Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Why Do We Do Dat?

Posts

Why Do We Do Dat?

#1

Why Do We Do Dat?

charlie belden

Why Do We Do Dat?

It may be in the nature of people who turn wood - to do things that seem, or are, irrational - perhaps just because we can, or think we can. To a large extent that may account for all the different directions turning has taken that have led to so many interesting pieces.

It seems to be a combination of �I do - because I CAN� mixed with a healthy dose of �Status Quo - That�s how it�s always been done.� thing. But every so often - it�s good to step back - look at things - and question the Status Quo to ask �WHY is this The Way It�s Supposed To Be Done? Does THIS make sense?�

Let�s look at some of the things we do - without REALLY thinking about why - or questioning whether it makes sense. I�ll readily admit I �occassionally� do each of what follows.

A lidded box with a pop fit or a threaded lid - requires two hands to open - and two hands to close. Now if you are holding something you want to put IN the lidded box in one of those hands - or have something you've just taken out of the lidded box in one of those hands - you�re a hand short when it comes to opening or closing that lidded box. Pop fit or threaded lids are impressive to a turner - and minor hassle to anyone who USES the lidded box. A �one hand to remove and replace� loose fit lid makes a lot more sense to a users. To a turner it may be seen as sloppy, an indication of incompetency.

We go to great lengths to get the walls of a hollow form, hollowed through an impossibly small hole, as thin as possible - and then spend more time getting the inside surface as smooth as the outside. Impresses the hell out of other turners - especially ones with freakishly long fingers. Seldom will a non turner stick a finger inside a hollow form to check the thickness of its walls, let alone be amazed that the inside, beyond which their finger can�t reach, is as smooth as the outside.

Semi gloss and high gloss finishes - show every smudge and fingerprint as well as every scratch, pit, run or sag in finish. If the piece gets dinged or scratched - it�ll take a bit of work to repair. All that smooth and SHINY - that�s so refelective - also makes it difficult to see and appreciate the essence of the piece - THE WOOD. And a half dozen coats of even �water clear� finish get between your finger tips and the wood beneath that finish.

A goblet - with a LONG, almost impossibly thin stem - may be beautiful - to look at and impressive - to a turner. But beauty can be a fleeting thing. When beauty is extremely vulnerable - as a piece like this is - that�s particularly true. If that stem breaks - it�s Humpty Dumpty Time - and all the king�s horses and alll the king�s men . . .

So my questions is:

WHY Do We Do Dat?

Got other examples of �Why Do We Do Dat?�?

Re: Why Do We Do Dat?

#2

Steven Antonucci

We choose to go to the moon because it's hard

steven antonucci

No different.

I get bored pretty easily, but not when I am learning.

Steve