Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Splitting mesquite log

Posts

Splitting mesquite log

#1

George Taylor

Splitting mesquite log

George Taylor

At the Hill Country Turning Club Thursday night a member had recently cut down a mesquite tree on his property and brought several sections for members who might want them (i.e. free). I wasn't too anxious (first in line) and picked up a piece about 13 inches long and around 10 inches across.

My question(s) are:

Would it be safe to lug this up on the bandsaw to split?

If so, should I construct some type of sled to guide it through the first cut?

Or should I find someone with a chainsaw that knows what he/she is doing?

I do not process much timber and want to be safe

Thanks

George


Re: Splitting mesquite log

#2

Dick Hines

Re: Splitting mesquite log

Dick Hines

If you cut it just as it sits and keep your hands out of the wat you should be OK. I would not lay it on it's side.

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#3

Mike Stafford

Re: Splitting mesquite log

Mike Stafford

If your band saw has sufficient depth of cut to handle this log section standing on end that would be a safe way to cut it. Once you have a flat side to sit upon the table you can probably shape it as you wish.

Trying to rip along its length with the grain would be dangerous without a cradle of some sort.

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#4

Re: Splitting mesquite log

Galen Vetterick

George

You have fewer questions then I for processing green wood.

Me having less experience with turning.

The non-symetric log you have I need to think more on which way I should split it to get good symetric halves to turn. If the pith has a definite split and to part it there makes unbalanced halves do I just leave that log alone? Do I try and get the best half I can and scrap the other?

Most logs I get I must split with an electric chain saw as my band saw only hast a 6" throat. Guess it is a good thing I only have a 12" lathe swing for now.

Hope to learn more from WoodCentral folks as I go on.

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#5

Steven Antonucci

Whatcha going to do with it?

steven antonucci

Depending upon what you want to end up making, I'd leave it alone for now. If you are ready to turn it, I'd go the chainsaw route first, bandsawn upright second, and split it with a maul and wedges third.

From the sounds of it, you've got to cut it down in the long dimension anyhow to fit your lathe. Leaving it longer will give you room to cut away any checking on the ends (mesquite is pretty stable.)

S

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#6

Re: Splitting mesquite log

Ken Oakley-Sunny St. Cloud, Fla.

I cut logs that size on my Delta 14" bandsaw with a riser block using a 3/4" 3TPI blade often. Works best when the blade is sharp and tension is correct.

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#8

Galen, here's a few answers. George a couple tooo *LINK*

Greg Haugen

Depending on what you want to turn, how you cut the log will matter. One thing that is always the same, you don't want the pith, or anything too close to it. If there's a few "splits" off of the pith, don't worry about it, those will be cut off by staying clear of the pith.

The easy answer is for end grain pieces (spindles, hollow forms, vases), it doesn't really matter. You can incorporate some "sap" wood color if you'd like but it's not that crucial. Stay away from the pith. If I'm cutting for end grain pieces, I'll still cut it often times like I'm bowl blanks, cut of a big of the bark side and cut down the middle about an 1 inch or so from the pith. From there, I'll take that slab and cut squares out of it. Usually getting two or three "blocks" per slab. If you're going to work it soon, you can just 1/4 a log, again avoiding the pith. I usually do the "slab and then square" method just to avoid turning a bunch of bark off later. I'll seal the ends and get to them later. Before I turn a "squared" block, I do tilt my bandsaw at 45 deg. and take off the corners. Especially if it's 6" or thicker. Makes the initial turning a little easier.

If you want to do a few bowls or plates, you're better off centering the pith, aka "balancing the grain", for each cut. Looking at George's log, There's "lobes" to the diameter of the log, the two that are on the back side are fairly balanced on the pith, and the third (in the front), though it's small, would be a great natural edge bowl or vessel. John Jordan talks about "balancing" the grain in his "Aesthetics" DVD, I'd highly recommend it. If the grain is balanced in a bowl and platter, it will help in the drying process since the "tensions" will be a lot more equal, it will also add some "effect" and symmetry. Production turners will bend this rule a bit since they're after quantity and size as well.

Here's an example of when I'd "scrap" a half. "limb" wood will have the pith off centered, majorly. IF you balance the grain, one side will be real thin and one side with be real nice and thick. I'd take the thick side, and possible scrap the thin side-if it's too thin. I wouldn't cut this in a manner where the two side are equal. Tight grain and loose grain will be in the same blank and it would be problematic.

The only logs I leave alone are the ones with "shakes". Splits that go with the growth rings. Looks like a separation of the rings. Cracks can be cut out easily, but "shakes" can go a long distance. It's just not worth it. If one side has a shake and one side doesn't, I'd take one side and scrap or burn the "shaked" side.

I use anchorseal to seal the end grain of pieces, unless I'm going to cut them that day. It's worth it.

George,

I agree with the others. I use a chainsaw for "log" work and a bandsaw for "block" work. But if you cut that on the flat end, like it is, you'll be fine with a bandsaw. Do not lay on its bark and try it. If not, find someone with a chainsaw. You could also split with wedges, but saws are my preference.

Enjoy. Mesquite is a great wood.


John Jordan's Page for Tools and the DVD

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#9

George Taylor

Re: Whatcha going to do with it?

George Taylor

Upon visual inspection, no checks are seen; like you said mesquite is very dense and one of the more stable woods. I hope to get some natural edge bowls and maybe a box or two out of the log. The sucker is also heavy since it was just cut down. :)

George

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#10

George Taylor

Re: Splitting mesquite log-Pic

George Taylor

Thanks for the visual and to everyone with advice; one of my first inclinations was to lay it on its side. Glad I asked and I am very glad we have such a great resource as WoodCentral.

Thanks Ellis!

George

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#11

Re: Splitting mesquite log

robo hippy

With a smaller piece like the one you show, I will often rip them length wise on my bandsaw. It CAN be done, and on a small piece, but you need to decide if it is SAFE for you. Taking a 1/8 inch kerf rather than a 1/2 inch one can save some wood. A lot depends on having a some what flat side to lay it on. First, see if there is any end checks from the pith. Usually there is one crack, and with good luck, it matches the one on the other end of the log. I will lay it on a table, and make a square/plumb line through the pith on both ends. Then I snap a chalk line mark from end to end. It will not roll on you if you are cutting close to center. If the log has any branches sticking off, they need to be trimmed. If there is a slight crown or bow, then they need to be trimmed off, with chainsaw, axe, electric planer or what ever is handy.

There are two things about standing them on end that might cause small problems. One is if the ends aren't square to the log, then you will have a hard time splitting it down the pith. The other is that by standing it on end, you will get a lot of long shavings which will plug up the inside of your bandsaw. Ever see the old Star Trek adventure 'The Trouble With Tribbles'? Looks like a lot of hairballs in there.

I would leave it in log form for a while, maybe a month or so, but not much longer than that, even if it is well sealed on the ends. A chainsaw does work as well.

robo hippy

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#12

Re: Galen, here's a few answers. George a couple t

Galen Vetterick

Thanks Greg

I did purchase Michael O'Donnell's "Turning Green Wood" and I think it is pretty good for showing potential shapes, grain orientation and shrinkage.

Now to THINK about it each time!

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#13

Re: Galen, here's a few answers. George a couple t

Greg Haugen

Galen,

Yes, Michael's is great as well.

Have fun.

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#14

Brad Vietje

Re: Splitting mesquite log

Brad Vietje

Hey George,

Couple-a thoughts:

I look for a way to split the log that leaves the pith centered. In the photo you posted, that appears to be the widest extent from left - right -- roughly from the little chainsaw dimple through the pith, and across to the other side.

I do this for three main reasons:

1. symmetrical figure is not guaranteed, but most likely

2. largest blanks with relatively symmetrical bark

3. "peaks" from shrinkage on end grain will be symmetrical and on opposite sides of a bowl.

BUT: keep in mind that Mesquite moves very little -- less than any other wood I have ever used -- so #3 won't matter as much as 1 & 2. Also, once you split it along the pith, you don't have to force yourself to hurry, which you would have to do with a fresh piece of wood with higher shrinkage, like Maple, Apple, or Cherry. The piece you show appears to have a rather flat side (away from the camera), which might make a real nice natural edge bowl with good sapwood contrast. For most species, you'll get the whitest sapwood if cut fresh and green -- though this may not apply to Mesquite.

In my limited experience with Mesquite, I have found it pretty tough on saw blades. I may have had a few with lots of silica in them, but I found that Mesquite will dull the blade pretty quickly.

Lastly, if you live where this stuff grows, it won't be the last one you come across, so don't let it intimidate you. You'll have a lot of fun and learn a lot no matter what you make from it!

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Splitting mesquite log

#15

Re: Splitting mesquite log

jim miles - Charlotte, N C|

If you are looking primarily for a simple, safe, no machinery method:

Split it with timber wedges, cut your own out of wood if don't have.

Will take a little more work with axe or saw to shape it for bowl blanks

But......no machinery & safer !