Re: Evaluating Vacuum Systems
Greg Haugen
Bob,
In my opinion, the "Holdfast" system and the Gast systems don't compare. The "holdfast" will hold a piece but there's better ways to do it. I have the Gast pump from Craft Supplies, it's a model 0523 and 110V. I'd highly recommmend it. Unlike the pumps in the other catalogs, it has an "on/off" switch on the wire. Others say, "this will have to be plugged into a outlet strip with a switch," which means there's no "on/off" switch. Plug in, to turn on. That's a pain. There's a lot of information on the internet about set-ups and options. 20 inches of mercury and up is an acceptable range of vacuum. If you're going to be hold a larger piece, I'd recommend to have a couple different "chuck" sizes. The same vacuum level will hold a 20" platter better on an 8" chuck compared to a 5" chuck. Also my plumbing is very close to the "oneway" setup that you see in the catalogs. I made it all from a plumbing supply source locally, including an excellent gauge. The only thing I added was a "filter" on the side that is connected to the lathe. The Gast pumps do have internal filters, but some extra can't hurt, especially from the side that would pull in the most dust. My chucks are also made out of various sizes of PVC couplers, mdf, and faceplates. The oneway chucks are incredibly nice as well.
I also did "buy" my pump from a catalog and didn't go through ebay or other sources. You don't know where the "used" pumps have been and I wanted to know what I'm using and the quality of it.
My vote is definitely for the Oneway (or stand style of system) compared to the "holdfast".
I've used Packard's adaptor but now I use Oneway's Rotary. Depending on the lathe, one system or the other has advantages. I like the oneway adaptor since it's always there and ready.