Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

Evaluating Vacuum Systems

Posts

Evaluating Vacuum Systems

#1

Evaluating Vacuum Systems

Bob Lalonde

Hi all. I am getting ready to buy a vacuum system and my choices appear to be the Holdfast and Oneway systems. Can you give me your assessment of either or both. I have an adequate air compressor for the Holdfast venturi system. I also have an old Gast vacuum pump but it may or may not pull enough vacuum to hold a large bowl. I also note that Packard offers an "E-Z Vacuum Adapter" if anyone owns one. Thanks for your help.

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

#2

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

Greg Haugen

Bob,

In my opinion, the "Holdfast" system and the Gast systems don't compare. The "holdfast" will hold a piece but there's better ways to do it. I have the Gast pump from Craft Supplies, it's a model 0523 and 110V. I'd highly recommmend it. Unlike the pumps in the other catalogs, it has an "on/off" switch on the wire. Others say, "this will have to be plugged into a outlet strip with a switch," which means there's no "on/off" switch. Plug in, to turn on. That's a pain. There's a lot of information on the internet about set-ups and options. 20 inches of mercury and up is an acceptable range of vacuum. If you're going to be hold a larger piece, I'd recommend to have a couple different "chuck" sizes. The same vacuum level will hold a 20" platter better on an 8" chuck compared to a 5" chuck. Also my plumbing is very close to the "oneway" setup that you see in the catalogs. I made it all from a plumbing supply source locally, including an excellent gauge. The only thing I added was a "filter" on the side that is connected to the lathe. The Gast pumps do have internal filters, but some extra can't hurt, especially from the side that would pull in the most dust. My chucks are also made out of various sizes of PVC couplers, mdf, and faceplates. The oneway chucks are incredibly nice as well.

I also did "buy" my pump from a catalog and didn't go through ebay or other sources. You don't know where the "used" pumps have been and I wanted to know what I'm using and the quality of it.

My vote is definitely for the Oneway (or stand style of system) compared to the "holdfast".

I've used Packard's adaptor but now I use Oneway's Rotary. Depending on the lathe, one system or the other has advantages. I like the oneway adaptor since it's always there and ready.

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

#3

Re: E-z Adaptor

Steve in Durham NC

I have been using the EZ adaptor on my PM 3520B and my jet mini for over 5 yeats. I works well and by simply changing the threaded rod, you can use it on different lathes.

I built my system from parts. Pump came from Surplus Supply. Defintely recommend a in line filter.

I use the Oneway 6" Vacuum chuck for much of my work. I have a smaller one that I made but it ties up a faceplate so I seldom use it.

There are lots of threads on this on WC so give it a search and you will get lots of info and opinions.

Hope this helps.

Steve

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

#4

Dick Hines

Re: E-z Adaptor

Dick Hines

Check out www.jtturningtools.com

I have no interest in this company but they carry all you need to build a vacuum system

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

#5

Alan Zenreich

Re: E-z Adaptor *LINK*

Alan Zenreich

I have no connection with JTTurning tools either, but I'm very happy with the components I purchased from them.

Combined with a Gast pump that I found on Craigslist, I now have a very nice vacuum chucking system.

I made some photos and notes of the setup on one of my web pages.

I hope this helps round out your choices.


img

Vacuum chuck web page

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

#6

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

pete labelle

Would like to hear from venturi-type users, as to how big of air compressor you are using, and how frequently it cycles to keep up with the venturi system.

If a 2-3 hp compressor cycles frequently to keep up with the needs for a venturi system, it seems it would be cheaper to run a 1/3 or 1/2 hp motor to do the same thing.

Venturi systems do develop a lot of vacuum pressure, but are low on volume. Thus, if your system, or wood, leaks too much, it will never achieve the vacuum you need.

Ventury vacuum systems also are altitude sensative. The higher your altitude, the lesser vaccum you will be able to achieve.

Pete

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

#7

Richard Allen

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

Richard Allen

I have been using the E-Z adaptor for many years (more than 5) on two different lathes. It works great. The pump? It is all about the vacuum developed not how fast the vacuum is reached. If your workpiece doesn't hold a vacuum then a fast pump might hold but the better solution is to resolve the leaks.

The vacuum pump, especially the diaphragm pumps are quiet. Running a venture system is noisy.

If you don't mind the noise then consider using a shop vac. Very large on volume to hold very leaky systems. Use a "bypass" shop vac like the Fein or the motor will burn out. If you can stand the noise the shop vac works great and is cheap. The only plumbing is a bearing adaptor to connect the shop vac hose to the back of your headstock spindle. No need or want for any gauges, filters, valves... Leaky systems are fine as the volume will overcome them all.

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

#8

Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems

walta

Take a look at the Stubby Lathe web site http://stubbylatheusa.com/cgi-bin/onlinestore.py

They have a new rotary vacuum adatpor that fits most lathes less than � the price of the E-Z adaptor.

Walta