I just started experimenting with Waterlox. I used it on a deep cup-type vessel turned from very white box elder. The end grain towards the bottom turned dark, and no matter how much I sanded, it wouldn't come out. At first I assumed that it was due to tear-outs in the end grain (I hadn't noticed any beforehand), but sanding after the fact did not help much.
I would assume that open wood capillaries of the end grain in the Box Elder(which is a medium soft maple) just sucked up the Waterlox like a straw. Perhaps applying a sealer beforehand would prevent that.
Of all the varnish products out there, Waterlox is more amber than most, if not all, of them. That means that the more you apply, the darker it appears. On endgrain, it gets sucked down into the pores and looks a lot darker than on the side grain, where less is absorbed. Preliminary sealing is one way to keep the color uniform. Try a few experimental pieces, using shellac as a sealer. Apply it, then sand it back to bare wood before applying the Waterlox.
I use Waterlox Original almost exclusively. Like most finishes, more of it will be absorbed into endgrain than the face grain, punky wood than solid wood and more on some woods than others. If I want to prevent this, or if I want to keep a light wood light, I use a quick wash of thinned lacquer (50/50 and sometimes even thinner) which I immediately wipe dry. This wash is thin enough that proportionately more is taken into the end grain or punky areas, resulting in a more consistent absorption of your final finish over the entire piece and avoiding the blotchiness that otherwise occurs. I have a number of pieces of light colored spalted wood (hackberry and maple, much of it with punky areas) as well as ones that have a relatively open endgrain, that by all rights should be blotchy has heck, and this technique has almost always worked for me. An additional trick is to lightly hand sand any highly absorbable areas with a grit one higher than what is used on the rest of the piece. Not sure why but this also seems to reduce the absorbtion of finish in susceptible areas. I am by no means an authority...this is just works for for me.
Thanks for the tips. I'll try it. I ended up using one of my broad curved woodcarving chisels to remove the stained end grain from my deep cup vessel and with some sanding it came out fine.