Extreme wood movement
Scott Hurley in N VA
I've had pieces move as they dried, but this piece of cherry is the worst. I don't think there's enough wood to get it round again...
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Extreme wood movement
Scott Hurley in N VA
I've had pieces move as they dried, but this piece of cherry is the worst. I don't think there's enough wood to get it round again...
Re: Extreme wood movement
Scott Hurley in N VA
Sorry, the picture didn't come through. I'm still learning photobucket. One more try!
Re: Extreme wood movement
Walt Bennett
Now if you just pick up a VOD oval turning chuck, you could make that into a nice oval bowl!
Re: Extreme wood movement
Barry Irby
That is pretty extreme, but the determining factor is on the other side. How thick did you leave the blank? Measure the width at the narrowest point on the outside and the longest length on the inside. If its longer than wide, no go.
Actually, you could partially turn it and then sand it into submission by hand.
Re: Extreme wood movement
Barbara Gill
I have had some of the bottom boards in the kiln twist with the weight of around 1000 pounds on the top. Wood movement can be awesome.
Re: Extreme wood movement
Brad Vietje
Scott,
That's a lot of movement -- looks more like the shrinkage I've seen in Apple. You probably have reaction wood there. Looks like a design opportunity -- maybe this is your introduction to a carved and/or textured bowl... could stir up all sorts of creative juices, and be the beginnings of a whole new direction in your turning career! OR -- you could send it to someone who does all manner of carving and texturing as a collaboration piece...
I hope you find a way to have fun with it!
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: Extreme wood movement
John Lucas
Scott I turned a piece of Wysteria Vine that was 10" in diameter. It warped so bad it will not go back on the lathe. I am going to have to hand carve that one.
Re: Extreme wood movement
Ken Ward
Been there done it,so I know your pain
made some nice bon fires though 
Re: Campfire wood
Joe Fleming
I agree with Ken. I keep bowls like this only for the show and tell value when teaching how to rough green wood. Otherwise, it is firewood. I think we frugal woodturners spend too much time salvaging junk. If you want to experiment with carving, or odd shaped bowls, that's fine. But this is found wood, more than likely, so spending hours doing something that is not interesting to you is wasting more time than the wood is worth.
I keep a large trash can full of offcuts and assorted lathe goof-ups. I give it to the local teenagers when they want to build a beach fire.
Joe Fleming, San Diego
Re: Extreme wood movement
Doug Trembath
Scott, I agree with Barry, in that if the wall of the bowl was left wide enough, you should be able to turn this. If, however, it was down around 3/4 to 1/2 inch, it's probably a Frisbee that won't fly too well.

Heck, put it on the lathe, line up the toolrest, and see just how much meat will be left, and then turn it. Make it a plate, and give it to a good friend, so you'll always have the story of the one that didn't get away...
Doug Trembath