Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

Posts

Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#1

Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

jake Niedling

I just recently purchased a EWT Easy rougher with some of my christmas money. Thought I would add it to my collection of tools.

Gave it a go today on a 12" diameter green walnut bowl blank with the corners knocked off with chainsaw. I found it easy to use and pretty stress free during the roughing the piece to round. As the wood became closer to round and there was more wood taken off, it seems to be a little slow in taken the amount of wood away.

I switch over to my 1/2" bowl gouge and was able to quickly take away alot more wood with each pass. I was able to shape the bowl quicker as well. The curls coming off were easily twice as thick over what I was getting with the easy rougher.

For me, I think the Easy Rougher will be used to get some of my pieces that are out of round roughed to near round shape. After that I going with the bowl gouge.

I can see if you are not comfortable with a bowl gouge, the easy rougher would be preferred.

The bowl gouge will be my go to tool.

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#2

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

john lucas

Jake I did the same thing. Rounding from rough has always been somewhat stressful. I tried a homemade version of the easy rougher scraper. It still pounds you when those odd protrusions come around. I switched back and forth between 5/8 gouge with a heavy handle and the carbide tool. both gave me the same beat on me impression.

Like you I found that once I got it round I could remove much more wood faster and with a cleaner surface and had better control of the shape. Now I'll grant you, it does take more experience to use the bowl gouge correctly but in my opinion well worth the effort.

On top of that if I want to leave a crisp detail with the bowl gouge I can. It will require little sanding and will stay crisp. With the carbide scraper you may not even be able to do that detail (depends on the shape) and it will require more sanding which leads to rounded edges.

I think it's like never learning to use the skew for anything but scraping. It does require some effort on your part to learn to use the skew. But what a wonderful tool when used correctly. No other tool will do the job as well.

I look at the new carbide tools both positive and negative. Positive because they let a raw beginner finish a project without blowing it up. this leads to more turners having a good time. Negatively because they fall back on that tool and never learn to use the cutting tools correctly.

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#3

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

wilbur

I know that this is flat work material, so please forgive me, but there's an analogy to the relationship between a random orbit sander and a hand plane in here somewhere.

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I agree Wilbur,

I have several EWT tools that I use mostly for pen making, some are very excellent for light clean work on non wood materials.

I also have used the bigger Easy Rougher on wood, I have been making pepper mills with it and it allows me to get to net shape quickly, well in many cases finished shape.

Like any tool once you work with it and learn what it can do in your hands, the skills you develop with it become your own experience. I find more and more I use my HSS tools less and less.

Take care,

Jim

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#5

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

Bill Howatt

I took the opposite approach. I bought a EWT mini-finisher and bought the replacement cutter for the larger finisher and made my own.

I am very happy with the final cut I get with the mini-finisher. Time will tell if I remain happy with it but right now it's looking like a useful addition to the tool arsenal.

Bill

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#6

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

Mike Brazeau

You are working dry wood, whereas Jake is working green wood. Personally I'll take a roughing gouge any day over any form of scraper on starting to shape spindle work. On green or wet bowl blanks, using a gouge, I find novices tend to try and cut straight on to make the blank round. If you use pull cuts and work from bottom (tailstock end) to headstock on an angle, the whole process is much more efficient. Just like planing wood with the plane on a slight angle.

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#7

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Great point Mike,

I am working dry woods, and I think of the edge of the tool I am using like a hand tool for my flat work. I often use high angled planes, I find that I am also using the carbides in the same fashion, I get continuos long shavings even with acrylic's.

A short story, when I was 10 years old I wanted to get some golf clubs and play on a course (Jack was my hero). My dad told me to take small steps first, he would let me buy one club and I was to learn all I could with it. We went to Miracle Mart and I used my paper route money to buy a 7 iron. Keeping true to my word and his wishes I would go to the local high school and hit balls in the middle of the play area they had surrounded by a track. I was out there often practicing and over that summer I learnt a lot about the club, my swing and what I could do with it (hitting it high, low, moving it right and left, out of the sand pits, long grass etc). Over the following years when playing golf, to this day the lessons learnt at the age of 10 will come back to me, when I need to get out of a jam or create a shot I reach for the 7 iron. I know that if given only 1 club to play a round of golf I would choose my 7 iron. Developing confidence and skills help all of us to achieve our vision, for me what learnt from the 7 has become my experience and my process, I trust the results.

Turning tools are in the same league to me, dance with the one that you enjoy, (I still have that original 7 iron).

Take care,

Jim

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#8

Steven Antonucci

Good point

steven antonucci

When I teach a beginner's class, I only teach four tools: The spindle roughing gouge, a bowl gouge, a spindle gouge and a round nose scraper. Until you have the ability to use these tools well, adding "clubs" to your bag only makes your bag heavier.

When they pick up these four, I drop the SRG and replace it with a skew. I personally think that carbide is a crutch, since it "overcomes" the need to sharpen. Sharpening is what I teach before we ever touch a tool...and I teach about cutting in the right direction before we even talk about sharpening!

Swing a handful of clubs well and anyone can play this game.

Steve

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#9

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

robo hippy

There is a gentleman by the name of Fred Ugla down in the Roseburg Oregon area, and he turns light houses, complete with long delicate finials on them, several inches long. He uses a 'big ugly tool' which is the for runner of the Easy rougher tools. It is 3/4 inch bar stock, about 30 inches long, with some 7/8 wide by 3/16 thick tantung steel silver soldered onto each end. A heavy leather glove is work on the handle hand. It is amazing to watch him work. Rpm at 3500 or so, and peeling cut in to finial thickness, a few deft twitches and there is a bead, cove, or other detail, then he does another peeling cut, and continues. Cuts are clean and need little to no sanding. Biggest difference is you can sharpen the tantung on a standard grinder. Any tool, in the hands of a master can work wonders.

robo hippy

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

#10

Re: Easy Rougher vs. Bowl Gouge

Wayne Kuhn

My irish gring bowl gouge was my go to tool-I had doubted these carbide tipped tools thinking I didn't need one. Well I broke down and bought one.

This thing is great for removing the bark from a green rough blank. Once bark is gone, its back to my trusty bowl gouge.