Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Posts

Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#1

Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Steve in Durham NC

I am considering getting a tailstock holding/removal system for my PM3520B. I have looked at JT's Down and Out and the Robust Tilt Away. Anybody used of these tools. I have seen them both and they both look well made. I like the Robust mechanism better but it seems like the tailstock would still be in the way when working off the end of the lathe. The Down and Out get the tailstock out of the way better but I think there could be a better chance for alignment issues due to the hinge.

It is a bunch of money but I am worried about my back lugging the tailstock on and off and I don't have enough time to turn never mind fabricate something.

Any experience or thoughts?

Steve

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#2

Steve Kubien

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Steve Kubien

I have never touched the JT version but I have swung the Robust tilt-away on an American Beauty. Nice piece of kit! I can one-hand the tailstock off my Nova (even with my messed up hand) but if I was in the market for such a thing, I would not hesitate with the Robust.

Not sure if that helps. Good luck.

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#3

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Greg Haugen

Steve,

I've used a lathe on several occasions that had the Robust accessory on it. It's great!! Where you would stand, the robust system isn't in the way. If you were to stand on the backside of the lathe, it would be but why would you be on the back side of the lathe? And if you were, JT's would give you a new body part to list as "turner's_________" and it's not an elbow and would be very hard to explain since it rotates the tailstock and could potentially have the live center pointing at you. Robust has it safely out of the way. Robust's system is heavy duty for heavy duty lathes.

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#4

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Ron

I'm currently just putting the tailstock on the other end of the 3520 when I don't want it (motor is in middle in these cases leaving room on other end). I find since I'm not changing height of the tailstock when moving it, it's not so bad on my back etc. I have tried putting it on another bench, etc but noticed that even an 8-10" change in height is a noticeable effort.

If I get to the point even moving it on the same level as I do now was difficult I think I'd make a roll-away that met up exactly. That way it wouldn't take much effort and I could roll it completely out of the way. Not to mention it would be lots cheaper to make a roll-away out of wood instead of purchasing either of the very nice mechanisms you're considering.

Good luck with your choice.

Ron

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#5

Robust.  No question.

Ed Moore in SW VA

I have the Robust American Beauty with the Tilt-Away. It can rotate on either side of the lathe and it is out of the way. One should remove the tailcenter when using the Tilt-Away for the same reason that you don't want turner's elbow or turner's knee. It is worth every penny if you have or have had any elbow issues. After a couple of years use it is still perfectly aligned.

I have used PM lathes which allow one to rotate the tailstock horizontally. It had a pin just waiting to be sheared and it wasn't sufficiently out of the way.

Get the Robust Tilt-Away. Now that a piston has been added it is even easier to change.

Ed

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#6

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Fred Holder

I had the same problem back in 2006 and 2007. Unfortunately, such devices were not available for my Nova DVR at that time. I made up my own out of wood. Cost was wood scraps and about an hours work, plus a hinge I had on hand.


The making of this was published in the January 2007 issue of More Woodturning, if you would like a copy of the story, e-mail me and I'll send you a copy of the article. Incidentally, I'm still using this device four years later.

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#7

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Scott Crumpton

I've got the Down-n-out on my 3520 and like it. I've seen the Robust version, but not used it so I can't really compare. There is a "bump" when moving the tail stock on/off the Down-n-out that no matter how I try to align it with the bed won't go away. But I don't mind and a slight lift to the tail stock as I slid it and it goes right over. I got the Down-n-out because I intend to turn off the end of the lathe with the bed extension mounted in the lower position.

BTW to avoid "Turner's elbow" I place a cap over my live center made from PVC pipe and fittings. The inside is lined with the loop side of some Velcro so that it friction fits on the center.

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#8

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Mike from St.Clair Shores

I purchased the Robust tilt away about 3 weeks ago for my 3520B, it was on sale then and still might be. It installed very easy and works great. I put the bed extension on the headstock end and can now turn up to 54" in length. I'm very happy with the purchase, the price and the quality.

Mike

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#9

Wooden bed extension

Doc Green

For my 3520B, to get the tailstock out of the way, I built an 18" bed extension that attaches via the same holes provided for the store-bought (and rather expensive) bed extension. To get the tailstock out of the way, I simply push it onto the wooden extension.

I used 3/4" plywood to make the vertical part that bolts to the lathe. Two parts cut from pine 2x4's form the base for two oak strips that form the ways. I've used it almost three years now and it's still good as new.


Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#10

Bed Extension

Jorge Casta�eda

Steve,

When I bought my PM 3520, I debated with myself about getting the Robust jig or the PM bed extension. I opted for the extension. If installed at bed level, gives you lots of room to just slide the tailstock. With this set up you can also make spindle work, like newell posts and balusters. The PM has a set of holes to install the extension 9 inches below the bed level, I opted for this after having it at bed level. Besides having the tailstock really out of the way, it allows me to slide the head and turn really big pieces, the trade off is that i still have to take down or up the tailstock, but so far I can do it with no trouble and I have a broken rib.

So consider the extension.

Good luck whatever you choose!

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#11

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

RPE

You are obviously talented. Why not make you own. There are many homemade variations out there you could copy. Save the money and gain the pride of something you made.

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#12

Fred: I like your tool rack!

adrien

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#13

Down and out has is my preference

jerhall------WebKitFormBoundaryS55vZAaXJsx+Qg1Q

I do a lot of undercutting of large bowls with my bowl gouge and stand behind and to the rear to get the best control of my tool. I don't want the tail stock in my way. Build your own for peanuts:

http://picasaweb.google.com/jerhall95945/SwingAwayAndDownTailstockForPM3520

This has worked great for me for years. If I had to buy one I would look at JT's.

All that said there are a gazillion good ideas on the Mustard Monster site under "Tail Stock"

http://mustardmonster.weebly.com/


img

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#14

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

Cyril Griesbach

I have one of the two prototypes of the Robust Tilt-a-Matic on my PM3520B. I wouldn't ever want to be without it. It does not interfere in any way with turning from the end of the lathe with the headstock slid down toward the end of the bed. And, should you want to turn from the back side of your lathe the Tilt-a-Matic will swing the other direction so when standing on the back side of the lathe the tailstock will now be on the front.

Cyril

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#15

Ellis Walentine

Please check in...

Ellis Walentine

You've got some alphabet soup stuck on your username. That's a throwback to our old software that we upgraded about a year ago. What you need to do is delete your WoodCentral cookies. If you need any help with that, click the Report Problem link in the navigation bar and send me a trouble ticket.

There is more information about all this under the FAQ link.

Ellis Walentine, Host

Re: Tailstock Down and out vs tilt away

#16

Re: Thanks all

Steve in Durham NC

Thanks for the advice. I will give it some thought.

Brent at Robust says they are still on sale while supplies last. Do you know if they are being discontinued?

Steve