Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Scraping; have you tried...

Posts

Scraping; have you tried...

#1

Leo Cuellar

Scraping; have you tried...

Leo Cuellar

using a plain old kitchen knife steel to raise a burr? On a lark, while trying to smooth out a winged bowl, I used one of my old homemade gouges(yes, I made them out of steels) on my scraper. It had gotten dull & I didn't feel like going to the grinder. I cleaned the gunk off the top with a ceramic stone I use for honing, then ran the steel in strokes from the bottom to the top. It produced a very fine burr that left a pretty decent surface on some very twisty grain in big leaf maple. The burr can be maintained in that fashion several times before going back to the grinder.

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#2

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

john lucas

Leo I suspect it's because of the extreme sharpness angle of the knife. It's a lot like using the skew on it's side. It seems to cut cleaner than my scrapers but then bevel to bevel it's 35 degrees and my scrapers are 45 or more depending on which one. I'm still playing with angles but I simply don't use a scraper often enough to really understand them. I tend to pull them out only when I have problems.

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#3

Steven Antonucci

I use one of two things:

steven antonucci

I use a diamond paddle (1200 grit-the green one). FYI- at the Totally Turning show, I was talking to the DMT folks and they have an 8000 grit paddle coming out (beige)!

The other thing I use if I want to go finer is 2000 grit wet dry paper backed on a piece of plate glass. Works great for polishing the top of your scraper so you can really get a fine burr...

Steve

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#4

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

Carole Valentine

No, but my kitchen steel is going out to the shop with me. Thanks for the idea.

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#5

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

Jeff Willaford

Haven't tried a steel but I do use the shaft of a phillips screwdriver.

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#6

Leo Cuellar

I don't use them often either...

Leo Cuellar

John, but sometimes they are the only thing that seems to work on pieces with lots of grain reversals. I haven't even gotten into the whole negative rake business yet either, but it will be one of the things I explore later this year. Although, when I first started out, scraping was all I did with a tool no matter what it was :D

Really glad to hear things are starting to mellow out for you!

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#7

Leo Cuellar

Must have more diamonds!

Leo Cuellar

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#8

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

Dale Miner

I just use the shaft of a bowl gouge. They are probably as hard or harder than a kitchen steel.

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#9

Steven Antonucci

Lacer article in AAW Journal a while back

steven antonucci

converted me to a "scraper user".

A quick recap:

A burr on a scraper is a cutting edge. It is essentially a little hooked edge, or half flute.

To properly prep a scraper, the top should be flat and polished. If you can't see yourself, odds are you can greatly improve the tool's performance in about 15 minutes. I have some wet dry 2000 grit paper that you can lay on a tile/MDF/glass plate and lightly spray with water. Polish the top until the mill marks are gone. (I also have used diamond finger hones to do this, and they cut much faster).

Finally, using a fine grit hone, follow the bevel of the scraper with 2 or 3 strokes from the diamond paddle. You should see a thin, polished line appear on the top and heel of the bevel. If you push a little harded, you get a bigger burr, but it is also a much BETTER burr because it is a 1200 grit burr (not 100G wheel burr, which is useless).

To renew, lap the burr off, and repeat the bevel rubbing thing...

Steve

P.S. 8000 diamonds > 1200 diamonds :)

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#10

Leo Cuellar

Talk about an ugly stick!!!

Leo Cuellar

That is, if I have to see myself on the surface of the scraper :D Actually the top edge of mine are done to 6000 on a Japanese water stone. I do like the info about the finer grit diamond paddle. I'll definitely be getting a couple of those for home & work tool boxes. Yes, finer is better, but a burr that is abraded might nut be as fine as a burr that is drawn. I don't have the photomicrography skills to check this out. Of course everything depends on the type of steel & how hard it is. As long as it works... quickly. Will try your method out, Steve.

Thanks!

Leo

Re: Scraping; have you tried...

#11

Steven Antonucci

I used to draw a burr...

steven antonucci

but I found that it was superfluous. If both faces were only 1200 grit, the best I would get would be 1200 grit anyway. Since I never sand that high, it didn't really matter anyway.

BTW- that polished burr really lasts a long time, but I only take the finest cuts with it. I think that the micro edge is really strong because it's small and it's consistent, so there are very few micro cracks in it, and the loss of any small individual bit isn't really noticible.

Steve