Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

Posts

Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#1

Brad Vietje

Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

Brad Vietje

Boy, oh, boy, there are some terrible turning videos out there in cyberspace... Every now and then we hear of a real beaut, and we cringe at the damage that could be done by some moron with a video camera.

Check out the YouTube video link, below, which could be re-named: "Using The Wrong Tools To Make A Short, Ugly, Crooked Box". Some knucklehead is lucky to still have his knuckles intact. I don't read or write in Danish or whatever language the text is, so I have no real hope of ever reaching the person who made it, but there are quite a few worst practices demonstrated here...

I never quite know what to do about stooopid DIY videos, but I have an idea: I suggest we scour the web for great examples of worst practices, and start posting them as exactly what they are -- great examples of dangerous ways you should NOT turn wood. Maybe someone here who's more YouTube-savvy than I can start things off. I say we create a DDT network (Don't Do This) to counter balance some of the DIY garbage out there! We could start with a contest to find the worst of the worst, so we can start exposing these idiots, so some 13-year-old doesn't post a reply like : KEWL!!!!!.

Your thoughts?

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT


Very Unsafe Turning Video

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#2

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest

Dick Wilson

Brad, There are and have been much, much worse videos on YouTube than this video. The chuck he uses doesn't impress me. The jaws stick way out ready to take his fingers off when sanding. It also looks like the jaws are off center because the turning is not running true. The idiot who was using a roughing gouge to turn a tree crotch round comes to mind as a real bone headed video.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#3

Chuck

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

This is what you get when you turn wood on a metal lathe. That looks like a machinist's 3-jaw chuck with independently set jaws, and his technique is taken from using straight bedan-type cutters to cut metal. Not really unsafe, but pretty limited to straight lines, flat shapes, and square corners.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#4

Jerry Louden

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest

Jerry Louden

Great music even if the turning isn't all that good. :)

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#5

Richard Allen

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest

Richard Allen

The only unsafe practice I saw was that the guy was wearing a watch.

Maybe instead to listing unsafe videos we could list the unsafe activities in a video.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#6

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest

Phil Powell

Wait, wait! with the contest until I have a chance to make my video. I'm

just sayin' given half a chance I bet I can scare y'all.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#7

Translation

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

"Yo, Bubba. Hold ma beer wilst I do this . . ."

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#8

Just send us a photo of you   

John Lucas

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#9

Brad Vietje

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest

Brad Vietje

Richard Allen wrote:

The only unsafe practice I saw was that the guy was wearing a watch.

Really??? I had to cringe when I saw him stick his hands inside the protruding jaws of the spinning chuck to sand the thing. I know many people use engineer's chucks, and that years ago, that's what was available. I'm also certain that some of the things I do at home would be considered dangerous to others -- BUT, I'm not posting YouTube videos of my stupid antics.

I have two concerns about these sort of videos:

1. influence of unsafe practices on novices

2. Novices posting instructional videos in the first place.

My take is that you ought to be good at something before presuming to know enough to teach it. Maybe I'm just being a jerk, but when someone shoots a video of the first or third bowl they ever made, complete with verbal instructions about how the viewer should do this and that, they are really pushing my buttons. When they post a video that combines dangerous and foolish things done with absolutely no credible experience, I think they are crossing a line and ought to be called out to remove the post. I usually find something constructive to write as a comment, or point out a few safety measures a viewer might want to be aware of, but if they reply with belligerence, then they deserve to suffer all the harsh comments we can throw at them.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#10

Re: Chuck

Dick Wilson

I didn't think of it but you are correct. It is a metal lathe!! Oh, brother :( :(

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#11

Mike Stafford

Back in the olden days...

Mike Stafford

There were no woodturning chucks. Everyone used machinists chucks. As a matter of fact in one of Ray Key's box turning videos he uses a machinist's chuck to good effect and explains what advantages and disadvantages it offers in certain situations over a woodturning chuck.

No doubt the protruding ears on the jaws offer danger to the careless turner but so do the slides of a woodturning chuck if they are allowed to protrude beyond the chuck body. I actually have jaws similar to those in the video for my Axminster although I infrequently use them

Compared to some of the other woodturning videos I have seen on YouTube this is one of the safer I have seen.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#12

safety issue

adrien

I'm with you, Mike. This didn't seem that unsafe to me. He seemed to be using scrapers rather than gouges which is what industrial arts teachers often import to their students because they are a bit safer and the learning curve for them is much shorter.

His use of a sanding block was interesting.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#13

Jesper, Denmark

Re:The language is Swedish......

Jesper, Denmark

....and the wood turned is Laburnum. It is a common garden tree here in Northern Europe and a prized wood for small objects. Unfortunately, the tree rarely gets very big, so decent size logs are quite valuable.

The text does warn about safety in a couple of places, but there are no golden nuggets there, so not worth translating the whole thing.

Other than using a machinists lathe and chuck with spinning knuckle busters, and wearing a lose watch, I don't see any glaring safety issues.

The technique with only a scaper and parting tool is vary basic, but that was used by many turners not so long ago.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#14

Steven Antonucci

Why it's called a chuck

steven antonucci

If you accidentally put your hand in the wrong spot, that's what it turns your hand into. Certainly requires a focused turner...

Otherwise, didn't seem too bad to me either. Scrapers ...eh? maybe spend less time taping videos, and more time in a book...

Steve

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#15

A piece of Inner Tube....

Barry Irby

stretched around those jaws would be a major improvement. Not only make the danger zone clearly visible but would most probably keep your hand out of the way.

With my short attention span I would get hurt.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#16

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest

Dick Wilson

You can post comments to any videos that you think are dangerous, which I have. I posted a comment to this particular video suggesting that he paint the jaws orange so he can see where they are while turning. You can also report dangerous/harmful videos to YouTube, which I have, and interesting enough the videos have been taken down. I don't know if YouTube did it or the turner did it, same result. Newbies don't try these unsafe practices.

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest *LINK*

#17

Re: Scary Turning Video Contest

charlie belden

Other than the Knuckle Buster chuck being a bit scary - it shows one of the many ways to turn a simple lidded box - in this case with a scraper or two and a parting tool. The nice thing about turning is that there are so many ways to skin a cat. If you find one that does what you want to do - use it. If you figure out a better way - then use that method.

I often use a japanese pull saw similar to the one used in the video to cut the lid from the box on my blank, especially when getting a really good grain match acrossed the lid to box joint. The saw kerf is MUCH thinner than any parting tool you can find - that works.

As to the resulting box being ugly - that is not because of the method he used. Hell, I can turn an ugly little box - and I've got two scroll chucks and ALL the jaw sets - and a tool case full of gouges and chisels - along with an articulated captured system (MiniMonster).

The knuckle buster chuck? Not what I'd use. The rest of the procedure in the video? If it works . . .