Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Jamie's wood stinks....

Posts

Jamie's wood stinks....

#1

Mike Stafford

Jamie's wood stinks....

Mike Stafford

Now, I am not one to say anything bad about a piece of wood that is sent to me for free. But if Jamie Donaldson sends you a piece of wood with a note that says something like, "I found this piece of wood in my shop and I am not sure what it is but I thought you might be able to use it. It has a funny smell" I would be very careful when you turn it.

I put this box sized blank of stink wood, er, I mean, unknown wood between centers and started to round it up. Almost immediately I noticed a foul odor so bad I thought my Depends had sprung a leak and I don't even wear Depends..... As I continued to round it up and form tenons on each end the stench became so bad I had to leave the shop. I decided to don hazardous waste clothing and went back into the shop, removed the offending timber and gave it a burial befitting a 3 week old road killed skunk. :D

Jamie, tell the truth, that wood was harvested from an old barn that must have stabled horses for 50 or 100 years and came from the bottom of a post that had wicked up all the waste products from countless horses.

I am adding a can of Lysol to my list of supplies for the shop.... ;)

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#2

It's against my phrugal nature to......

JamieDonaldson

...discard any beautiful chunk of wood, but this sample is the exception. Neighbor that gave it to me said it was a skid on a pallet of mahogany, so I don't know the source beyond that. It may have come from a barnyard somewhere, but you must admit it looks perfect for end grain box production, and I gave up on it's potential with the first cut on the bandsaw! :b Is anyone else game for a free sample? :D

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#3

Re: It's against my phrugal nature to......

Jim Rutten

I've had my sense of smell surgically removed (not my choice) so it wouldn't bother me one bit. LOL. :b

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#4

5'll gitcha 7.50

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

It was from the cottonwood family. Used a lot for horse stalls because they won't "crib" it because of the smell and taste.

Didn't know better when I glommed a big bolt. Started turning it and SWMBO came pounding down the stairs to announce a) that either she or the wood was leaving inside of the next 10 minutes (my choice), and b) both I and what I was wearing would be cleaned "off premises". Since I had recently put in a new mater bath and gotten a new laundry pair, I got first-hand knowledge of just how cold the water from our well can be.

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#5

Dick Hines

Re: 5'll gitcha 7.50

Dick Hines

Mike you must be looking this gift horse from the wrong end. :b

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#6

There is a fungus called "Wetwood"

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Which can occur in almost any species that causes it to stink, and it doesn't ever go away. I takes a lot longer to dry, is more prone to check. You might be able to finish it to cover it for a while, but a warm humid day brings the smell back.

Last year the husband of an artist friend gave me a walnut log infected with it. It ended up getting burned.

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#7

Re: 5'll gitcha 7.50

Barbara Gill

That is so funny. Cottonwood reminds me of my riding days. To me it smells like the tack room. In fact I really don't find horse or cow manure that objectionable. Now pig poop is another story!

I think Red Oak smells sort of sour. I like the smell of walnut but once had a customer who couldn't stand it.

Ailanthus has to be the worst smelling wood when it is green.

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#8

Re: There is a fungus called "Wetwood"

Barbara Gill

I bet that is what was going on with some Magnolia I once had. The center was almost black and the smell was not pleasant.

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#9

And I held Jamie with such high regard hmmmmm!

Stephen Mushinski

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#10

Ever try Macadamia? Whew!

Doug Trembath

Re: Jamie's wood stinks....

#11

what Barb said

Dave Peebles Lyons, Ohio

I totally agree with Barb, horses and cows are fine.. but hogs are a bad scene.

Also Mark, it must be where your cottonwood comes from. My Ohio stuff was used for my stables and my Morgan horses loved it. It may be the Hoffa affect in N.J. :)

Best wishes,

Dave