Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

High Quality Pen Kits

Posts

High Quality Pen Kits

#1

High Quality Pen Kits

Mark

I am looking for high quality pen kits. I spent top dollar for kits from Penn State, Craft Supplies, Rockler and Woodcraft but none seem to last very long.

I dropped one and the thing exploded. The ones from Penn State break when you're assembling them and forget about customer service.

I have a Parker Pen that I abuse on a regular basis and it's as smooth as the day I bought it.

All all pen kits the same or are there some that stand out as the best?

Thanks for your response.

Mark

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

Hi Mark,

Quality and price are not one in the same, I can think of many quality pens, but not all of those kits are expensive and also just the opposite can be true.

What kits have you tried and what have you experienced?

I have a few favorites that do well for me, but that will not always be the same for everyone when they use the term quality.

What are you looking for when you describe a pen as having high quality?

Take care,

Jim

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

#3

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

Barry Ward

I'm just starting to get into penturning,so I can't say much about who makes the best,but a few friends of mine that have been turning pens for yrs now,and are very good get most of there blanks from a place called wood-n-whimsies.I just recieved some cigar kits from them and and they nlook good for what thats worth.

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

#4

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

Mark

In quality I mean how reliable is the pen? I want smooth operation, quality parts and something that will last. I made a kit for my wife, dropped the pen, and I had to replace the cartridge for it to work. I've never had a pen last for more than a year before it's toast--and I don't mean just getting a new cartridge. Maybe it's bad luck, but pen kits seem to be very poorly made. For the price, they do not compare to a good Parker or Cross pen. I tried too many pens to list. If I were selling pens, I would never be able to offer any kind of a guarantee. Does this help?

Thanks

Mark

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

#5

Contact Barry Gross *LINK*

Craig Daymon

Barry is an AAW member, so if you are as well (recommend you join if you haven't) you can get his e-mail from the AAW directory, which I'm pretty sure is accessible from the site.

Barry wrote at least one book on pen turning and he sells his pens at some very high end pen shows. (At prices to match.) I believe he's turned pens for several presidents/vice presidents as well.

He also writes articles for Woodturning Design magazine, which might also include some contact information.

He may post here on occasion, but I can't say for certain.

Searched for him and found his site, then edited this post. The link is below. Barry sells kits on his site, but you might ask him first which would be best for you as I'm certain he sells to a broader customer base than just the high end.


Barry's website - VERY impressive pens

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

#6

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Some Thoughts

Jim in River Oaks, Ont.

I understand how you feel Mark,

For a long time I struggled with the functional performance of some kits, many had limitations and also the plating durability was a factor.

About 8-10 years ago I would try a new pen, make it and give it to someone I knew, once in a while I would ask how it was working or see how it looked, that helped me understand how people use them or even store pens. A few things stood out for me, quality mechanisms are worth the extra money if they are available. I also buy higher end ink cartridges and replace those included with kit. Upgraded platings are not all upgraded, so buying from certain suppliers allows trust to proven finishes and designs.

I sell my work primarily through a gallery now, the presentation of my work is important. Many of the gallery clients are not squeamish about spending $500 plus on a pen so I make my work so that it suits their expectations. Several things I have learnt from my clients is that many want a well balanced pen, finish is critical, choice of material (uniqueness), quality of the function is also very important. Doctors, lawyers, business people etc, they all want something that is unique and one of a kind, quality to them is in part meeting those expectations.

The pens that work for me, might not be what you consider quality, the newer PSI Broadwell designs are at the top of my list. Lotus and Imperials do well for those who like large pens, Cambridge pens are excellent for lighter weight medium pens.

I too am frustrated with the limitations of some kits, I really would like to see an upgraded 7 mm slim pen, I know if there were a few slim designs with some very good quality accents in this size on a pen and pencil I would be able to address a segment of my clients that I can't right now... any one listening?

If you are looking for a great group of pen makers check out the forums at IAP and Pen Turners Paradise, those are easily my favorite forums to participate with.

Take care,

Jim

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

#7

Re: Some Thoughts

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Why not check out threads over at IAP? This subject comes up all the time. I have pens made five years ago still going strong with exception of changing out refills.

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

#8

Re: High Quality Pen Kits

Bernie Weishapl

I have made pens from PSI, Arizona Silhouette, Bear Tooth, Berea, CSUSA, etc and have never had many problems at all. The wife and I still have the first slimlines I made 6 yrs ago. They have been used and abused and still writing. I think in 5 yrs of doing pens probably around 250 or more I can honestly say I have only had 3 come back that were broke because of a kit malfunction other than the usual change of writing cartridge.