I bought the gate some years ago and tried/used it a couple of times. I thought that I could get deeper, or work with better control or something but...well, I just don't get it. And especially I wonder why the saddle pin was made to extend through and beyond the support bottom...limiting the extension into the opening by about another 3/8". Worse still, it seems to me, is that my absolute best tool for deep, controlled cuts, is my "Eliminator" which won't fit into the saddle.
Anybody here find this gate to be indispensible? Anybody want to trade something for mine?
I only got the cutter bars, never the whole set up. Works fine in my D bar and had an adapter made for my Monster when I got it, so no need for the whole set up. The standard comfort tool rest works fine. I have the newer Mark 8 bowl coring system which has a yoke on it for the hollowing bar, and thought it was in the way.
I've looked at these devices as well as the pin type devices that go in a tool rest. I don't see why you would need one. I don't seem to have any trouble removing all the wood I want without one. Always ready to learn however.
Don't think it's a matter of how much wood you are removing, but one of control and leverage. I see the gate as sort of a midway option between unsupported handheld and a full captured rig.
I have the Irons gate and use it relatively regularly. I find it gives a little more control, and maybe a little leverage. What it really excels at for me is allowing me to reach deeper into forms such as those that Binh Pho or Frank Sudol makes/d. Deep bowls like these are really turned like hollow forms as they are end grain. I can use the Hunter tools deeper and more confidently than I can reach with a regular rest. You can extend the gate right into the form, which gets your support about 3-4" closer to the bottom than if the rest is outside the form. I do find that the range of motion seems to be a little more confining, and wind up repositioning the rest a lot.
Mike On open forms like Binh Pho's I just stick the end of my straight tool rest in as far as it will go. I would think that it will go in further than the irons rest.
I usually do that as well. Sometimes I find that I feel a little more comfortable when the rest is skewed to the work ( the angle of the rest gets close to the angle of the tool) with the Irons gate. I find I get a little nervous about sliding off the end of the rest at times, especially if I'm really concentrating on the cut like a thin walled turning. The Irons gate takes that out of the picture. It also allows more of a perpendicular support. I don't know how to describe that, but it just feels more comfortable and solid to me. Like I said, the downside is that I find myself repositioning the rest more often.