Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

"Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

Posts

"Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#1

"Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

charlie belden

In an earlier post, I described an old method of exploiting two of wood's characteristics

- that its grain can be compressed/crushed

- that it expands as it absorbs moisture

If you compress/crush the wood's grain

- such that you create a depressed pattern

- then remove wood down to near the bottom of the depressed pattern

- then steam the wood

your pattern becomes raised above its background.

Turns out the Japanese woodworkers have been exploiting this idea for quite a while,

long enough to give it a name - Ukibori.

Thought I'd give it a try - since I had the chasing hammer and ball end metal punches.

Found the bottom of a small lidded box I never finished. Chucked it up, punched some

hemispherical depressions, turned the surface down to near the bottom of the depressions

and put the piece in a little vegetable steamer.

Here's what I got, along with a pic of the "punches" and chasing hammer used. Took

about 5 minutes of tapping and should have only taken a minute or so with the wood

exposed to steam.


I should have

a) sanded to at least 600 rather than stopping at 320. Better yet, should

have done a light shear cut on the last pass rather than scraping

b) steamed the piece just long enough for the "frog bumps to rise"

instead of steaming for 10 minutes and having the grain split apart

in some places. The "frog bumps" appeared within less than a minute

of encountering steam - but I figured More Is Better

(which often is totally not true)

I've since taken a curved, polished agate burnisher to the surfaces

and smoothed the raised grain. Piece got shinier - without losing

the bumps.

Interesting possibilities with this thing. Tear dropped punches, with rounded

edges, concentric circular ridges punch, flat cone punches, heart shaped

punches. Lots of possibilities.

If you decide to play with this technique PLEASE post what you find and

how you used it - with photos of course.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#2

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

Cyril Griesbach

Nicely done, Charlie. Our mini turning group has just started to experiment with this process with a bit less success than you've made. We used automatic center punches and perhaps did not get enough compression with them. In any case we will continue with our efforts.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#3

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

Jorge Casta�eda

Charlie,

Ukibori looks good, how do they finish it? Lacquer?

Thanks for posting.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#4

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

Mike Foster

Charlie, that is really cool and something I may have to try. Never really considered this method, but I already have several ideas on how I would use it. Thanks for posting the info. It's always fun to try something new like this.

Mike

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#5

Richard Allen

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

Richard Allen

The wood species is important in this process. The wood needs to be compressible. Cocobolo is not going to work. Soft maple is a better choice. Beech, Birch, Box elder, Bradford Pear... Open grain woods like walnut, butternut, red oak... are not well suited to this punch and steam technique.

There are loads and loads of leather punches which can work well for this process. Compress the wood, dent the wood but don't break the wood. Steaming will not repair broken wood.

You can also dye wood before bringing the level down to the bottom of the depressions. That will provide a color to the resultant tops of the bumps. Note the dye should not be water soluble as the steaming could cause the dye on the bump tops to run.

This is just techniques. It is not art. The technique can be used in an artistic way.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#6

Cyril Provided The Term Ukibori *LINK*

charlie belden

- and with a name - made it easy to do a google search for examples. And THAT

lead to the attached link to Janel Jacobson's exquisite netsuke carvings that will

will quietly take your breath away. The page linked to shows the process from

chunk of wood to the finished piece - including the Ukibori process used on the

frogs in the piece. The detail shot at the bottom of the page should give you

a pretty good idea of what is possible with this technique.

I strongly suggest that you also explore the rest of her site and see all the

other of her works. Amazing artistry - carrying on a very old tradition.


You HAVE to see this

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#7

Neat site, thanks for sharing that.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I have a piece in mind for starting soon, and had done a test run, which was successful, but then, where I was planning on using it, would be end-grain. I'll bet that won't work as easily as perpendicular to it. What do you think?

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#8

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

charlie belden

Cyril:

The advantage of using a hand held punch and a chasing hammer over a spring loaded punch

is that you can position the handheld punch more easily - and control how hard you hit it

(actually it's more like a firm tap than a struck blow).You can also reregister the punch in a

previous "stamped" pattern - and tap the punch again to deepen the depression. This lets

you produce different height bumps based on how hard you tap the punch.

I think, by angling the ball end punch, I could get tear drop shaped bumps, one end of the

depression being shallower than the other. One of the keys to getting this to work is to

compress the side grain rather than tearing/cutting it. Sharp points will do the latter - a no-no.

Works best on side grain. Not so good on open grained woods though. I'm going to try it on

some grapefruit wood next. Am also wondering how dyes might be used to enhance the bumps

- say a light airbrushed coat of dark dye, sanded lightly to remove it from the high spots of the

bumps, then a sight airbrushed honey or yellow dye to pop the bumps a little. Or maybe use

a fine brass bristled brush in my foredom to burnish the surfaces - and maybe leave some brass

behind. Have more surfaces on my test piece that I can experiment on.

Plenty of interesting possibilities with this Ukibori technique.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#9

Re: Neat site, thanks for sharing that.

charlie belden

Tough to compress end grain. And being The Ends Of Straws Like, probably would absorb a lot more moisture and more quickly than compressed side grain. But often what seems intuitively not possible turns out to be possible - the big bodies bumble bee with the small wings as a great example of what seems impossible - but isn't. The DO fly.

You're assignment, should you choose to accept it is - to try it and see what happens - on a test piece of course - and report back your findings. As always, this tape will self destruct in ten seconds . . . . phhhhhht.

(the idea of a reel to reel portable tape recorded seems so archaic today)

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#10

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

charlie belden

Jorge:

Until Cyril provided a name for this technique I had no idea that it has been used for a hundred

years or more in Japan - and probably several other countries. I'm no expert on it - just thought

it was something to play with - and it worked - satisfactorily. But if you were to do a little web

surfing and find how they finish pieces - PLEASE report back your findings. If you try it and try

finishing it - and you find things that work - PLEASE report back your experiences.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#11

I had my tool in a hammer drill, just on impact.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Without any rotation, which was pretty easy to control.

I was thinking of using it on end-grain cherry for dragonfly eyes. I like to work green wood on projects like this, so that might ease the compression, if it doesn't just pop right back up.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#12

Had to try it

Mike Foster

I was so intrigued with this I had to try it. Like I said, I have a couple of pieces in mind that this would be perfect for. I can see it will take a little messing around with to get what I want, but it is a really cool technique. I covered the surface of this disc with dimples hoping for the inverse when exposed to moisture. As you can see, it was only partially successful. I just used a rounded nail to make the depressions. I would guess the nail was a little less than 1/8" and I made the pattern covering the surface. I thought I was making consistent depressions, but maybe not. I used a piece of curly soft maple, and the curl may have caused some differences in wood expansion, but it doesn't seem to correlate with the bumps. I may have to try a little larger tool and shoot for a more consistent depth. It's a really neat trick, and one that may find a place in my work. I'll post anything that I come up with it, but that may be a while. Thanks again, Charlie, for posting the technique.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#13

Leo Cuellar

Very cool, Charlie!

Leo Cuellar

Thanks for doing the leg work on this. Not sure that I'll use it right away, but its enlightening too learn about these things :)

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#14

Steven Antonucci

Dennis Fuge demonstrated this to WGW 2 yrs ago

steven antonucci

He referred to it as Ostrich skin, but it was a neat effect regardless.

I never did anything with it, but I might revisit. Thanks for opening the vault...

S

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#15

Pretty Neat

Tony - Memphis

I was fisrt introduced to this concept by Frank Klauz. He used it to make a water tight joint for a sharpening stone trough on The Woodright's Shop. He used a piece of copper wire to form the indention, planed the surface as you described, then wet it after it was assembled. I also read about this ina FWW book on carving. The lady in the article had carved some frogs and used this technique to make the bumps on their backs. Neat stuff.

Tony

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#16

Dang it!

Dave Belser

That was on my secret list of cool ideas to try, now you went and told everyone!

Thankfully the Japanese have been doing it for a long time and named it. I played with this on a really small scale and realized that it was a cool textured idea.

I love it when I "Discover" a new ancient technique. It shows how ideas and techniques are so interrelated and connected that they often logically flow from one to then next.

Thanks for sharing Charlie, look forward to seeing more if this kind of work.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#17

Re: I had my tool in a hammer drill, just on impac

Charlie belden

With something like this, a power tool, like an impact driver, works way to fast - and even if it's relatively small, like the Foredom's Reciprocating Handpiece (about the diameter of your thumb), it's difficult to control the location of the tip of the tool. You also don't have as much control over the depth of impact.

With a hand held punch and hand held chasing hammer, things happen at a much more Human Speed and with human control. This is a finesse technique, not a Get It Done Quick thing at all. Place the punch where you want it and tap. If the little dimple is where you want it - tap again and harder. If it isn't right where you want it, move the punch a little and tap again. If the dimple isn't deep enough, reregister the punch in the dimple and tap it a little harder. My point is that hand held, hand operated tools allow time for feedback - and the opportunity to make little adjustments. With a power tool, by the time you sense something's just not right - the power tool has already made the same mistake - 5, 10 or 50 times.

The other difference between hand tool work and power tool work is the range of tools available. I can make punches/stamping tools, in a range of sizes and simple patterns with tools and materials I have or can easily and inexpensively get - nails, steel rod, hacksaw, needle files, grinder. No tap & die sets, no machinist lathe required that are needed to make a tool that threads into a power tool.

Another thing about using Off The Shelf tips that will fit in your particular power tool is their tips' profiles. Sharp points and sharp corners tend to sever wood grain rather than just compress it. With this technique it's compression you're after, not severed or split grain. Power tools also used hardened steel - which is harder to "adapt" than mild steel rod or a nail. Power tool tips also are seldom polished - and you want the working surface of your punches to be as smooth and polished as is reasonably possible since every pit, ding or scratch will be in the surface you're creating. This is far more important when working on metal - like copper, brass, silver or gold. With metal, the tool is stamping a pattern in the metal AND burnishing the resulting surface to make it shiny as well.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#18

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Hi Charlie,

This is very neat! I am going to give this a try. I wonder if I could just hold the piece over a pot of boiling water to get the steam effect? I don't have a steamer, but ah, wait, maybe the veggie steamer from the kitchen... :)

Thanks for sharing, that's a neat technique.

Mike

Heading to the woodshop this afternoon in Apex, NC!

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#19

Wonder if you could do ...

Barry Irby

micro bumps on something like cocobolo. Very small indentations then remove a thin layer and wet the surface. You might be able to create bumps you could feel better than see. Braille anyone?

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#20

Re: Dang it!

Charlie belden

Dave:

There's very little new under the sun, which is why I think "creativity" - literally making something from nothing - is a myth. Now combining existing things in ways they've not yet been combined, or applying some technique developed for one purpose - to another purpose, or medium - THAT is Synthesis. And EVERYONE can do that. How well? That's mainly a function of practice - the more you do it, the better you can get at it - if you pay attention.

As for Secret Lists Of Things To Try - why keep secrets? When I was in college there was a ceramics prof who had all sorts of secret glaze formulas - one that was his Signature Formula - a crystaline glaze - which he never revealed - to ANYONE. That flew in the face of what I think a TEACHER should be - one who shares as much of what he knows about a subject with any student who wants to learn it.

Back in the late 70s and early 80s there was a metal artist who did beatiful little scenes out of scrap copper and foils, brasing rods and copper wire - a little miner's cabin stuck on the side of a river, a rickety little bridge spanning to the far side of the river to connect the cabin to the rest of the world. After a year or two, other folks started doing Knock Offs of his stuff - cheap. They weren't very good Knock Offs, lacking details and subtle coloring and weathering of Originals. I asked him how he felt about people doing Knock Offs of his works, and usually not very good Knock Offs.

His response. By the time someone else figures out what I've already figured out and have been using - I'm taking things in a different direction, or have developed another set of techniques, built on what I've already learned to do - and use - my way (he'd gotten into playing with a Bamboo theme. Like the early bird getting the worm, the artist who gets there first is usually the one who makes the money. The Copy Cats usually work at laborers wages.

Now when it comes to SYNTHESIZING - any Wild Hair Idea I come up with pales in comparison with the REALLY Wild Hare Ideas YOU come up with. A bundle of little sticks, frozen in ice - then turned - before the ice melts!

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#21

Re: Wonder if you could do ...

Charlie belden

Dense, resinous woods probably wouldn't take to this technique very well. But who knows, it might work. When YOU try it let us know how it worked.

The idea of using this technique to put a braile message on a piece - a short exerpt from a poem - or a phrase - perhaps like "It's the blind - who really SEE" (we are primarily visual creatures - sacrificing the full use of our other senses - and "overlooking" much of the beauty around us).

I'd really like to "see" a competition or a show of pieces that would only be experienced by touch. We turners make sensous pieces - that are typically Look But Don't Touch. Why not turn that on its head - Touch But Don't LOOK? Imagine how one of Terry Scott's Winged Pieces or one of J. Paul F's pierced and flowing veins pieces would be perceived or one of Gary Fisher's multi centered and carved pieces would go over. Seeing is one thing - but TOUCHING and exploring with fingertips!?

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#22

Re: Dang it!

Dave Belser

Charlie, it's too bad you don't live closer. The topic at the last meeting of the Guild of New Hampshire Woodworkers - Right Brain Woodworking sub group was creativity. Needless to say we had a lively discussion.

I beg to differ with your definition of create / creative - it's not required to be from nothing, just unique, novel, not evolved or from ordinary processes. There seems to be a certain leap involved. Personally I believe that in only needs to be "local" in nature as in unique or original to the creator. Clearly the more "globally" unique and original - the more substantial the creative act will be considered by humanity but this makes no difference on the personal experience of being creative.

The local-ness relates to the "nothing new under the sun" line of thought - is there such a thing as absolute originality? I get my own thrill every time I come up with a unique/original (to me) idea. If it excites me enough, then endeavor to manifest it - the act of creating.

From nothing - ex nihilo - is really more about The Creation (non-religion specific)

As for my secret list of things, it's not particularly secret. It's just a long accumulated pile of ideas that have occurred to me or that I've barely dabbled with. It is my imaginary sketchbook. I have a very vivid, non-verbal imagination and I can easily with the slightest prompting, remember vividly things that I have thought about years ago and not yet created.

It's really not a lot different than people that keep a continuous sketchbook of ideas. I can't pick it up and leaf through it but if I start thinking about one idea I find that they are all right there.

The act of trying to manifest these ideas always seems to require much more consideration and presence and time.

I was steaming dings out of work with water when I realized that the same process could be used for texture. I "discovered" Ukibori. I spent an afternoon creating turned tops with bumps on them. My brain filled with a wealth of possible ways to exploit this idea. I don't remember what I was actually "supposed" to be working on at the time, but I stopped and got back to the important work, adding this idea to the pile.

Taking time and allowing yourself to actually explore, to be open and present while exploring without a specific goal in mind, is something that a lot of people find very difficult to do. They then turn around and say of themselves "I'm not very creative". I strongly believe that we are all quite creative.

I could have easily spent another day on the bumps, which would of course lead to week and then probably a few more - Instead I stuck to the important stuff I had to do.

You should see my shop at this moment, there is a large collection of cubes of various sizes and species with lots and lots of holes drilled in them. I haven't made what I set out to, I've learned way more then I ever intended to about drilling and the limits of wood, I'm questioning my sanity and motives, I'm not done - and today I order more drill bits.

If only I had a job : )

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#23

Thanks for sharing your insights.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I did make grind the little domed end on the tool I was using, and did polish it.

I may have to try doing it manually, since it was pretty tiring. You know how many facets in a Dragonfly's eye? I've read 30,000, but I'm not so sure that is accurate, nor wanting to make it that realistic, but there are an awful lot of them, so I want to go as fast as I can while still maintaining control.

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

#24

Mike Stafford

Re: "Frog Bumps Texture" - It's EASY

Mike Stafford

The first time I saw this technique was in Hilary Bowen's book "Decorative Techniques for Woodturners". She has a section in the book entitled Altering Surface Texture and within that section she describes techniques for "dimples and pimples".

This book was first published in 1996 or 7 and is a great reference for a variety of techniques of embellishing woodturnings which seems to be the primary reason people turn.

Some of the techniques discussed in the book are incorporating metals, coloring or colouring, lamination and inlay techniques, use of resins, scorching, surface texture etc.