Gary Knox Bennet
John Lucas
I got this piece of wood last night at our club meeting. It reminded me too much of Gary Knox Bennet's famous piece with the nail. I'll have to do something special with this and somehow keep the nail. 
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Gary Knox Bennet
John Lucas
I got this piece of wood last night at our club meeting. It reminded me too much of Gary Knox Bennet's famous piece with the nail. I'll have to do something special with this and somehow keep the nail. 
Leave the wood as is, gold plate the nail
steven antonucci
Re: Gary Knox Bennet
charlie belden
I see GNB as a latter version of P.T. Barnum and a contemporary / contemptorary of Alice Cooper. with a hint of Ken Kesey - all terrific self promoters - and to some extent - con men. GNB seems to me to be the woodworking world's Howard Stern and the antithesis of James Krenov.
GNB has a gift for wood and woodworking and the skills and knowledge to use it. Yet he seems to squander it on pieces like a Ladder Back Chair - with the back of the chair an actual ladder - or a massive, and I think, ugly, desk of thick slabs of all heartwood claro walnut joined with giant dovetails. He established himself by driving a nail into a really nice display cabinet he'd done - and bending the nail while driving it. But the Dadaists (see Duchamp's "Fountain") already did the Anti-Art thing.
This man consistently seems to put way too much ego in his work. There's a difference between a good graffitti artist - and a tagger. The former often creates works that provoke thought and reflection, the latter is merely pissing out his territory.
Re: Gary Knox Bennet
Mark Wollschlager
I saw a piece of John Jordan's a few years back that incorporated a nail.
The unmistakable Jordan form had a rusty nail sticking out of the shoulder, proud by at least 1/2".
Quite a save, and a bit more carving that usual.
mark
A contemporary version *LINK*
Greg Haugen
John,
I don't know if you saw this on Mike's blog. Here's a recent bowl that Mike Mahoney made.
Mike Mahoney's Blog with the hook in the bowl
Re: Gary Knox Bennet
Walt Bennett

Can't remember the exact size, but it was around 20" in diameter. I had a wonderful time telling those that asked me how I did that about my new tool invention that could turn around a nail. "My Nail Box" sold in about a month after being put in a gallery.
Re: Gary Knox Bennet *LINK*
John Jordan
Garry Bennett is one of the most talented and generous people I've ever known. The amount of work he has produced is staggering, and he will freely give any knowledge he has, and its considerable, to any one who asks. See the link below.
This piece is silver maple burl. Normally I would have tossed the nail when I pulled it out, but this one laid on my bench. When I carved the piece some months later, the hole was really obvious, so I stuck the nail back in it-which is much easier than carving around it. 
John
Re: A contemporary version
Bob Macgregor
Aaaargh! Captain Hook! I can't imagine turning that with the hook still in it, but if he took it out and replaced it later, it doesn't show.
BOB
Re: Gary Knox Bennet
John Lucas
John Thanks for the link. When I first learned about him it was the controversial back cover of FWW with the Bent nail cabinet. I was new to relatively new to woodworking and striving to make a perfect joint and finish and was appalled by the cover. Of course that was Gary's motive was to say we care too much about this we need to back off and look at why we make things.
Since then I've seen a lot more of his work and read more about him. I've learned to really appreciate what he does. Here's man who thinks like I do, he just has more time and money to do those things.
Re: Gary Knox Bennet
J. Paul Fennell
The history of art is replete with controversy such as this. Some say that the role of the artist is to create work that takes unresolved issues head-on, work that is disturbing, ruffling the feathers of the established art community. The impressionists did this, as did the abstract expressionists, and so on...
If Gary Knox Bennett did not introduce the bent nail onto his beautiful cabinet, who would have remembered the work? And would we be continuing a discussion why the artist did so after all these years have passed?
Well said, J. Paul...
Doug Trembath
So
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
What's with that whole Campbell Soup can thing, anyway?
Now where did I leave my Peter Max posters?
[psssst. These ARE trick questions]
Re: Gary Knox Bennet
charlie belden
I think it's a matter of motive.
If an artist creates a piece that provokes/demands a reaction/response to it - intending to spark thought and discussion of a topic or issue - that's one thing. If an artist creates a piece to grab and focus attention on himself/herself - that's a very different thing. Duchamp's "Fountain" is an example of the former motive - a reaction to the insanity of WW I - and the Status Quo that created that horrible conflict. Howard Stern is a great example of the latter - Look At Me! (and pay me a LOT of money to do so) motive.
In GNB's case - with his Hammer A Nail In A Nice Cabinet piece - he was following the Howard Stern How To Get Famous - and - RICH! Model. I don't think Shock Jocks - or Shock Furniture Makers - are "artists". However, having seen a small can, with a label that reads "Artist's Shit" - in the Centre Georges Pompidou in Paris, my view of what is and what isn't "art" may be completely wrong.
Having looked at the price tags on some of GNB's work, and assuming the pieces sold for the prices given, clearly his Nail In The Cabinet piece has paid off - just as he may have intended. However, unless I was looking for a speculative investment, rather than a piece of art I wanted to be around and enjoy, owning a GNB piece sure wouldn't be on my Acquisition List.
I've never met the man and know him only by the Persona he apparently consciously took to create and apparently maintain it. He lives and works "just up the road" from me. Perhaps I should try and get to know the man a little - and perhaps get passed The Persona to the person behind it.
Wonder if he's in the phone book.
Hmmm. . .
Re: Gary Knox Bennet
clay foster
Judging by your reaction, I would say his nail furniture was very successful. With out knowing you, without ever having met you, without even being aware that you exist, he has been able to shock, outrage, enrage, irritate, and anger you to the point of apoplexy. He has thoroughly manipulated your thoughts and emotions. That's not just a piece of furniture, that's a piece of art, to be able to elicit such a strong response. Don't you wish you could make something that powerful?
Nails
Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey
I've turned a bunch of stuff for people who gave me wood; mementos of their tree. More than a few yielded a fair crop of nails, screws, etc. I make it a point to include those objects in a little plastic bag when I give them their piece. On several occasions I've had a person ask if there was any way to put the nails, etc. back in the piece. My response has been and will be, "Have a hammer?"
When I taught, it was very hard to foster the attitude of a piece not being the artist's baby or some such measure of preciousness. I even had my ceramics students destroy pieces (we recycled the clay) to get used to the idea that it is the artist, not the art, that is the important part. "But I spent so much time doing it," would be the cry. "Did you learn anything in that time?" was my response. "Well, yeah . ." they'd say. "Time well spent" was my reply.
Mr. Bennet does the same thing. He challenges traditional notions of the value of objects. Any P.T. Barnum factor that attaches just makes his statements all the more valid. He deals in extremes; with people smart enough to understand and appreciate his statements as important or with people to whom money has no meaning but being different is everything.
Re: Gary Knox Bennet
charlie belden
My aspirations are more towards getting people to smile or even laugh, by having something familiar, behave in an unfamiliar way - a little sugar bowl - lift the lid - and it waddles away - a coffee mug - with a key sticking out the side - which when you wind it - has the mug jiggle, vibrate and dance around the table top - giving off the smell of coffee from the fine ground fresh coffee beans inside - a round bottomed lidded box with a finial - that stays vertical as the piece tilts - a penduluming finial with an unseen counterweight inside.
I've only done one piece that was meant to make the viewer uncomfortable - and then think about a societal problem - and propose a solution. That was an "Issue" piece, the issue being the need for On Demand Drug Rehabilitation rather than jail or prison.
I think if you want to draw attention - it should be to foucs that attention on something that needs attention.
It doesn't seem too difficult to become famous - or infamous - these daze. Becoming famous doesn't seem to be that difficult - I give you Paris HIlton, Britney Spears - or a guy who drove a nail into a cabinet he'd made. Charlie Sheen seems to demonstrate that it isn't all that hard to become infamous.
Perhap's GNB should be thought of as one of the woodworkers who opened up the woodworker's door to a more lucrative market - the art market. I don't know when the term "studio furniture" came on the scene, but maybe it was around the time of The Bent Nail Cabinet. If that's true - he's been there, done that - and has the T-shirt. Kicking a door open is one thing. To keep kicking AFTER the door has been kicked in . . .
Ah - the "You Apparently Don't Get It Trick"
charlie belden
Come on Mark. To say "He deals in extremes; with people smart enough to understand and appreciate his statements as important."? The Emperor's tailor got away with that one - 'til a child laughed and pointed out the obvious - the Emperor was naked.
I understand that he deals in extremes. WHAT he does is obvious. WHY he does it is what I question. I think that's also obvious - because it brings in Mo' Money, Mo' Money, Mo' Money. And that's fine by me. Money is just a tool that provides options.
What I find disappointing is all that talent and skill and all that creativity which could make some amazing pieces rather than merely shocking pieces. It's like Yo Yo - with a Marshal amp - and a wa-wa plus fuzz tone pedal doing I Like BIg Butts - and never playing the prelude from Bach's Cello Suite No. 1. One would grab your ears - the other - your soul.