Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

Posts

check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#1

check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

John Lucas

I believe I can build one of these. It's just a matter of finding the time. I'd like to put an adjustable base on the bottom so you could enter the wood at different angles.


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5u2Yst1qXpc

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#2

Leo Cuellar

Great find, John!

Leo Cuellar

Possibly, you could size the post to mount in your banjo. I would think that the cross-section of the core that you take is going to limited by the curvature of the knife, but, I haven't done any coring yet. This looks like the rig to get started with though.

Thanks,

Leo

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#3

Nice Thumb!

Dave Belser

The rig looks pretty solid, but it's the fixed blade / curvature that bothers me. I've never liked the systems that restrict you to one shape. But hey I don't core much at all I glue sticks together : )

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#4

Steven Antonucci

Looks like the "bowl mill" video

steven antonucci

There's a show called "How It's Made" that has a video on YouTube from a segment they did on "bowl making" at a bowl mill. Similar type of setup, very efficient.

I bought my McNaughton with the idea that I would sell a couple of cored sets to get the money I spent on the tool back, but never got there. If you like to make bowls, this looks like a great way to make lots less mess with a lot more finish work...

S

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#5

Here's the video Steven is talking about... *LINK*

Greg Haugen

Here's the "How It's Made" video on wooden bowls. It's showcasing the Holland Bowl Mill in Michigan.


How It's Made-Wooden Bowls

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#6

That does look interesting.

Greg Haugen

It has the support on the cutter but doesn't have a separate finger that has to be moved. I really like the fact that it "catches" the core instead of allowing it to be thrown if it's cut all of the way through.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#7

Storebought: Oneway

Doc Green

This rig appears to be quite similar to the Oneway coring system except the knife is not supported in the cut as it is with the Oneway.

If you're going to do coring, I'd recommend the Oneway, but it costs an arm and a leg. It appears that the guy in the video got his system for only a thumb.

I don't like to core. ~Doc

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#8

Re: Storebought: Oneway

John Lucas

Doc The knife is supported all the way. The brace that is under it is apparently shaped like the core it takes so it's fully supported.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#9

Re: Nice Thumb!

John Lucas

The Oneway is also a fixed blade. Actually the McNaughton is also if you don't move the tool rest. By fixed I mean the partial circle that the cutters are. I'm pretty sure if I take the basic design that he has on this rig and simply make the cutters less than a 1/4 circle you could have flatter bowls.

When I made my own cutters for the McNaughton system I made varying arcs. They are all part of a circle, some are just a very big circle and maybe only 1/8th of it. I don't see why you couldn't fix bottom brace and then make it pivot on that arc. It may require a fancier pivoting area that moves in an arc itself rather that one fixed point.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#10

Leo Cuellar

Yeah, I've seen that one before...

Leo Cuellar

which got me thinking about building my own setup, especially after looking at prices on most of them. That core capture feature on this guy's setup is pretty slick.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#11

Re: Storebought: Oneway

Doc Green

OK, John, I missed it at first, but I see it now. Good design! Thanks. ~Doc

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#12

Re: Store Bought: One Way

Barry Irby

The knife MUST be a segment of a circle if it is going to track in its own kerf. I have been thinking for a long time that the way to make the cutter sturdy would be to use a segment of a sphere. Just don't know where you would find such a thing. A sphere that would have walls thick enough to be cut up and serve the purpose. And then others that would be of different sizes.

I have the McNaughton system and had to reshape the knives to track as they should.

Wonder where the guy got his blank? do you suppose he made it?

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#13

Re: check out this homemade coring rig

robo hippy

This particular set up is center mount only. You would not be able to move it off to the side to core. That would change the arc of the core, and the support blade would not fit into the kerf. The Oneway can move a little off to the sides, but if you go as far as you can, it does bind a bit in the cut.

robo hippy

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#14

Leo Cuellar

Steel pipe?

Leo Cuellar

Say, Barry, if you live near a good sized scrap yard you might see if they have various sizes of large diameter Sch.80 steel pipe. Seeing as how that knife is supported from the bottom anyway, a couple sections of the pipe welded together might be strong enough. Then a carbide cutter could be brazed or bolted on for the cutter. The sections could be flattened symmetrically to take a shallower core.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#15

Dick Hines

Re: Nice Thumb!

Dick Hines

I like the basket thingie that catches the bowls. No need to chase them around the shop when they come out of the mother bowl. :)

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#16

Re: check out this homemade coring rig

Dick Strauss

Pipe will only work if you also heat and form the knife strip from the pipe in a piece of pipe perpendicular to the original cut piece so that it follows a spherical surface. Some manufacturers do this by rounding over the edges to make it close to a spherical surface. A better idea would be to salvage anything in a hemispherical shape like the bottom or end of an empty propane tank. Then you could just cut out the triangular portion you wanted to use for coring and weld a cutter and pivot to it.

FYI-I think the reason for the cutout in the triangular knife system like the ones shown is to allow for shavings to fall out of the way, otherwise the core might not stay put or you might not be able to finish coring.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#17

Leo Cuellar

Or even easier...

Leo Cuellar

Dick, you could do what that guy did. It looks like he just bent some flat bar to the radii that he wanted then welded them together. 3/4" X 1/4" would probably be sufficient. A bending jig is fairly inexpensive to purchase or easy to make. Depending on one's mechanical abilities and either having or having a friend with a welder. His design is actually quite elegant if not pretty.

Leo

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#18

Leo Cuellar

Re: check out this homemade coring rig

Leo Cuellar

Have you had time to work on this one yet, John? I've been collecting parts, pieces & tooling and finally tacked the first one together today...

I'm still waiting on some miniature bolts, taps, & wire drill bits to attach some carbide cutters.

Initial results were poor, but that was due to not owning enough fancy metal working jigs & clamps. I'm thinking that probably the easiest way to provide jigging will be to turn at least one wooden hemisphere to slice in half to provide a stable clamping base for tack welding all the pieces together. I haven't worked out all the details yet, but from there it may be possible to use spacers to assemble the other coring heads.

I got to play with my new Grizzly bench top metal bender. It seems like a pretty good unit for what I paid for it. Now I just need to learn how to bend a consistent curve with it. :D

Since the coring tool pivots from a central point, one is limited to taking a piece of wood that is hemispherical. The only way I can see to change that, is by using a larger knife head and setting the pivot point back from the piece you are coring. By doing that one might lose that handy core capturing feature, but might be able to take a core from a shallower blank. I've got some ideas on how to work around that, but they'll have to perculate for a couple of weeks.

I'm going to stop by my local ReStore tomorrow & see if they have any chunks of laminated beams to save myself a little work.

Leo

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#19

Re: check out this homemade coring rig

john lucas

Leo Glad your working on one. I will not have time to even think about it for several more months. As near as I can tell with my limited experience in coring, all cutters are parts of a circle. You just enter the wood at slightly different angles to get steeper of flatter bowls.

The blanks won't be perfect half spheres so you will have to allow thicker walls or a thicker bottom so you can re-turn them later.

To make this more visual think of a large arc entered at less than 90 degrees to the surface. The cored blank would more closely resemble a V with curved sides. Conversely if you enter the blank at greater than 90 degrees the core would be more of flattened part of a circle with the bottom being dimpled or thinner.

Naturally you would have to allow much thicker walls to compensate for these odd shapes but it will allow you to get bowls of different dimensions than a half sphere.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#20

Leo Cuellar

Re: check out this homemade coring rig

Leo Cuellar

John, that is true with a conventional coring knife system where one can vary the angle of attack. But with this system the geometry is fixed. If one sets the post off center the knife won't follow the arc of the curve and will bind in the cut. If one try's to make the knife in any other arc that doesn't relate to that center pivot the same thing will happen. Unfortunately this system is limited to hemispheres, but that is perfect if one wants nested bowls. Draw a line to simulate the blank on a piece of paper & bend a piece of wire to simulate whatever curve you want on your knife from that fixed pivot point and you will see the dilemma. Not the end of the world though. As you said taking thicker sections will still allow lots of shape variations. It might be possible to sustain a flatter arc by taking the blade out with a straight section of flat bar then beginning the curve at the appropriate distance from the pivot. Or just don't throw away the old system for those special cases. In any event, I'm going to have fun playing with this for a while to come. I'm glad you found this in the first place. :) When this starts to look like something, I'll post some pics. I haven't had time to figure out i-Movie yet either :\ so a video may be a ways out yet.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#21

Leo Cuellar

I found out how far out of round I was...

Leo Cuellar

John! :D Way off, but it did work. I took a shallow section as I didn't really have any large pieces of wood. Can be a little difficult reverse engineering from an unclear (on details) video. I didn't need to attach a lever bar as the gentleman in the video did. It actually cut pretty well with a piece of HSS planer knife brazed on as cutter.





Got a little bit of burn from binding but not as bad as expected. With a thick blank, you could also make a stack of bowls all the same diameter. I put on a "retired" welding glove to hold the core when I got near the center, but it (the core) just fell on the floor away from my side of the lathe.

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#22

Re: check out this homemade coring rig

Bob Macgregor

This is just a trivial quibble...but the blank cut out can never be quite a hemisphere, because the pivot point must be outside the wood, so part of the radius must always be excluded from the blank even at the closest setting. Moving the pivot point further away from the mother blank will yield a shallower arc in the daughter (ie, an even lesser part of the hemispherical arc of the cutter).

Seeing this makes me regret not having the set-up (or skills!) to fabricate nifty gadgets and tools like this one.

BOB

Re: check out this homemade coring rig *LINK*

#23

Leo Cuellar

Re: check out this homemade coring rig

Leo Cuellar

Hi, Bob, your points are quite true. I was for the most part just trying to simplify the issue for the sake of discussion. Right now my major issue is trying to keep a cutter on the system. While I have brazed all kinds of like metals together and filled in huge holes in machine casings, I have never tried brazing HSS to mild steel on such a small surface. This is proving to be more problematic than I'd anticipated. I have a new compound to try tonight and hopefully that might give me better results.

After I work out more of the details, I'll be more than happy to share the info so that you can get somebody in your area to help you out with making some, if that is something you're interested in.

Leo