v flute or u flute bowl gouge
James Pittman
I am getting ready to buy some bowl gouges so would someone explain the advantages and disadvantages of differant flutes. Thanks Jim
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
v flute or u flute bowl gouge
James Pittman
I am getting ready to buy some bowl gouges so would someone explain the advantages and disadvantages of differant flutes. Thanks Jim
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge *LINK*
Jorge Casta�eda
James,
For most uses I find the V excellent, sometimes in very wet wood it clogs and the U is better. your work habits are important to consider.
It depends on several factors, what are you doing, how are you going about it etc,
I recommend the Thompson gouges, they are my work horses and if you visit the site read info in there, and nobody better to answer your questions than Doug Thompson himself.
Thompsonlathetools
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
Brad Vietje
James,
In addition to Jorge's comments about chip-clearing (and I agree completely), I'd add that the utility of the two different flute shapes depends on the grind, too. Which will work best for you will also depend on what you make with it. The V-shaped flute has straighter sides -- which can be useful in making very fine, shearing cuts, but mostly it has a much smaller radius at the tip. Generally, when cutting across the tip of the tool, a smaller radius makes a finer cut because there is less contact between steel and wood, and less resistance, and it can get into smaller places. If you use a swept back grind, such as an Irish grind, you can expose that tight radius and you'll find cuts you can make with that tool that a wider tip (U-shaped) can't make, or can't reach as well. It is also much more likely that the bevel geometry will not be the same at the tip as along the sides.
A U-shaped deep fluted gouge can be sharpened to have the same bevel geometry all across the cutting edge, so a rotation of the flute doesn't have to change the cutting angles. This is how David Ellsworth's grind can be used, so you can rotate the tool to use a sharp part you haven't dulled yet. At least that's how I use the two shapes. If I'm wrong about that, you can be sure some one will shout out, and we'll both learn something new 
I like the wider flute of the 5/8" and 1/2" U-shaped bowl gouge for roughing work, especially with green wood, and I usually use a 3/8" V-shaped gouge for finish work. For difficult woods (grainy or highly figured stuff), I usually use a 1/4" bowl gouge, and find that the tighter radius at the tip helps me make a finer cut. If you get a 1/2" V-shaped gouge, you can have a big tool on the sides, and a smaller radius, like the 3/8" or 1/4" at the tip, and possibly get the best of both worlds.
Safe spinning,
Brad Vietje
Newbury, VT
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
The picture shows the V and U shape flutes side by side. As you can see the grind follows the flute shape! The V shape will have a smaller nose radius and straight wings, this is what most turners use. The U shape flute has the large nose radius which can be used for that finish cut inside a bowl or platters etc.

Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
Carole Valentine
Dang! I knew there must be a reason why I preferred the V...just never sat down and thought about why. You have done it for me, Brad! 
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
john lucas
It's hard to see in his photo but I find that the wings on my U shaped gouges have a thinner profile or more acute edge. I use this in some pull cuts to get really clean cuts in difficult woods. The V shaped gouge in the way that I grind it gives me a beefier or more blunt angle to the edge. This is closer to the nose angle and holds an edge longer. This is my most used tool because I can use all the edges for a long time before sharpening.
I have never had my V shaped tool clog up. I guess I'm doing something wrong. 
Probably it is me John...
Jorge Casta�eda
I am a fellow with learning disabilities from way back, so I never got straight that bit about "beving the rubble" :o))
Most of my bowl roughing gets done with pulling cuts kind of like shear scrapping, but it is not scrape, it is a very aggressive cut that removes a lot of wood in a hurry.
Have never warmed to the v-gouge
Aage Rendalen
I have a Thompson v-gouge but I'm obviously not grinding it correctly. This pictures Doug supplied might explain why. I'll have another look at it. I use a Crown 1/2 inch U-gouge for virtually everything. I have worn out half a dozen of them by now (with the Ellsworth grind).
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
robo hippy
The old Glazer gouges had a much steeper V than Doug's V gouge, and I did have problems with it clogging up when doing heavy roughing. I haven't had that problem with Doug's V gouge though. Part of that could be that I mostly use scrapers for my roughing in green wood. To me, that is the more efficient tool. With the higher wings on the V gouge, you can get a better shear cut without rolling the gouge away from the cut. The higher the shear angle, usually, the cleaner the cut. My gouge profiles have gone more to conventional profiles (40 degree sweep, and more rounded nose) than the swept back design. Not really sure why, but they just feel better for me. I use scrapers for shear cuts for cleaning up tool marks rather than the gouges, so dropping the handle and using the wings of the gouge isn't necessary any more. Never could get the hang of that cut.
robo hippy
Re: Probably it is me John...
john lucas
Jorge I don't turn near as many green bowls as you my odds are less.
I do some pretty aggressive pull cuts.
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
The old glaser tools clogged and I opened the flute up so they wouldn't. My turning style is very agressive, heavy cuts with no bevel (right to left) until the final shape starts to appear so I'm using the wings all the time... the v shape flute is perfect for this. Jorge on the other hand uses a PULL cut with a U shape flute, we have two totally different styles, different tools but both very agressive.
You pick a flute shape by the way you want the tool ground that fits your style of turning, don't pick a flute shape because you believe the shavings will flow better.
Flute shape determines the grind, a U shape can't be ground to a Ellsworth fingernail and a V shape can't be ground with a large nose radius. You need to follow the flute shape when grinding like the picture or else you'll lose the cutting angles of the tool... it won't cut.
All pro's use a V shape flute to rough and shape the wood so that is the tool to get first. Years ago at the IndyFest I did a hat demo, when it was done Ray's workbench and shop light was covered with shavings and it was done with a 1/2 inch V shape bowl gouge.
The V flutes or U flutes ...
JamieDonaldson
..on Doug's gouges are not exactly the same as some other brands. In his posted samples, the V is slightly more rounded at the cutting tip than the original Glaser or P&N's that I have used. And the U flute on Doug's gouges are even wider in radius at the cutting tip than the Sorby's I learned on. They have both been welcome additions to my tool collection, and have their own working characteristics that I value.
Doug's Tools R my Faves
Jennifer Indy.USA
Man those look dull.
You need to sharpen those!

Another aggressive V gouge pull cutter here!
steven antonucci
I used to turn a lot more green bowls. I have clogged the flute on a V gouge many times during a rough out.
If you ask me, the long,swept back wings on the gouge and knowing how to use them are the thing that makes me grab for a V gouge more than any other tool I own. I grind the wings back far enough to take almost 1" shavings, so I can usually be round in one or two passes. Cutting that much wood makes a flute clog in about 1" of cutting distance, so I usually cut with about half the wing.
S
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
Jorge Casta�eda
Doug,
As I said, I use the V most of the time, my 1/2" V is the most used in my arsenal and go to the U when in trouble. I would love to see you turning, I am a totally visual person, so learn through my eyes and always willing to try new methods.
When I hear you will be demonstrating I'll try to be there.
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
Jorge Casta�eda
Reed,
I very seldom use a scraper, and I have a bunch of big heavy ones I inherited, we are in opposite ends of the continent, but I would love to see how you use them to rough.
Have you thought about making another DVD, one on bowl making?
They are still there,
Ray Thompson - Middletown, in
at least on the light 8 feet in the air. Some day I may clean it off but for now it begs for a lot of questions.
Ray
Re: v flute or u flute bowl gouge
robo hippy
Jorge,
I am actually in the process of organizing my chapters for a bowl turning DVD. I will have it by next summer's AAW symposium which will be out here on the west coast.
As to scrapers for roughing, well, the cut most used for roughing with a gouge is pretty much a scraping cut, flutes on the side, and pull or push it is much the same cut. With a scraper, you can push and pull without having to change your grip, stance, or handle. I have never had clogging problems with it. One other advantage is the the shavings go up over the top of my hand, not across the top of it, so no more bowl turners callus on my left pinky.
robo hippy
Proof
Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio
It was a great day!!
Dave
Re: Proof
Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio
One more..
Dave 
I miss all that fun...
Doug Thompson near Cleveland
In the fall I'm going to start a sharpening demo hopefully I'll find time to turn.
Thanks Dave, I had lost the pics
Ray Thompson - Middletown, in
I may have more
Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio
Hi Ray,
If I can find them, I will email them to you.
Is your email addy here a good one?
Best wishes,
Dave
Yes it is, and thanks.
Ray Thompson - Middletown, in