I enjoy making promo images for my work, in order to build my marketing. Not all of them will be Vogue magazine worthy, but I'm constantly working to try and get people's attention.
What does this have to do with woodturning? Selling work! I'm sure we can ALL use more sales!
So... in that interest -- I would like a CRITIQUE of the below photograph. (Not the turnings -- they're as they should be). I'd like a discussion of what you think is good or bad, what could use improvement.
Does the photo entice you? (Does it entice you enough to buy something, (if you crocheted))? What about the colors, wording, layout???
Let me know what you think!
(My goal here is to get thinking about how you would promote your work, and generate ideas that we can all benefit from!)
Put a name or a color where the pretty is located, or even a number. The person looking at it should be able to say "I like the Samantha", which happens to be the fourth one from the top. Or "Send me a #32 and a #41."
Avoid "cutesy". The hooks are pretty and saying it is not necessary.
...is too "hard," and a more diffused light source would still show the shiny surfaces. Without the defined edges of the shadows, the forms would appear to be more crisp. And the white background could be less distracting if the exposure was adjusted, also easily manipulated with software - it appears to be slightly overexposed on my corrected monitor, and the colors of the woods would then be more saturated.
I disagree with Ed, keep the "pretty" comments, but maybe have a font that seems to imply conversation, or animation. For the final word on the subject, I think you should wait for some feedback from some gals. What I wonder about is the white background and the color of the font. I feel that a graidated background appears richer, and some fun colors on the fonts may imply that different people are commenting on the hooks. Nice work on the hooks as usual.
It looks like the hook size varies with them so why not identify what size they are along with a name for each. Maybe some acknowledgement you can make any design/color in a given hook sizes requested?
I don't crochet, so I don't know exactly what your image needs to be, but I would want to show the product in whatever setting you think your target audience would want to use it. Perhaps a nice ball of alpaca wool in a nicely made basket, with the hook coordinated to the yarn color?
I dislike "pretty" and the glaring white backdrop. It makes me think mass produced (the white, not the pretty... the pretty makes me think craft, which makes me think "less expensive"). I'd want to convey an image of luxury, and someone "treating themselves" to one of your hooks, since you can buy the cheap metal ones for $1 at Michael's.
What are the qualities of your hooks (product) which make them a product and not a commodity?
"Pretty" is one of those qualities which separates your product from mass production. I suspect that the feel in your hands is different. If you can qualify that difference then express that in words and pictures. For example wood tends to be a more neutral temperature than metal. Wood tends to have a texture that can't be duplicated with metal so that the wood hooks are less fatiguing than metal.
I know with bowl gouges there are some which are my goto gouges and others which sit in the rack. I like the way some tools feel and work. If you can express that in a picture then it would likely be a good thing.
Take pictures of a bunch of hooks. Some you make and some that are store bought. Adjust the picture so that your hooks stand out and the store bought hooks look like background. Like a Lexus in a parking lot full of Yugos.
These are tools you are making. Show what the tools can do. Connect store bought hooks with drab looking crochet and your hooks with exciting vibrant looking crochet.
Show hands holding the hooks. Tired sore hands holding store bought hooks and lively supple hands holding your hooks.
Hi Katherine, As you probably know, VW had a very successful ad campaign in the 60's, showing a photo of their "bug" with the words "Ugly", "Lemon", etc. underneath. I like "pretty", but not overdone...just once. Then text to explain why they are more than just pretty.
I'm a crochet-er, and I like the white background for the stark contrast
to the colors. I also like how you've alternated the colors, the two greens
off-set to balance each other right and left, etc. And I like the repeated
list of the word 'Pretty.' Frankly, it makes a buyer think, "why shouldn't what I work with be Pretty? just for me..."
But, I'm put off by the last line "I'm Pretty, Too." It is hard to describe why.
I think, it is coming across as either an 'excuse' for the new design, smaller
steel hooks embedded in the turned handles, or, and I realize this is off-base,
but the implication of it placed directly above the artist's name, gives some
subliminal impression of attaching the compliment to the artist, instead of
the hooks.
My suggestion would be to treat the two different types of hooks as 'paragraphs' in the photo. Use the Pretty-Pretty-Pretty repeats on the all-wood hooks, then skip several white spaces, arrange several wood-handled steel hooks and among them use the "I'm Pretty, Too!" then list something like 'Handmade by...' as the artist.
At least, that's what I'd do. I've long admired your photography. Your pages are always attractive. Thanks for sharing.
Normally I would not like things just stacked up like that. However you by staggering them and then putting the words down below each one you've created a sort of rhythm bouncing down from top to bottom. I think it works. I think the I'm pretty too is sort of like putting a period at the end of a sentence, it finishes it off. The "pretty" almost comes off as a subliminal message. Maybe you could put in smaller lighter print the words "buy me"
Usually I prefer to shoot groups like this at an angle. However this emphasises one end over the other and might work with the carved ends forward.
On both my home computer and work computer the pieces seem a hair light. It could be because the white is too bright which sort of mutes the colors.
I have to dissagree with Jamie I think a smaller light that makes a slightly more defined shadow would give the pieces more 3 dimensionality. It would produce a smaller bright hot spot instead of the long diffuse highlight you have now. I would have to play with it to see.
I think what might contribute to the 'too light' look (my impression) is that all of the text is light and strikes me as bleached out in combination with the white background. I have to admit I was confused by the repetition of 'pretty' when I first looked at the graphic. I sort of wondered whether these were good because they were decorative, and if they were really for use. Perhaps if you alternated 'pretty' with something function-related -- e.g., "I work" or something adjectival. Since you effectively have four pairs, an alternation would work. Or simply a single label along the lines of "I'm pretty [look good?] AND I work".
I've been very interested to read everyone's responses to my marketing image. (And forgive the spelling in the initial post title -- my dyslexic fingers added one too many "t"s!) I've been fascinated to see how each of us perceives the image differently.
I'd like to tell you about my philosophy for this image:
Background: I use white for almost all of my product images -- mostly because it looks kind of "cool" to see a crochet hook "floating" on the screen, as though you could simply grab it! It's also for convenience -- the hooks come from 8 separate images, which I combined with software. (For artwork, I generally do use a gradient or colored background, and this in turn differentiates it from my production work). But products have to be eye-candy, ready to leap off the screen and into a client's hands!
Crochet hooks: I wanted to present a variety of colors and types of hooks, to show people exactly what is available right now. Each is one-of-a-kind, and with the text I include, "you can find these at my eBay store, (link), etc. etc." they'll know where to find them and what to expect. (I agree that the photography could be better -- I'm always working on it... And thank you to all of the pros out there willing to share your knowledge!)
Font: This is a font I use for all of my images, it's part of my branding. John hit upon exactly what I was working toward... the color of the "Prettys" is a light gray so that the colorful hooks stand out! It is indeed intended to be a semi-subliminal message. (The excessive repetition almost makes it a background or like "wallpaper"). The last "I'm Pretty Too!" is an effort to break the complete symmetry of the image. (Thanks Barb for pointing out your feelings on the "compliment to the artist" -- that was NOT what I was after!
Use of the "Pretty" wording also begs disagreement/interaction. I can't tell you how many e-mail comments I've gotten saying, "they're not pretty, they're gorgeous!" etc. By playing down the beauty of the pieces, I've encouraged action from my clientele. (Every interaction is an excellent opportunity to improve the relationship with your clients.) Most of the time, the "disagreement" is in the mind, but still begs action -- wanting to see a larger image, the price, etc.
The Titles on top and bottom are in slightly darker gray to grab more attention, and are slightly "forward" of the "background."
This is part of a series of marketing images, which so far as been very successful. I am selling to people who know what the product is; new folks and also return clients. The idea is to present these pieces to be maximally appealing to this particular group of people, generating sales, interest, and new clients.
Here are a couple thoughts from a non-crocheting marketing type....
1. Less is more. My first impression is that the composition is confusing. The pieces themselves are visually very busy by nature because of the highly-contrasted colored laminates. By grouping them so closely, in an offset arrangement as you have here, it creates a lot of tension, pulling the viewer's eye in different directions instead of focusing it on the key feature that you want to dominate the advertisement.
2. Features and benefits. Unless people collect these crochet hooks simply because they're pretty, I think it would be good to somehow tell prospective customers (or show them) why they should prefer your hooks to the alternative. What is/are the alternatives anyhow? Can you crochet faster? Are your hooks more ergonomic? Feel better? You can aver to these benefits perhaps by having a sad-looking conventional hook on the left, with a tag line or label under it, contrasted dramatically with your gorgeous hook on the right. This would also give viewers a gnomon with which to judge the size of your hooks. Otherwise, there is no way of knowing exactly how long or thick your hooks actually are.
Just top-of-my-head stuff you might want to consider.