Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Rotten Maple

Posts

Rotten Maple

#1

Rotten Maple

Bob Edwards


I think it was John Jordan that was quoted as saying something to the effect that there is too much good wood to turn bad wood. Or something like that. Well this proves his point. This maple was fresh cut and stored in a sealed plastic bag for about five weeks. Not just spaulted but rotten!

9"h X 7"w.

Re: Rotten Maple

#2

Re: Rotten Maple

robo hippy

Me experience with maple (big leaf, silver and sugar) is that it degrades very quickly. If not in a dry environment, it will be punky in a month or three, and totally gone in a year. Must be all the sugar which is so good for all those little nasties that love to devour our wood.

robo hippy

Re: Rotten Maple

#3

Re: Rotten Maple

Bob Edwards

You are exactly right, I just waited about ten days to long. The exercise will hone you skills however and teach you to keep your tools sharp.

Re: Rotten Maple

#4

Rob Wallace

Correct me if I'm wrong - the John Jordan quote...

Rob Wallace

....you are referring to is, "Life is to short to turn crappy wood."

I have adopted this philosophy as part of my life's mantra. ;)

I also (literally) bought the T-shirt....thanks Ruth!

Rob Wallace

Re: Rotten Maple

#5

Re: Rotten Maple

R Henrickson

A couple years ago, my next-door neighbor had to have her large streetside maple removed since it was dead. It was one of the hard maples. I took whatever wasn't cracked, so I got a huge supply. Much was already spalted to some degree, which made it more attractive. I sealed the ends with Anchorseal. Some logs got put in my (detached unheated/uncooled) garage. Others I sawed in half through the pith, coated the ends, stacked them on my driveway along the north side of a fence (so they had no direct sun exposure), and simply covered them with some thick paper (yard-trash bags) for minimal rain/snow protection. In the last couple weeks, I've started finally pulling some out and turning. A bit of trouble with minor cracking on some, but none have rotted or even gotten discolored. The pile has been covered with snow and indirectly soaked with rain.

Re: Rotten Maple

#6

Re: Correct me if I'm wrong - the John Jordan quot

ken ward

Guess I'm the wierd one :D cause I love worki with that stuff,love that piece,beautifull :)

Re: Rotten Maple

#7

JJ is right about not turning....

JamieDonaldson

..."crappy wood" to some degree, but some of us also accept the challange of using such imperfections as "design opportunities." :D

Re: Rotten Maple

#8

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Rotten Maple

Lyle Jamieson

You people miss the point. Is that nice turning you have there worth $7,000.00???? Thats what one of our members medical bills were from a piece that came apart and ripped his arm apart. He was not even cutting at the time the piece flew apart. This is dangerous stuff and lots of you folks get lucky for a while, but sooner or later you are going to get a wake up call. One mentioned minor cracking...thats like partly pregnant. If its cracked or punky, throw it away.

With all that said I am one who does mostly non functional turning. I love a falt or flaw that I can make into a feature in the vessel. BUT, I always eliminate any cracks and make sure the void is surounded with solid wood. "Life's too short to use crappy wood" another way of putting it "You could shorten your life with crappy wood" Lyle

Re: Rotten Maple

#9

some are more chicken than others

bob davis

Re: Rotten Maple

#10

Steve Kubien

That's uncalled for

Steve Kubien

Lyle doesn't need my help but Bob, this is out of line. There are a lot of of less experienced turners here on WC (and some very experienced ones) who can really benefit from a wake-up call like Lyle is giving. Don't agree? Look through this site and others and look at the horror-show of stories we have about people getting hurt by premature dismounts, flying debris and even the bandsaw where it is supposed to be kind of tough to get hurt.

Thank you Lyle.

Re: Rotten Maple

#11

Re: That's uncalled for

Barry Irby

Got nothing to do with being chicken. The lathe and the wood doesn't know or care if you are chicken. Neither do any of the other tools. They will maim or kill a bear as quickly as they will a chicken and think nothing of it. Because they they don't think.

A cavalier attitude will get you hurt of hurt or killed. I know because I have been to lax on too many occasions and have suffered because of it.

Lets be careful and enjoy this wonderful hobby to the fullest with all our parts intact and alive.

Re: Rotten Maple

#12

Steven Antonucci

Teaching a proper stance

steven antonucci

Perhaps the single most important thing that we can teach as woodturning instructors is the stance at the lathe. If you have the correct stance, you reduce the odds of being where a disintegrating turning will go.

I watch new turners stand on top of their work and one of the first things I work on is getting them out of harm's way. I have stuff come off the lathe all of the time, but I am never where it is going. Learning about the line of fire and the physics of turning is a very important lesson for a new turner to grasp.

I also see lots of watches and rings in YouTube videos. Folks sanding without removing the tool rest. All of these things increase your chances of injury as much as turning "crappy wood".

If you are behind the gouge, with the flute turned away from your body, you greatly reduce the risk of being hurt by flying wood. Cutting under control is the key. To many beginners rush the cut, which stresses the wood and can sometimes cause a failure, even in good wood.

Steve

Re: Rotten Maple

#13

Re: That's uncalled for

Harry Robinette-Woodspinner

THAT'S beyond uncalled for,that is rude and unbelievable to even conceder.Lyle is just trying to help.I've

had a bowl blow up on me and cut up my hand and arm. Plus bruises and scratches clear-up to my head.

Just because I thought one little crack wasn't nothing.

Also I have a hard time being here with people able to post ----like that.

Re: Rotten Maple

#14

Katherine Kowalski

Re: some are more chicken than others

Katherine Kowalski

Bob,

Perhaps you are not aware of Lyle's extensive experience and reputation in the field of woodturning. I guarantee you he's turned more wood than you've ever dreamed of. Respect his professional experience, even if you are unwilling to follow his advice. His recommendation is sound, and one I completely support.

Katherine

Re: Rotten Maple

#15

Re: some are more chicken than others

Jim Rutten

No offense guys but I don't think Bob meant that in the way you guys think. I was in Bob's woodturning guild for a while and a kinder gentleman you could not meet. Please don't rush to judgement.

Re: Rotten Maple

#16

Alan Zenreich

Re: some are more chicken than others

Alan Zenreich

Jim,

That was my thought too. My guess is that he was trying to be witty, but touched on a (rightfully) sore point.

His profile indicates that he's 86 years old, and as such, I'd give him the benefit of the doubt due to his life experience. It's often easy to miss the intent of posts... there's no voice or facial expressions to help explain the words used.

Re: Rotten Maple

#17

Rotten Maple

Bob Edwards

Who knew a simple three line post with picture could incur such a response.

Let's start with the comment I attributed to John Jordan. It was not a direct quote and I didn't feel the need to research it for accuracy. That's why I followed the comment with �Or something like that.�

The point was that I agreed with the comment without feeling the need to go into a two page dissertation as to why. There are many reasons to avoid rotten, punky, spaulted wood. Not the least of which is breathing the dust produced. That's why I ware a TOTOBOBO dust mask and promote it's use whenever possible. But I wasn't pushing safety from dust inhalation any more than the hazard from turning unstable wood or wood with cracks. Lyle Jamieson is a highly respected professional turner with a wealth of experience and I accept his opinion as I am sure it is well intended. But I'm sure Lyle occasionally dose something he wouldn't recommend to a beginner. I'm no Lyle Jamieson but I am 70 years old and I've been enjoying this hobby for over 35 years. I still enjoy pushing the envelope occasionally but not without taking reasonable precautions. Precautions I don't intend to attach to every photo I post. And I don't need the benefit of anyones doubt because of my age.

If someone posts a picture of his/her work you and feel strongly enough about the form or the shape or the finish or whatever to make a respectful comment have at it. But don't assume they produced the piece in an unsafe or inappropriate manner.

Bob Edwards

Re: Rotten Maple

#18

Alan Zenreich

Re:  Rotten Maple

Alan Zenreich

Bob Edwards...

Just to be clear, the posts regarding age and the inappropriateness of the message were not aimed at you... they were referring to the (zero line) post about some being more chicken than others.... made by Bob Davis.

Too many Bobs.

Re: Rotten Maple

#19

Re: some are more chicken than others

bob davis

thank you jim. i have known lyle jameison for years. infact he was my guest the first time he demoed in kc.. to state that one should never work with punky wood is ridiculous..obviously proper precautions should be taken. lyle introduced me to the elsworth grind which i still use. no malice was intended.sometimes my humor is too deep for some

Re: Rotten Maple

#20

Re:  Rotten Maple

John Jordan

Bob, I am often credited for saying "life is too short to turn crappy wood" The actual word was not crappy, but...... :) I'm sure I'm not the first to express similar sentiments.

The statement is not really aimed at what's safe or not, but rather the extraordinary effort turners often put into low quality wood that will never yield a good piece. That very often is "spalted" wood, but as you pointed out, sometimes that just means rotten. Your piece looks pretty good, so I guess whatever extra time you spent was worth it to you. :D

I don't use cracked or defective wood, so I don't think about that aspect of safety, much.

John

Re: Rotten Maple

#21

Re: Teaching a proper stance

John Jordan

No offense meant, Steve, but I can't imagine knocking work off the lathe "all the time". It would indicate a problem(s) and should not be a common occurrence, IMO. :)

John

Re: Rotten Maple

#22

Re:  Rotten Maple

Bob Edwards

Thanks for your input John. I knew I wasn't quoting you correctly but was sure I got the meaning right.

I wasn't addressing all the safety issues involved just agreeing with you. Thanks for realizing that. Sometimes my Irish pig headed stubbornness won't let me give up on a challenge and that's all it was. But I was pleased with the piece and it underlined the need for sharp tools and good technique.

BTW I know you meet a lot of turners and can't remember them all but to put a face to my name, I organized and acted as moderator for the SIG night for Newbies at the Albuquerque Symposium. I never got to thank you for taking part. As expected you added greatly to the discussion. Thanks again!!

Bob Edwards

Re: Rotten Maple

#23

Steven Antonucci

depends upon what you are turning

steven antonucci

The two most common things that cause early dismounts in my shop are thin spindles and cutting through vessels (aka "knocking work off the lathe"). I have made wands and thin stemmed goblets, and it's not 1 out of 2, but maybe 1 out of 5 that the grain runs funny or a bug hole is in the middle of the 1/8" section and something snaps.

Cutting vessels (as you know) requires a lot of careful measuring. Every once in a while, I make a bowl out of a hollowform. The key is to make sure you are never standing in the line of fire, and so the "proper stance" keeps you from being hit by anything that might happen.

Now if I had me one of them laser contraptions ;) (in case Lyle is watching)

S

Re: Rotten Maple

#24

Lyle Jamieson

Re: depends upon what you are turning

Lyle Jamieson

Yes, You would never get a catch and be in complete control of the wall thickness. Want to do paper thin...no problem. :-)

Re: Rotten Maple

#25

Re: Teaching a proper stance

robo hippy

I learned to stand out of the line of fire by turning sloppy wet green wood. In wet years here, you will be able to wring out your turning smock in an hour or two. You especially learn to stand out of the way if the wood doesn't smell good like cottonwood.

As far as turning punky wood, I don't. When it comes to selling, the extra work you have to put into it costs you more than you can get back out of it. You have to turn more slowly as slower rpm, lighter cuts, and take way more care when cutting to prevent accidents. Then you have to add wood hardener, or CA glue so you can sand and finish. Most of the times, just not worth the effort. Nothing to do with being 'more chicken than others' and all about 'efficiency is intelligent laziness'.

robo hippy