I just watched someone turn a bowl without a faceplate or chuck. He used a skew, a bowl gouge and started with 60 grit paper then smoothed it out with 100. He left the tool rest in place when he sanded the inside of the bowl. His tools were so dull all he was getting was dust. I can't believe what some people put out for public consumption!
One if the initial things that attracted people to YouTube was people posting street fighting videos. Odd thing is that you'd think most people would be smart enough not to post videos of themselves commiting crimes, yet there you go...
Seems that woodturners aren't much different. I saw a video of a guy doing backyard metal casting in shorts. The steam explosion he got probably made him change those shorts. Videos of stupid people with chainsaws dropping trees on their houses are also all over the place.
I could not get past the first 3 minutes of that one! LOL Has to be about the worst I have seen for woodturning. And I don't know that I could get dust like that from green wood (he specifically stated it was green) if I tried! Painful indeed.
That guy is something else. Most turners could have had the outside rough turned with a bowl gouge in 1/3 the time it took him just to round it out. I loved it in the comments where he said he had been lathing a whole month. Now that is Scarey.
I'm happy to have been able to learn something from someone who has been "lathing" a whole month!
This guy is certainly a leading candidate for a forthcoming Darwin Award...
In the last woodturning class I taught a few weeks ago, I deliberately told the participants to NOT watch You Tube turning videos if they wanted to learn proper woodturning technique. While there are exceptions, the majority of those that I've seen are quite poor. This is a perfect case-in-point!
Thanks for the chuckle Barbara - unfortunately this is so sad (and dangerous) that the humor is short-lived. Whatever compels grossly inexperienced people to put this kind of stuff up for worldwide consumption is beyond me....
Thanks for heads up on video. I haven't watched it yet but I can tell you that without seeing it that is not the worst video. A couple of months ago there was one that was much worse.
The guy had a large limb crotch on the lathe between centers. I am not kidding when I say that one of the smaller limbs ( probably 4-5" in diameter) stuck out a good 5-6" from the body of the crotch. He turned the lathe on and the whole thing started dancing. He positioned his tool rest and proceeded to turn the piece round with a ROUGHING GOUGE!!!! It was the scariest, most painful thing to watch. When he was done after what seemed like an hour the whole turning was a cylinder. Apparently he never heard of a chain saw.
One of the things you can do is go below the video screen and you can send a report to YouTube about harmful or dangerous videos. I did. I along with a dozen viewers comment on the video. To say the least they were all very negative and rude. The video was pulled, I don't know if he or YouTube pulled it, but it is gone.
I wonder if his tool set includes a scraper. It looked to me like he pretty much used all his tools like scrapers, anyway. I also noticed that he adjusted his tool rest without loosening (or re-tightening) the thumbscrew. I wonder if he brags about being self-taught?
I think that he's really not very different than many of the beginning turners I meet. The main difference is that most of them know that they need help, and he thinks his problem is that he doesn't have the money to be a good turner.
I suspect that given the same tools and conditions, I could actually reproduce his bowl in one video, since it probably wouldn't require the 15 minutes of sanding he taped. I'd probably skip using my skew as a negative rake scraper and just use a regular scraper to save my edges.
I think that his comments were typical. Someone said something negative, his kneejerk reaction was to fight back. The people that posted the comments probably could have used a nicer tone. I seem to recall someone pulling a video a while back after a bunch of WCer's approached them. A lot of times, it's going to be about how you deliver the message and not the words themselves.
Pretty sad...I watched the last couple of minutes of #3. I cringed when he was sanding inside using a large piece of 60 grit while the tool rest was still in place.
A very fitting ending when he parted off on the inside with the skew and the bowl went flying.
I shouldn't have watched that because now I want to go in the shop, set up a video camera and make a bowl without a faceplate of a chuck to show how it can be done safely and efficiently. Problem with that is that I had surgery for carpal tunnel syndrome today and if I go to the shop SWMBO will kill me (and be totally justified in her actions). I just hope the kid in the video lives long enough to read some of the advice he has been given and is smart enough to listen.