out the bulk. And his remark about "No rules" ... classic.

Re: Youtube video

#5

Re: Youtube video

Fred Holder

I hate to be the first to comment on this video, but I hope there aren't too many beginning woodturners watching it. My first complaint was the use of a spindle roughing gouge on a bowl, there have been too many of them broken over the years from trying to turn side grain with a spindle roughing gouge.

The use of a skew on a bowl is in my opinion a No! NO!

I was not impressed with the grinds on his bowl gouges either.

Re: Youtube video

#6

Mike Stafford

Re: Youtube video

Mike Stafford

What is amazing to me is that there are some very fine woodturning clubs in the vicinity of the corporate headquarters. There are any number of highly skilled turners who could have done a demonstration video for Klingspor illustrating the correct way to use the correct tools.

Interesting and sad at the same time.... :(

Re: Youtube video

#7

Re: Youtube video

Galen Vetterick

And to think I have been trying to learn what is right and wrong and then you go and show me a video that says there are no rules. I can use most any tool to do a cross grain bowl or dog dish.

You'd never show a green horn like me a video that is not correct, right?

Re: Youtube video

#8

Steven Antonucci

Until this afternoon, I didn't know the rules were

steven antonucci

merely "suggestions".

Cut in any direction with any tool, any grind.

Call the tools whatever comes to mind.

No rules.

S

Re: Youtube video

#9

Re: Youtube video

john lucas

Lets see, just so the beginners will know I'll try to make a list.

first, using a faceplate is OK but it limits your ability to change the orientation of the bowl for better grain alignment.

second. Using what people still insist on calling a roughing gouge to rough a bowl. As we all know it should be called a spindle roughing gouge and used for spindles not bowls.

Using the round nose scraper was OK but he was cutting against the grain most of the time.

Using either of these tools going back and forth across the end is the slowest way I know of truing up an edge. Start at the bottom corner and get it running true using a bowl gouge. Then start your cuts here and work your way around to the uneven areas. This beats you up a lot less.

He is using techniques that are dangerous and doesn't have a face shield on.

Using the spindle gouge on the outside is OK if your careful but why. He had 3 bowl gouges. They are much better for that.

Using the skew to clean up the corner is OK, but again he had 3 bowl gouges.

When hollowing he was doing fine with the bowl gouge. Open up the flute a little more and it will cut faster. He switched to the scraper because in his hands it cuts faster but again he was cutting against the grain.

Then when the bowl was almost finished he switched to the bowl gouge and turned the bottom without the bevel rubbing. Dangerous and doesn't cut much better than the scraper he was using.

did we mention the shape. This kind of shape is fine if that's what you want to turn. However you have a transition area where the sides meet the bottom you get catches there very easily. Especially using the tools the way he was.

I'm guessing here but he probably didn't finish the bottom.

Still, all in all the question has to be asked. Does he have fun doing what he's doing. then if he does that's great. However I'm sure you will agree with me, he shouldn't be making a video.

Perhaps we should send him some Easywood tools. He could use those quite successfully. That's not meant to put those tools down, I'm just saying that if he's going to do nothing but scrape he might as well get the best tools available.

Re: Youtube video

#10

Re: Youtube video

Dale Miner

http://www.popsshed.com.au/

Re: Youtube video

#11

Re: Youtube video

Vince Welch

LOL! That was funny!

Vince

Re: Youtube video

#12

Re: Youtube video

Dick Wilson

Dale, Thanks for the link. The best video on his site is the Wood Cut hollowing video. Now this turner has a clue on how to turn. It is certainly refreshing to watch a video where the turner uses the right tool in a safe and efficient manner - and guess what - sharp tools!!! I was very impressed with the hollowing tool. I have never seen a demo of it before.

Re: Youtube video

#13

Steven Antonucci

Now that some have weighed in

steven antonucci

The thing that struck me to most was that even doing all of the things that he was doing wrong, he seemed to be doing them well (but still wrong). No broken bones, no catastrophic failures.

Would I use that video to teach a new turner? No. Speed dial 9-1-1...

But apparently, he had "mastered" his techniques to the point where they were no longer dangerous to HIM.

My favorite was his "larger spindle gouge" which just looked like a misground bowl gouge to me. It had concave wings!

S

Re: Youtube video

#14

Re: Now that some have weighed in

Gordon Seto

Glad that he is not in the medical equipment sales.

At least it is not instructional video for student doctors.

Re: Youtube video

#15

Re: Youtube video

robo hippy

I found this video frightening. Not so much so for the tool choice as the way he used the tools, and what I consider to be his lack of knowledge as to the proper use of the tools. He started by using a continental style spindle roughing gouge as a scraper, and he had the handle lowered so the cutting edge was pointing up into the rotation. I will agree to a point about the 'no rules' part as to which tools work best for bowl turning. You probably have all heard my rants about how effective scrapers are as a roughing tool for bowls, but there are right and wrong ways to use each tool.

I noticed that the video is now 'no longer available'. Not sure why it was removed. I would never show that to a novice.

robo hippy

Re: Youtube video

#16

Re: Youtube video

robo hippy

The video isn't on his web site now either.

robo hippy

Re: Youtube video

#17

Steven Antonucci

Imagine that- we're slowly changing the world!

steven antonucci

it used to be that folks would flame a guy like that into submission, but nowadays, the world is so connected that I'm guessing someone here knew him and quietly reached out to him to review the comments.

As a purveyor of turning materials, he probably thought it through and realized that whether he agreed or disagreed with the opinions expressed here that it was bad for business to have people who might buy something from you disagree with you.

Go figure.

Steve