Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Identification Help Please

Posts

Identification Help Please

#1

Identification Help Please

Dick Wilson

Well, this one has me stumped. A friend gave me a couple pieces of wood at our turning club meeting yesterday. He said he got it down south and the person he got it from said it was Holly. I have never turned Holly but this sure doesn't look like any Holly I have ever seen. I think of Holly as being a very light wood. The bark and the grain doesn't look like anything in Michigan. It is mottled, cream, brown, gray streaks, and spaulting. Thanks for your help.

Re: Identification Help Please

#2

Re: Identification Help Please

robo hippy

I am pretty sure it isn't holly. Looks kind of like oak with the little ray marks on the surface. Oak always has that 'oak' smell, almost like vinegar, and some of the red/black oak types have bark similar to that.

robo hippy

Re: Identification Help Please

#3

Keith Tompkins

Re: Identification Help Please

keith tompkins

I agree, either oak or beech, which are related. Was the bark on the trunk smooth, light gray?

Re: Identification Help Please

#4

Re: Identification Help Please

Dick Wilson

Smooth bark, kind of gray and white

Re: Identification Help Please

#5

Re: Identification Help Please

Ed Moore in SW VA

Dick,

The bark looks like holly and I have seen holly with a lot of gray streaking through it. However, the light brown instead of white or cream tone looks suspect. The grain looks closed, not open like oak would be.

Ed

Re: Identification Help Please

#6

Additional Info

Dick Wilson

I found out that he got the wood in Texas. Hopefully that will help. Also it is has a fairly closed grain like white oak. Feedback has been Birch, Beech, Red Alder, but definitely not Holly. Thanks for help

Re: Identification Help Please

#7

Re: Additional Info

Ed Heuslein

Looks like Bradford Pear to me. We have a lot of that in East Texas.

Re: Identification Help Please

#8

Re: Additional Info

Dick Wilson

Ed, I just got a call back from Rich and he said he cut it up in Port Arthur. He said it might be "Live Oak". Apparently has its leaves year around. ???? Oh well, it's gonna be purdy.

Re: Identification Help Please

#9

I say oak

Thad Parker

That's about all we have down here in GA. Either oaks, pines, or ornamentals here in the midstate. We've got alot of b. pear too, and that picture you have is unmistakably oak IMO...I've turned tons of it b/c it's everywhere here and free.

~ Thad

Re: Identification Help Please

#10

Re: Identification Help Please

jim miles - charlotte, N C|

I was going to say Willow Oak- but since you gave location I would agree with Live Oak

Robo is right- the smell test will tell you if it is Oak

Splits and cracks badly.

Jim

Re: Identification Help Please

#11

Rob Wallace

Re: Identification Help Please

Rob Wallace

Dick:

You've turned enough of the bark away to show the parenchymal rays from the tangential perspective - it does look like oak, at least superficially....although a close-up of a clean end grain cut would be more informative.

If it is an oak, you should be able to easily see a distinctly ring-porous structure in the the early and latewood cell sizes. In some groups of live oaks, the large pores (vessels) will have tyloses in them (if it is in sub-genus Quercus) - the tyloses are small barriers that seem to block the openings of the largest pores. If it has these then it almost certainly is an oak.

There are 'live oaks in several different sections of the widespread and variable genus Quercus, so it would likely take a bit more information and descriptions of the wood structure to be able to narrow it down further. If you are going to the AAW Symposium in St. Paul this summer, come to my demonstration on wood identification and bring a sample of the wood!

Rob Wallace

Re: Identification Help Please

#12

Re: Identification Help Please

Dick Wilson

Unfortunately I will not be there but thanks for the help

Re: Identification Help Please

#13

Re: Identification Help Please

DC Powers

I'm fairly certain it's either Water Oak or Willow Oak which are in the Red Oak sub grouping. There's no way to tell exactly by looking. It's very common in SE Texas.

The leaves stay on very late and fall of just before the new leaves. Not exactly on all year like live

oak.

Re: Identification Help Please

#14

Re: Identification Help Please

Dick Wilson

DC, Thanks for responding. A gentleman on WOW said it was Water Oak and that he has trees with exactly the same bark and grain in his yard. Thank you everyone for helping me out.

Re: Identification Help Please

#15

Re: Identification Help Please

Matt Birchfield

Does it smell like root beer (or more appropriately 'birch' beer)? Black birch has a VERY distinctive smell when worked green. I turn a lot of black birch, and when it's allowed to spalt, which doesn't take long after cutting, it looks just like the photo you posted.

Re: Identification Help Please

#16

Re: Identification Help Please

Dick Wilson

Matt, The piece didn't have much smell to it. It was pretty much dry when I got it. It originally came from Texas. I have had a couple of southern turners respond that it looks just like trees on their property..........Water Oak. I have it turned and sanded and it does look like Oak so that is my story and I am going to stick to it :D Thanks

Re: Identification Help Please

#17

Re: Identification Help Please

Matt Birchfield

Just trying to help... stick to what you're certain of.

For info only: Black birch is very tight-grained; during the depression it was used for toy wheels and womens' shoe heels. In West Virgina we also have something that is commonly called 'water birch' which would have been my second choice based upon your photo (bark is a little bit different, though very difficult to discern in a photo that doesn't show the whole log). Water birch has many of the same properties as black birch, but has almost no smell... if it does, it smells slightly rotten as compared to any oak. It always has VERY interesting and interlocked grains with rays and flecks similar to oak. It also has a high silicon content which dulls tools WAY quicker than oak does, it spalts in very regular patterns within days of harvest, per your photo.

In my OPINION, if your wood is any kind of oak you should be able to detect the distinctively 'oak' odor, wet or dry... if you don't smell oak, it isn't oak.