Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Hollowing tool advice

Posts

Hollowing tool advice

#1

Hollowing tool advice

Keith Inscho

I have decided to get some hollowing tools, and have narrowed it down to Keltons or Jordans. After all the reading I have done and weighing the pros and cons, I am finding it hard to make a decision. Are both systems really on an even playing field, or is there someplace one outshines the other.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#2

Re: Hollowing tool advice

Carole Valentine

Both tools will do the job. I have a couple of Jordans, but a stable full of Keltons in all sizes. The Keltons have remained my go-to hollowing tools. They seem to retain their cutting edge extremely well and rarely, if ever, need to see even the lightest touch on a grinder...only an occasional quick honing is all that is required.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#3

Re: Hollowing tool advice

steve worcester

What I like about the Jordan style (his in particular) is the cutter is replaceable. You might want to augment that selection with Trent Bosch's extreme bend for those undercuts and tough places.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#4

Re: Hollowing tool advice

Jennifer Indy.USA

I have both the mid size Jordans and the Keltons. I grab for the Jordans before the Keltons every time. There's something about the curve on his bars that just seems to be perfectl aligned the cutter with the shaft and makes them less grabby than most others. I like the Keltons too, but I don't seem to have as much success with them as Carole.

Jen

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#5

another vote for Jordans

Dick Coers

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#6

Re: Hollowing tool advice

robo hippy

I don't do a lot of hollowing, but have the full set of Kelton hollowing tools. Work great, and have adapters for putting them in my Monster articulated arm tool. Never tried the Jordan ones.

robo hippy

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#7

Re: Hollowing tool advice

woodspinner-Harry Robinette

I've tried John Jordan's tools and they work good,but my go to Hollowers are my Keltons. I been using them for over 7years and they work great.I've tried allot of the hollower on the market and I still like my Keltons.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#8

Joe Fleming

Re: Hollowing tool advice

Joe Fleming

Keith,

Hard question because you didn't provide enough information. You are looking for hollowing tools to hollow what size(s) and shape(s)? Different tools work better in different situations.

My name is Joe (hi Joe), and I am a tool junkie

I have many, many hollowing tools. For small hollow forms up to 3", I use the Packard 3-tool mini hollowers. I have the Kelton mini tools, too, but I find that they vibrate too much for my taste.

For forms from 3" to 6 or 7", Kelton small hollowers (1/2" shaft) are my first pick. Older versions of these tools have shafts that are, in my opinion, too short. They have lengthened them to a much better length. I just bought a set of the longer shaft tools for myself. My second choice in this size is my Jordan 1/2" shaft. I have a homemade straight tool with a 3/16" cutter that I use as my straight tool.

For forms from 6" to 10 or 11", I use the Don Derry captured system. Depending on the opening size, I use my 3/4" Jordan hook tool here. For vessels from 8 or 9" to 18", I use Jordan in an armbrace. I also have the Stewart large hooker for these big vessels.

For tall, narrow endgrain vessels, I reach for my Exocet tool. The straight tool is great. The hook tool is not well designed. Not sure you can get these anymore, though.

I have way more tools than listed here, but they get very little use except for show and tell. Probably time to sell them at a swap meet.

Joe

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#9

KELTON Hollowing tool advice

glenn roberts

Keith, one of the reasons why you will get differences of opinions on hollowing is due to the varying design pieces that people make. One feature that is often overlooked is that if you have a very small opening then a tool with a largish head is obviously no good AND if it makes shavings, instead of smaller chips/small shavings, then you can have real problems. I find the Kelton's don't necessarily make long shavings and often make small chips that can be blown out with compressed air. So if you ask different turners why they like a particular brand of tool, it is also worth asking what type of work do they do?

If they do the 'usual' stuff large openings etc) then obviously most tools will work well. If it's small opening you want then, its worth thinking about it some more.

If you want to hollow wide forms ( through a small opening) then rotational forces are large, what ever brand tool you buy, unless it has either a capture system ( hollowing rig etc) or a side handle of some type.

So you are doing the right thing and asking around before buying. As it has been said, I find the Kelton's hardly need sharpening ( even with hard Aussie burl) so their life span shouldn't be a problem if you know not to grind them away.

I hope this helps.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#10

Re: Hollowing tool advice

John Jordan

Well, I live here and you can always call me, and I will return your money if you don't like them. :)

I don't refund a lot of money.

John

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#11

Re: Hollowing tool advice

cliff smith

never tried the keltons, but love my jordons have the large and small sets, don pencil also makes a good hollowing set too.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#12

Bill Blasic

Re: Hollowing tool advice

Bill Blasic

Way back when I was about five years old I was at a class mates house (his name was Bill also) and we were drawing pictures. He wanted his mother to tell us which picture was better. She whispered to each of us separately - Don't tell Bill but yours is better! Now if you ever see me whispering in either Kel or John's ear you'll know what I'm saying. I have both sets of tools.

Bill

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#13

(Message Deleted by Poster)

Greg Haugen

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#14

Aage Rendalen

Re Bosch

Aage Rendalen

I bought the Bosch bent tool at the Richmond Symposium, and managed to rip the cutter out of its drilled recess when I got a catch (thought I'd return to the good old days of hand-held hollowing). The steel was so soft that it gave out.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#15

Re: Hollowing tool advice

Terry Scott

I wonder sometimes if brands of tools are a bit like your preference for cars

We have many followers of Holden and as many with Ford .Although the swing usually goes to who is winning the V8 series.

I remember when I was younger (that in itself is something remembering )I asked my father Dad why do you like Holden? His reply "because I grew up with them son and they have never let me down "

Being a self confessed Tool-a-holic I own or have owned most(or tried ) of the hollower's on the market thats if I can get my hands on them.I do have my favorites but came to realize early on I needed more than one brand as differnt projects require a differnt approach or cut .Haven't found a tool yet that will cover all the bases .

At least Ive an excuse for my toys .Whats Your's

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#16

Dick Hines

Re: Hollowing tool advice

Dick Hines

I have the Bosh, Kelton, Jamieson captured rig and a bunch of home made tools.

I will use any or all while turning hollow forms.

I use the Jamieson when I can but will use what ever get the job done.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#17

Re: Hollowing tool advice

George Guadiane

I gotta say, that the articulated Rolly Munro hollower is a little expensive but it can pretty much be adjusted to any hollow form. And it cuts nicely.

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#18

Re: Hollowing tool advice

John Jordan

I've never heard of a broken cutter? I've made a whole lot of pieces with them, and I've never broken a cutter-which happen to have the same size shaft as Trent's. I've never heard from a user that happened either.

John

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#19

Re: Hollowing tool advice

Charles Watson

Obviously I like tools because my shop is full of them. I haven't tried all of the hollowing tools available because like most of you I have to buy them to do so.

Many times I use tools just so that I don't feel too bad for having purchased them in the first place. On occasion I decide to sell them because I hear of a new tool or one that I haven't tried and think that at last a magic tool that will make perfect turnings has been created. Wrong!

When it comes to freehand hollowing, my Jordan tools are the ones that have always met my needs. The tips can be quickly removed, sharpened, or replaced, the shape of the tools are just right for the forms I like to do, and the tip holder for sharpening is another plus.

If I'm doing hollowing with a captured system and can't quite get things done the way I would like, I pull out the Jordan tools, and finish. Being able to feel the action of a tool being used freehand is hard to beat especially using my Jordan tools. They are keepers. Thanks John!

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#20

Brad Vietje

Love my John Jordan hollowing tools!

Brad Vietje

I'd say ask at a local turning club meeting and, if possible, try them both. I've used a lot of hollowing tools, and I like John's a lot. Since he's one of the best-know hollow form turners in the world, and designed these tools to work for him, go figure. If you get real good with them, you might start talkin' funny, like you're from Tennessee... ;)

John's videos on hollowing are real good, too. If only he liked the Patriots instead of those Titans.... :)

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Hollowing tool advice

#21

Re: Love my John Jordan hollowing tools!

Keith Inscho

To late Brad, I already have aint and yall down purdy good. I just discovered I only live about an hour from John. ;)