Vacuum Chucking System (LONG)
Brian McKearney
I posted a question about a week ago and there have been others since, so I thought that I'd post a follow up with pics of my new vacuum system. I haven't used it for any actual pieces yet, but it is up and running and seems more than adequate.
To start, I purchased a new Gast 523 vacuum pump from Craft Supplies (Woodturner's Catalog) after watching E-Bay for quite a long time. Ultimately, SWMBO persuaded me to buy new rather than used from E-Bay so that I know what I'm getting. As I always say, you get what you pay for - I may have gotten a good used pump on E-Bay but there were no guarantees. Also, it seems that the supply of pumps from Surplus Center has dried up - I probably should have grabbed one several years ago when I was looking and they were available for $89. So, a shiny new Gast 523 is the heart of my system.
I looked long and hard to determine what I needed for plumbing and other parts. Ultimately, I decided that I needed a needle valve rather than a ball valve for the bleeder based on some comments from a few folks - the reasoning being that a needle valve gives you much more precise control of the actual vacuum force that you are pulling. It takes several turns on the needle valve to open it wide open. I ended up buying that particular part on E-Bay - you'll notice it in the pics below with the large round phenolic black handle.
I also concluded that I needed two filters - one for the line coming from the lathe and the other filtering air entering through the bleeder. After I had received all the parts, I realized that one filter would probably have been adequate in the line going back to the pump, but better safe than sorry. The cost of the filters is trivial compared to the pump, so better to protect the pump as best I can.
I also got a liquid filled vacuum gauge from McMaster Carr, and most of the remaining plumbing parts came from www.veneersupplies.com. One of the specialty parts that I got from Veneer Supplies is a quick connect for a vacuum system - this was a bit on the expensive side (+$10 for both pieces), but it seems to seal well and works well as far as I can see.
Here's a pic of my gauge setup - the tubing to the bottom goes off to the Gast 523 and the tube to the left goes to the rotary adapter installed on the tailstock of the lathe.
Regarding the connection to the tailstock, I chose to make my own Oneway-like rotary adapter. I happened to have a spare Beall buffing adapter that I wasn't using, so I drilled out the end and inserted two sealed bearings into the end using a combination of epoxy and silicone sealant. The bearings were 1 3/8" O.D. and 5/8" I.D. - these fit well within the aluminum cylinder and were just the right size to tap in a piece of common 1/2" copper plumbing pipe. From the plumbing pipe, you can readily find adapters to converters to convert to 1/4" NPT. When installing the sealed bearings, I carefully applied epoxy to ensure that they were stuck in place (taking care not to apply any to the center ring that spins) and I applied silicone caulking between the bearings to improve the seal. As far as I can tell, I'm getting very little leakage so far - time will tell how well this part will hold up. By the way, you'll notice black electrical tape in the pics - that's because the Beall adapter has a through hole for the purpose of inserting a rod to remove the adapter from the lathe. I plugged this hole with a piece of plastic from a butter dish and then covered that with black electrical tape - that way, if the adapter ever gets stuck on the lathe, I can still get to the hole with little effort/damage.
Here are a couple of pics of my homemade rotary adapter:

Finally, I decided to purchase a vacuum chuck from http://www.jtturningtools.com/vacuum-chuck-hubs. I ran into a bit of trouble fitting this chuck onto my Oneway 1640 - it seems that the threads started about 1/8" too soon which prevented the chuck from seating properly on the spindle shoulder. I also received a couple of plastic washers for an M33 spindle, but these turned out to be just a bit too small to fit over my spindle. I spoke with Tom on the phone regarding these issues, but have yet to hear back from him for over a week even after sending detailed pics of my spindle, etc. Finally, I decided to bite the bullet and I removed the first thread from the chuck with my Dremel tool and enlarged the hole in the plastic washers with a spindle sander. After these adjustments, the chuck seems to work well - seems like a very nicely made piece of equipment, but I was a bit disappointed with the issues described above.
Here's a pic of the vacuum chuck - note that the foam that I initially used to seal the piece to the chuck was 3/4" wide self-adhesive vacuum foam that I purchased from VeneerSupplies. Now I'm thinking that craft foam from Wal Mart would be a better choice - I purchased some yesterday but have yet to try it out:
After putting it all together, I tried the system yesterday with a piece of 3/4" Maple board held to a 3" vacuum chuck and the system was drawing 25.5 in. Hg. Given that the pump alone is rated to pull ~26 in. Hg., it seems that I have little to no leakage and the system should serve me well.
Just wanted to share my system in case others are interested. Hopefully this writeup will help someone else who may be considering a vacuum system.
Brian




