Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

vibration

Posts

vibration

#1

Jack Guzman from Maine

vibration

Jack Guzman from Maine

I don't post here. I mostly do flat work with non powered tools. I do turn occasionally though. Mostly tool handles and such. I own a Grizzly lathe.It goes to 36" between centers and has variable speed controlled by the opening of the driven pulley. I just replaced the belt. The old one broke after 9 years.

I recently started making windsor chairs. As a result my lathe is getting alot more use. Before the belt broke I turned a set of baluster type legs out of dry firewood to practice the leg making. The wood is ash. I had no problems. I did have to sharpen all my turning tools. They were suffering from neglect. The belt broke while I was roughing a green blank of red maple that I got to make the first keeper leg. The roughing chisel caught on a protruding knob on the blank and the belt couldn't take it. I replaced the belt and started all over. Now I find that after roughing in and starting to shape the leg the piece vibrates on contact with the chisel. Any chisel. If I hold the piece the chisel cuts fine but when I take my hand away the piece starts vibrating again. I reshaped all my chisels according to Leonard Lee's sharpening recommendations and it makes no difference. I'm using a 1" roughing gouge ,a large skew with a bevel on each side and a curved edge,a 3/4" spindle gouge and a 1/4" spindle gouge. Even my parting tool vibrates. Is this because of the green wood? Help.I have turned four green legs so far and it still vibrates whenever I put a tool to the wood.---Jack

Re: vibration

#2

Re: vibration

robo hippy

Rule of thumb for spindle turning is a ratio of 10 to 1, which means a spindle 1 inch diameter and 10 inches long will not vibrate or whipping is another term I have heard. If you are getting the vibrations when you are in the middle of the spindle, and not when you are near the headstock or tailstock, this is what is going on. If you really crank down on the tailstock, that can add to the vibrations as the wood is under pressure and any side pressure will make vibrations more severe. You do need to have it snug enough to stay on, but not too tight. There are steady rests available, and ones that you can make fairly simply. Old timers learned to use one hand behind the wood, opposite the cutting tool to stabilize the wood. The pressure from your hand is the same as the pressure from the tool. Also, start at the tail stock end, and work towards the headstock.

If this isn't the problem, then some thing on the lathe is loose, like tailstock, headstock, how you mounted the blank, or maybe the pulley set up.

robo hippy

Re: vibration

#3

Re: vibration

Barry Irby

Jack, I am assuming you have checked your mounting of the pieces and they are secure. And that the bearings are not shot and allowing the shaft to vibrate?

If you are turning a long thin spindle they will deflect and vibrate near the middle. Green wood is much more flexible than dry wood and will have more tendency to vibrate. If you cut near the ends f the spindle where the drive center or tailstock will support eh wood you should have less or almost no vibration. If it vibrates worse near the center, this is most likely your problem. (If you got a defective belt or one not suitable for this application, it probably vibrates whether you are cutting or not.)

So if its a long thin spindle that is vibrating what can you do? You can practice your techniques and find which methods of cutting produce the least vibration. Use really sharp tools, take light cuts, etc. You can support the work with your hand. (May not be the best Idea and will lead to callouses.) You can sue a piece of High density plastic in your hand as a support. You can make or buy a spindle steady. There are as many designs as there are people using them. Anything from pieces that have a vee in them to set ups with rollers. To some extent what you use depends on what you want to spend and how much effort you want to put into it. If you are doing one chair, the answer Amy be different than if you are doing dozens.

You may be able to search for "spindle steady" and get more info here.

One last thought. If you are putting too much pressure on the ends of the piece with the tailstock really cranked in, you may be able to reduce it somewhat by backing off the pressure slightly. Get the spurs seated really well and then loosen the tailstock very slightly, enough to take the compression off but not release the piece.

Re: vibration

#4

Re: vibration

Fred Holder

If you only have a few spindles to turn, a string steady such as Escoulen uses to turn very thin spindles might serve your purpose.


This photo was taken at one of his demonstrations in 2006. I've made one myself for occasional use on small stuff.

Re: vibration

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks

Jack Guzman from Maine

That was fast. As I am turning more spindles as soon as I finish this,I'm very grateful.

Yes, It does get worse toward the center. It's a 20" spindle at 1"-2" in diameter. I did have the tailstock a little snug. Seeing there's only 4 legs per chair I think I can get by with just using my hand and I think it will help if I perfect my sharpening skills. Also I will back the pressure off the tailstock a bit. One more question. Will honing the tools after grinding help or hinder? Right now I'm going straight from the grinder.

Thanks for all your help.---Jack

Re: vibration

#6

Re: Thanks

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Hone your skew, not the others.

Re: vibration

#7

one more tip

John Lucas

turn from the middle out. I know it seems awkward at first but if you turn the middle details and work toward then ends you will get less chatter because the wood on the ends is thicker which supports the work.

when you do get chatter change the angle of the skew or gouge very slightly and reduce the pressure you put on the bevel of the tool. Pushing on the bevel is what makes the wood vibrate in the first place. Changing the angle of the cutting edge will tend to take off the high points of the chatter and make it easier to get rid of the marks.

Re: vibration

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

You folks are great

Jack Guzman from Maine

Sounds like good advice. Anything that helps.

I ought to check this place out more often. You people are very helpful.---Jack

Re: vibration

#9

Dick Hines

Re: You folks are great

Dick Hines

The group of turners on this site may be the best in the world. Of courls there people from around the world that check this site.

Come on back.

Re: vibration

#10

Brad Vietje

Re: and then another tip...

Brad Vietje

Hello Jack,

Sounds like you are going through belts pretty quickly, too. You'll get different answers on this from various sources, but since you are making light cuts to avoid flexure and vibration, I'd loosen the belt just a little, too, so it is not tempted to snap under stress.

Another trick I learned from Mark Sfirri is to drive spindle pieces with an old "cup" center or "dead" center, instead of the typical drive spur with 4 teeth. That way, if you get a catch, the piece simply stops, and you can adjust the friction between the drive center and the blank. This will prevent a broken belt if there's a catch, and can prevent a nasty bonk on the noggin' if something goes wrong. It's also a good way to train yourself to make light, smooth cuts with sharp tools, so you don't cause the wood to stop.

If you are driving the teeth of the drive center into the end of the blank with the tailstock feed, you put a lot of stress on the bearings (and make the flexure worse), so if you stay with the spur drive, consider tapping it into the wood with a wooden mallet or beetle, instead of the tailstock, OR, back off the tail stock a little once the teeth have bitten into the wood to reduce flexure of the spindle blanks.

Thanks for visiting the turning forum -- I hope you'll come back often, and hey -- don't forget to show us the chair when it's done! ;)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: vibration

#11

HeyCompadre *LINK*

Jorge Casta�eda

Jack,

if you are going trough belts, check the alignment of the pulleys, they me be not perfectly aligned, that causes a lot of wear; also leave the belt a little loose rather than tight.

We have now several turning clubs in Maine! Here is the address of the main group, but there are two close to you, the other groups are listed there, check it out and hope you join one, there is where I've learned the most and enjoyed a really nice bunch of fellows.


Maine woodturners