In an earlier post I noted that several vases I have in metal, "cinnabar" and porcelin have a base/stand rather than a more common to wood turned "foot" for vases and hollow forms. So I've been playing with doing different bases. Turned a hollow form out of some punky dry spalted birch, leaving a tenon on the bottom and then turned a claro walnut base for it out of dry wood. The arches are where the flat faces of the original square blank were. Used an oscillating spindle sander to create the arches. HF is a bit over 4" in diameter.
I've turned another base but haven't parted it off so no photos with it yet.
Apologies for the photo quality - it's a Q&D (Quick & Dirty) pic just to quickly show the idea and effect.
Very different from the more common "foot". With a different base the piece's look can be changed
easily.
The hollow form has no finish on it - merely sanded to 8000. Base finish is Mahoney Walnut Oil.
Anyone else care to share pics of pieces they've done with a base rather than a foot?
I suspect that this project will involve a lot of planning, Charlie. In general, we work to make two things that look good, and then look good together. Not sure these two are married?
I might like this better if the upper vessel passed through a stand, but right now it terminates at the stand and it just stops my eye. I'm also not a fan of the mixed woods proportion- less walnut would make it easier to distinguish the vessel. I think it's a light/dark thing?
Charlie Ive only used a base a few times as I soon came to the conclusion although practical they distort the image of the form and are plain Ugly .Ive tried Greek forms with bases again the proportions end up all wrong.
To work with the magic mean pieces will generally fall over as the base is so small so
My preference is to now have feet so the forms curve flows right through the piece giving a sense of movement and grace
These works are very early in my journey as a turner but you will see even 10 years ago I wasn't afraid to experiment and play
These three in my seed pod series have taken me on many differnt directions
Charlie I would cut into your base/carve pierce so it is minimal and you can see the form through it make it 3 D it will draw the eye in
You are absolutely correct in noting that this will take a bit more planning than doing more familiar turned pieces, in part because there are so few existing examples of turned pieces to study and find the underlying "rules" like those that have already been worked out for traditional turned pieces. Can the Rule of Thirds or Fifths be applied - and if so how? Can the Neck 1/5th the diameter and the Base 2/5ths or 3/5ths proportions apply? How do you combine two distinctly different components in a way that creates a coherent synergy rather than a discordant mash up?
I think the challenge with this Base Thing is to find the aesthetic "rules" for the combination that MAY be significantly different from those rules we're familiar with.
Turners think in terms of the "rules" for turned forms - the curve of a bowl or hollow form should appear to continue on through the foot, the bottom of that curve visually implied as touching the ground within the foot. And the foot itself plays a very minor role normally, merely there to keep the piece from falling over.
When we woodturners think of a "pedestal" piece it's usually more in terms of a long stemmed goblet - tall thin stem. And for a Stemmed Goblet piece, the "pedestal" is typically done in a color that contrasts with the vessel part of the piece, usually an almost black or actually black wood stem. Because the stem is typically so thin and delicate, it's visual impact is minimal - more a line pointing to and supporting the focus of the piece - the "vessel" is supports.
When it comes to the vase or jar form, which, in other mediums - stone, ceramic or glass - usually have the "S" profile of classic vases and some jar forms - we skip or minimize the reverse curve towards the bottom - the bottom quarter of the "S".
I looked around and found these pieces with a "base" - a starting point for working out some initial "rules"
Now, regarding carrying the "vase" into the base, if you look at the profile - the bottom curve of the vase transitions to a reverse curve in the base - just below the top bead.
If you think in terms of a statue - elevated on a base - the expectation is just that - a platform on which to elevate and display the focus - the piece. It's much trickier to smoothly integrate a separate base with the piece itself. But that's not to say it can't be done. May be just a matter of trying, trying again.
For starters, I don't particularly like a lot of the things you posted as examples. I think a few are just ugly. Doesn't matter if they are wood or something else. People working in other mediums also make ugly things. It's not just woodturners.
I also don't think it's about rules. I certainly believe that using design guidelines makes a lot of sense, as you lower the chance of making something ugly. Sure, you can take risks and push the rules, but don't be surprised if it fails. Failure is a part of life.
I have a whole workshop full of experiments that I keep around just to remind me what happens sometimes when you push the rules. (They push back). this vessel just has too many curves in it, and it kind of looks like a light bulb. If I had the option, I'd remount it and turn the bottom under. I might thin the support ring to provide a band and thin the legs to look much less heavy.
Or, you could put it on your shelf as a learning experience...
In your examples, the bases are clearly - bases. They work as the fess up to being bases, not trying to be part of the object shape.
Your "lightbulb" base tries to be part of the shape, and I don't think the overall shape works - with or without a different colored base. Looking at it, you are afraid that it will topple over any minute - and it is also clear that that was not the intention of the piece.
The examples in the photo of objects that have a base are just pieces I have around the house, some functional, some purely decorative - and in different mediums. Hey, ya gotta start somewhere. And even a bad piece can get you thinking about WHY it�s bad - and maybe what changes could be made to make it better. If the maxim �We often learn the most from our mistakes� is true, even bad examples can be valuable.
Call them Rules, Guidelines or Design Envelopes - there are underlying principles at work in any set of aesthetics. If you have some understanding of them - and apply them - more or less - you�re more apt to end up with a nicer piece than an uglier one.
Yes, the main component of the piece I did as an initial foray into �with a base� looks like a light bulb. And adding a base to it only made it more Light Bulbish. It was a piece I had laying around I could use for a starting point for exploration. The walnut for the base was just some dry wood I had on hand to play with - that would contrast with the wood of the �bulb�.
There WAS some planning for this first attempt. If you take the photo of this first attempt into a CAD program, do some measuring and then some calcs you'll see that some of the common guidelines/rules were applied - albeit in a Mix & Match way. The piece - with base - is made up of five curves, adajcent curves meeting at their tangent points.
Looking back, it's clear to me now that the "base" should have started from the 4th from the top horizontal RED line rather than the third horizontal red line. THAT might reduce the Light Bulb Look of the overall piece.
Regarding the legs/feet needing thinning/narrowing - you�re right. Correcting that would be easy to do with an oscillating spindle sander. But I figured it�s a lot easier to REMOVE wood than to put it back - so I started thick/wide knowing I COULD make them thinner/narrower. I like having options - just part of the way I approach things.
This Piece With Base exploration may lead nowhere. But it is interesting to explore possibilities for areas I haven�t seen tried - a departure form what�s out there NOW - stepping Out Of The Box always being fun.
This is a "fixit" - something went wrong with the foot, so I added a different colored wood as a fix. It's not anything interesting, but somehow I left it around the shop as an example for further options to explore later.
i think that in principle, the foot works, as it is clearly a separate feature from the original bowl, and in that respect similar to the objects you showed from around the house.
Since I have only ever done this as a fix, I have to admit that my first reactions to this kind of thing is:" Turned throught the bottom, did you?"
This is an example of one of the uses of a base. For an actual round bottomed piece, a base with a concave to would allow the piece to be displayed tilted at various angles, something not possible with a fixed foot.
Last night I took the liberty to paste your light bulb into a simple picture editor and turned it upside down and..."Whoooaa!"... sez me. Then I blacked out the background and the base, and just admired the excellence of the simple form. NOW I could visualize various separate bases that would give the piece a look of stability as well as elegance. What do you think?
I've always hated rococo. the idea of too much on top of too much always seemed like too much to me.
Simple things seem to be more beautiful because of the simplicity. We marvel at the line, color or form. One curve. One color. A Greek Tragedy- a single place and time with few characters.
I recommend you explore the ideas with this in mind. One thing done well.
Re: I like where you are going. I took some libert
charlie belden
Of COURSE! - he said slapping himself on the forehead - once again. Classic example of Big Blind Spot - pursuing a bad idea when there's a good one on an immediately adjacent path.
This is also a great example of Seeing What You Expect To See rather than See What's Actually There. If you want to actually see what you have - a plate, platter, bowl, hollow form or a lidded box - turn it upside down. Curves that don't blend together, or a curve that just doesn't work quite right will jump out at you when you disorient your mind's eye from what it expects to see and make it see what's actually there.
And you brought up a great design tool - image manipulation software. With it you can take a photo of a piece, cut and paste components of the whole and then mainipulate them - flip horizontally or vertically, squeeze or stretch, pinch some areas of a component and pull others, scale components up or down. Graphics manipulation programs are visual equivalents to word processors. You can start with aa First Draft of a visual story, then edit it to create revisions, then edit a promising revision and refine it - while keeping the original - and earlier revisions.
I played with the image in PhotoShop, flipping the HF as you did and could see what you've discovered. Ironically, I see a light bulb transformed into its ancestor - a lantern.
"A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words" is so true when it comes to The Visual Arts. So how about posting the image you put together?
One of the many great things about this site is that you can get other perspectives of an initial idea. More eyes looking the greater the probability of seeing something that's wrong or missing. More minds on an idea the greater the chance of collaboratively "fixing" problems.
Like you, I play with images of pieces others post here - both to study them as well as to occassionally graphically "tweek" them. And like you, I'm hesitant to post "tweeked" images. For anyone out there who has or wants to tweek any image I share here - PLEASE DO! - and post what you've come up with,
While I'm a fan of Sumie - a minimalist evocative form of painting, and I agree that a single simple form, done to perfection is preferable to an overly done, busy piece - there are practical considerations to think about - and maybe use.
You're Greek Tradgedy is a good example. The plays are performed without much stage settings, special lighting or accompanyng musical score. BUT - they were performed on a stage that elevated the performers so the audience could see them - or better yet, performed on a stage in an amphitheater - that had great accoustics. Pehaps the use of a "base" can be approached as a stage for the performer rather than a part of the play itself.
A base may also serve a function. Take a classic Calabash form. The original calabash bowl is inherently unstabile. As a vessel - in its orignal context - it could have a rounded bottom - because it was placed on sand, dirt or a soft mat. We, on the other hand, have flat hard surfaces that we put things on - tables, displace pedestals, shelves, mantles. If we want a calabash form to sit a certain way, a base makes a lot of sense. Getting it to work with the piece - that can be tricky - but do able - I think. May not be possible in all cases for all forms - but worth exploring.