pith checking?
nick
Some woods are very prone to checking around the pith during drying. Which woods are less prone to this type of check?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
pith checking?
nick
Some woods are very prone to checking around the pith during drying. Which woods are less prone to this type of check?
Re: pith checking?
B. Leathers
"Haven't found a wood that didn't like to check at pith during drying process.That's why Bruce Hoadley recommends avoiding pith.
Re: pith checking?
john lucas
I don't leave the pith in very often. However when I was starting out with green wood I often did, with mostly disastrous results. Dogwood however was surprisingly good. Those pieces were turned thin but not extremely thin because I wasn't that good. I remember making several goblets from dogwood limb sections. I would place the pith off center so it would only show up in the foot and bowl not in the stem.
Re: pith checking? *LINK*
Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas
Nick, You would do well to study the wood shrinkage values tables found in "The Encyclopedia of Wood" or Hoadly's "Understanding Wood".
What you want to find, is low number with the least difference between tangental and radial ratio. Also, if there is a volumetric table, the lower numbers will be better than high.
Of course there are other considerations, like Tension perpendicular to the grain relative to Compression perpendicular to the grain. Most are higher on the compression side, but a few are the other way, like Tupelo, Sweetgum, Sycamore, Yellow Poplar, to name a few.
However a better thing to know, is that having more shape, like cup or cone, rather than being a large flat section perpendicular to the grain, helps relieving the stress deferential.
http://www.woodcentral.com/bparticles/woodmove.shtml
Re: pith checking?
Bill Howatt
I know what you mean by not having it show up in the stem. A few weeks ago I was making a thin stem for a sea-urchin shell and since the wood was some kind of a hard exotic I thought I would take it down just a bit more. Result was I broke through to the pith and ended up with an ugly scar down the stem. I didn't realize that I had mounted the piece perfectly on the pith.
My general assessment is that pith is bad news and should be eliminated if possible. Branches entering the trunk also contain pith.
Bill
Re: pith checking?
Ralph Lindberg
Every wood can pitch check
Probably the least (and that may not be saying much) prone is mature hardwoods, main trunk, old trees (probably not Fruit trees though)
Turning green helps, either to final thickness or rough and boil.
Re: pith checking?
robo hippy
I don't know that I have ever cut up a log that didn't already have a check or two right off the pith. It is a weak point. Even having it at the bottom of a hollow form or end grain turned piece will not stop it from cracking, especially if a crack is already there. During the drying process, cracks get bigger, not smaller.
robo hippy
Re: pith checking?
Dick Wilson
Nick,
I can't think of any species that won't cause you pith trouble in the long run. For bowls and other open turnings I get away from the pith before I even put it on the lathe. The only form I sometimes leave the pith in is hollow forms. The pith is centered on the top and bottom. After turning the form and a tenon for the chuck I CA glue the entire bottom and let it dry good. Chuck it and hollow the inside. After hollowing to final wall I liberally coat inside bottom with CA glue ( when I'm done you can't see it anyway. PS - If you turn from start to finish at one session no problem. If you leave turning for more that say ten minutes cover turning in plastic grocery bag and tape it off. Air movement will kill you.
I will be the first to admit that I have had pieces go south on me, hey, its the vagaries of wood. I have had a much larger percentage come out great. 10 years from now ????????????????????????????????
softwoods
Dale Lenz
Many of my pine, fir, spruce 2x4 has the pith in the center, no checking, maybe my ERC(?). Most if not all of the hardwoods I've use will check from the center of the stem.
Re: softwoods
Peter Lamb in SC
I am a fan of Turners Choice from Cedarcide. I have been experimenting with freshly cut Live Oak and Cherry rough turned and 3" branches up to 10"in length then soaked in Turners Choice for 24 hours dried for at least 72 hours. I have been amazed, no splits or cracks in the pith weeks later. This effort is in the early stages but so far like bowl blanks the results are as hoped for.
agree, dogwood...
GaryG in MD
John, You took the word right out of my mouth. I have a number of dogwood branches (6" - 8" dia.) that I cut green and have been able to dry without pith cracks. ...Gary
Re: pith checking?
nick
Thanks to all for your replies. I avoid the pith but I've seen very large turnings that include it without checks.