Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

Posts

CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#1

CA glue  and punky wood...What happened?

Randy Johnson

Last night I was working with a piece of spalted maple. It soon became obvious that the part that would be the bottom was too punky for any kind of attachment. I thought that a good soaking with thin CA glue would make it firm enough to, at the very least, give a glued on sacrificial block a chance of staying attached while I turned the piece.

When I started squirting the glue on the wood I noticed what looked like smoke or steam rising from the wood. Along with this was acid like fumes. It quickly became so bad that I had to set the wood down and retreat to the other side of the shop for a few minutes.

I�ve done this before, but this is the first time there has ever been a reaction between the wood and the glue like that.

What kind of chemical reaction was going on?

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#2

Re: CA glue  and punky wood...What happened?

Doc Green

Randy, I don't know anything about the chemistry involved but I observe this frequently when I apply thin CA to punky wood. Considerable heat is generated and the fumes can cause allergic reactions in some people. This should be done only in a well ventilated area. ~Doc

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#3

Re: CA glue  and punky wood...What happened?

john lucas

It's a combination of moisture in the wood and too much glue. When it cures this fast not only does it release a lot of fumes that are really nasty but it will often change to foam (the white stuff) and may not be as strong. It also might not penetrate as far as you would like. Try applying it in smaller doses. Turn your dust collector on near it or run a fan across to dissipate the fumes.

Another option that will take considerably longer to dry is diluted PVA glue. Cut your yellow or white glue with water until it's fairly thin and coat the area with quite a few layers. It will take overnight to dry but really toughens up the wood. I have not used this option on areas of the actual bowl so I can't comment on how it will affect the finishing. I'm certain it won't take stain the same as the rest of the bowl but then the CA section won't either.

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#4

Re: CA

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

What you're describing is a fast cure of the glue which can be caused by excess moisture or other volatiles in the wood. Remember that fast cured CA is quite a bit weaker than a slow cure in the same situation.

Aside from John's suggestion of thin PVA, you can strengthen the wood with resins. Polyall 2000 is a 2-part polyester system that will penetrate very deeply, but it sets up very fast (1-2 minutes!) so you'd have to work quickly. Another branded product is marketed to boaters called "Get-Rot" which is a very thin 2-part epoxy system that will penetrate the wood fibers. Lastly (that I know of ;) ) you can thin regular epoxy with DNA, after mixing in the hardener, by not more than 30% by volume to get a penetrating liquid. The resins should be allowed to cure over night and you should use more epoxy to mount your waste block rather than PVA.

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#5

Re: CA

John Lucas

Mark just made me remember about System 3 Mirror coat. You can get it at Woodcraft. It is a self leveling epoxy designed to coat bar tops. The advantage for what your doing is that it gets extremely viscous as it cures. It will penetrate punky wood very deep and is very solid.

I've had it go all the way through an end grain piece. The downside is it takes 12 hours or so to cure and it isn't cheap. However it's also quite useful if you want to do inlay work with clear epoxy over it. I cut a depression in the wood and then put anything from buttons and coins to leaves. Then fill the depression with the mirror coat and let it harden. It turns well and is fun to use.

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#6

Re: CA glue  and punky wood...What happened?

Don Evans

My opinion only, life seems this way in all things. Want the best results take time, willing to settle for 2nd best or less then it is ok to takae the faster route. It's kind of like fast food verse 4 star restuarant. Better food takes time, in a hurry, then settle for no taste but something in your stomach!

I will use CA glue but very seldom, we still don't really know what the long term results are going to be, what you make today my come apart 10 years from now so I don't use it very often, maybe on something that isn't made to last long anyway like most pens etc.

If you think this piece of wood is worth the effort, why don't you try the stuff (type of epoxy) made to repair rotten wood in window sills and stuff like that? This stuff is made exactly for what you are doing but there is a problem with hiding it in some cases like this. If I can hide it in the turning somehow, I would go with it.

Regarding you problem I think it was just moisture speeding the curing process. Don't breath the fumes.

Don

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#7

Re: CA

Craig Daymon

John,

Keep in mind that when you say System 3 "isn't very cheap", Randy was using CA glue. Ounce for ounce, I suspect that almost any epoxy will be cheaper than CA, even West Systems. Check out Raka for marine epoxy similar to West Systems. Last I checked, they were about half the price of West Systems. (http://www.raka.com)

My preference is epoxy, as it is machinable after hardening and not brittle like CA. It definitely WILL impact your finishing options, but you can add stain/coloring before using it. I've used black chalk line from the big box store to get a nice ebony in fill look. (It doesn't penetrate very deeply this way though.)

-Craig

P.S. Why not Minwax wood hardener?

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#8

Re: Minwax

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Craig,

My understanding of the Minwax product is that it's a solvent-based prep, much like, if not actually, lacquer, and is more for firming a surface for finishing rather than reconstitution of the structural integrity of the wood fibers. Wood gets "punky" because the fungus (white rot, etc.) has eaten the lignin which is the basic resin that holds the fibers together. Epoxy or polyester resins will be a much stronger replacement.

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#9

Brad Vietje

And ... It's VERY Toxic!

Brad Vietje

Re: CA glue and punky wood...What happened?

#10

Thanks for the tip Craig.   

john lucas