Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Joe Meirhaeghe
Any one here use the Kelton hollowing tools? Any thoughts or comments from anyone who has used them.
Thanks
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Joe Meirhaeghe
Any one here use the Kelton hollowing tools? Any thoughts or comments from anyone who has used them.
Thanks
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Jeff Willaford
Joe, I have the three smaller (5/8" set, 1/2" set and 5/16" set) sets of Kelton Hollowers and really like them. The shapes included seem to cover the range for me with hand held hollowing. I'd buy them again in a hearbeat.
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Carole Valentine
Great tools. I have two sets of all sizes and use them almost exclusively for both freehand and captured rig hollowing. I have a ton of other hollowing tools which basically just sit in the drawer instead of in my "tools that I use" rack.
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Terry Scott
Joe for the large hollow forms I do I wouldn't do with out them .Especially if it is very hard mallee burl .The new Collated handles are especially nice to use.
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Doc Green
I have the 1/2 and 5/8" sets. They are my go-to tools. A sweet combination is a 5/8" Kelton tool mounted in the articulated arm system made by Randy of Superior Design & Machine. The laser takes some of the "adventure" out the hollowing process.
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Carole Valentine
As Terry said, the hollowers combined with the new Kelton colleted handles are a great combination. And for larger hand hollowing without a rig the torque arresting handle adds a lot of control.
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
glenn roberts
I have been using them for years. compared to many other options ( I have tried a few!!) they work. Yes they don't always produce a big shaving or sometimes don't remove wood as fast as other options but all round they are 'reliable' and generally more 'controllable' (not nasty catches or clogging). Plus their ability to get into small openings and their ability to hold an edge.
I hope this helps.
The reason I don't use them.
John Lucas
My first hollowing tool was a Kelton, second was a Sorby with multiple bits. I didn't like the Kelton because of the non interchangeable bits. I was new to turning and ground my tools down fairly quickly because of my inept sharpening skills. I could see where I would use up the Kelton in fairly short order so I sold it and bought the Sorby. It was OK but I didn't like the selection of tips and made some of my own. I still use it on occasion.
My choice was the John Jordan tools. I liked the idea of the replaceable HSS tips that are quite inexpensive and last a fairly good while. The curves on his tools do the job well. I have since made many more of my own tools for special needs but still use the same HSS inserts.
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Paul Zerjay
I have been using mine for about 4 years and have not begun to put a dent in their sharpening life. Does that make sense?
Re: The reason I don't use them.
Carole Valentine
If you manage to grind a Kelton hollower down beyond the usable stage, you have 1) either had it for about a century! or 2) are doing a lot of unnecessary grinding! They only take a few swipes with a stone or diamond card, with only very rare trips to the grinder, and then only for an ever so light touch. My oldest and most used ones are about 5 years old and I can't tell any difference between them and the new ones.
Mine haven't seen the grinder yet....
Jeff Willaford
but I've only been using them for two years. Like Carole said.....hone....
You've done much better than me...
Doug Trembath
I was in too much of a hurry, and took them to the grinder whenever I needed a fresh edge. As a result, I need to replace some of them.
That said, however, I've turned a few hundred hollow vessels with them, so I feel I got full value for the initial cost, and don't regret the replacement cost. I have used HSS inserts as well, but I think the Keltons perform light years ahead of the other tools. With the larger cutting surfaces, I have achieved surfaces folks accuse me of sanding, right off the tool. I also think the tool geometry affords a lot more capability, with much less angst.
Of course, others may not agree, and I'm OK with that, as well...
Doug Trembath
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
Doug Trembath
Mine still have quite a bit of the original hardened steel left, but I'm finding it difficult to get into the places I need to get with the shortened tool. Whatever that steel that Kel put on the top is, it's the best cutting metal I've ever seen... Holds an edge like a dream!
Guess I'll also have to invest in a diamond hone...
Doug Trembath
Re: Thoughts on Kelton hollowing tools
robo hippy
A friend of mine traded at the local Woodcraft for some after giving lessons. He gave them to me to try them out. I ended up getting the entire set. Very efficient, and I love the 5/8 and smaller ones in my Monster system. I prefer to swap out bars rather than the articulated heads with HSS bits in them. They can get through smaller openings. I don't get a good finished surface with them, but that is what the carbide discs are for.
robo hippy
Another vote for John Jordan Tools
Stephen Mushinski
Both do the same job but with the inserts the tool is forever. If you plan of doing a fair bit of hollowing then the best bet in my mind would be John's. I do own both and cannot say anything bad about the kelton tools other then once they are ground down they are toast. With John's just put another tip in.
Re: Another vote for John Jordan Tools
Bill Blasic
I use the all the Kelton Hollowers in my Monster Articulated System and they work like a dream. The same can be said for the Jordan Hollowers. Also the new Kelton Collet handles are a perfect match for these tools.
Bill
Kelton hollowing gate
Jorge Casta�eda
Now that we are talking about the Kelton hollowers, reminds me I have the gate, but misplaced the saddles a couple years back, now fear they fell and were discarded with the shavings.
Any ideas were to get replacements?
Thanks
Jorge
Re: Another vote for John Jordan Tools
glenn roberts
It was while using Kelton hollowers freehand, that inspired the original concept for the ER collet handles and side handle. Lately I have been using The new Kelton hollowing rig that has a ER32 collet to hold the tools. It works great, as it only takes seconds to swap tools, with no allen keys, damaging shafts etc. And the ER collets are easy to buy and allows you to use 'other' diameter shaft tools. (1mm clamping range per collet)
I own 3 sizes and love them!
keith zimmerman, Normal IL
I also own the Kelton hollowing rig
keith zimmerman, Normal IL
Sigh....
GolfSteve in Calgary
I guess I can't blame my Kelton hollowers for the difficulties I have...sound like they are great tools.