Hello, I am new to wood turning. I've been wood working for ~8 yrs so I've become aware of the dangers with traditional tools and will feel comfortable teaching my girls when they're old enought to tackle a saw. However, I don't know what I don't know about wood turning. Can anybody tell me what the worst case scenarios are for turning that I should teach my girls and myself to avoid? Is there a good wood turning safety reference somebody can point me towards? I've heard people say that turning is relatively safe, but I don't want to take any chances with those precious little fingers and hands.
Re: Turning safety - worst case scenarios??? *LINK*
GaryG in MD
Bill,
Sounds like your girls are in good hands.
At the following link, you can see the AAW list, plus a number of links to short articles.
The main thing is for them to keep their hands on the right side of the tool rest. When I first started turning, I didn't once. Luckily, no harm done, but I still cringe to think about it.
The way I see it there are three dangers in woodturning.
The most exciting danger come from bits of wood or tool smashing into you. This is a very serious danger in that a spinning hunk of wood can KILL you!!! It isn't just fingers that are in danger. Wear face and eye protection and learn to turn with your soft parts out of the line of fire.
Wood allergies. We turn exotic woods and sand to very high grits. Our bodies can be overcome if we are exposed to a lot of wood dust. When working with exotics limit your exposure to short predictable times, wash up which may include a shower as soon as you finish working with an exotic. The longer the exotic dust stays in contact with your skin the greater your exposure.
The biggest danger is to your lungs. Wood dust slowly kills your lungs. If you are careful this exposure can be safely tolerated for many decades. If you are not careful you can notice bad effects in less than a year. We sand wood turnings on the lathe and as a result we sand across the grain. To eliminate sanding scratches we sand to very high grits. You might sand to no more than 220 non-woodturning items. You might sand to 2000 on wood turnings (though 400 is a more usual high grit). Sanding to high grits generates very fine sanding dust. Our bodies can repel or expel larger sanding dust and larger particles precipitate out of the air much more quickly than very fine sanding dust (which can remain in the air for many hours). Good fitting respirators are a must. Collecting sanding dust at the source, a very common practice with most modern power woodworking tools, is very difficult at the lathe.
Woodturning is VERY addictive. You completes project from log to eating out of a bowl can be done in an hour or two. Where you may spend more than an hour or two just planing a book case. The instant gratification off woodturnng will find you spending a LOT of time in the shop. You will find yourself dreaming about woodturning when you can't be at the lathe. You will find ways to spend money on woodturning that you never knew you had.
Read the links posted above. In addition, from personal experience I would add or reinforce a few things.
Turn sound pieces of wood. Look out for cracks and checks and any other defects. I know of a man who tried to turn a piece of wood with a split in it. He turned it to a sort of long vase shape and then turned up the speed. A side flew off remaining attached at one end and hit him on the head.
I personally mounted a piece of wood and apparently did not have it secure enough and it flew off and hit me on the forehead, cutting me, requiring 27 stitches. A face shield would have prevent the injury. (Mounting the wood better would have prevented it flying away altogether.) I was tired and was doing repetitive things and on this occasion I turn the lathe on before putting the shield on. So there are at least three lessons here. Don't work tired. Mount the work securely. Put the face shield on first. And a fourth is to start with the lathe set allow speed. Mine was set way too fast.
Keep your hands behind the tool rest.
And keep your hand on top of the handle. Another fellow I know walked up to a piece and with his right hand under the handle reached out and touched the work piece. Got a terrible catch and the handle hit him under the jaw.
I often rough with a glove on my left hand. (This will ignite a safety argument in itself.) Many think it is and unsafe practice. I was turning a bowl out of Bradford Pear, a wood that will take wonderful detail. I reached out and put my hand on it to stop it. The rime was as sharp as a knife and sliced through the glove. I should post a picture. It would have been a horrible gash but because of the glove I only got a paper cut. OYOH without the glove I might not have touched the spinning piece at all. So, did the glove reduce the injury or cause it? The lesson is, don't touch the spinning work. (Most of us do and usually get away with it, but sometimes we get a reminder.)
I have made this hobby sound like a little chamber of horrors. Actually it is creative and fun and generally safe. Just listen to that little inner safety voice. Don't do anything that starts with Here girls, hold Dad's beer.
1.) being struck by a defective piece of wood (minor pain, caused by standing in the line of fire)
2.) being struck by poorly mounted wood (minor pain only because of the faceshield I was wearing and still standing in the line of fire)
3.) woodchip in the eye (no shield, no glasses)
4.) CA glue in the eye (no shield, no glasses)
5.) Cut with a skew:
a.) from coming off the end of the toolrest
b.) carelessly reaching for tools in the rack
c.) underhand grip, catch, and hit in the face with the point (not me)
6.) Cut by a sharp rim on the bowl (and using it like a handwheel)
7.) Severe allergic reaction to cocobolo (2 days of swelling)
8.) Minor burn from grinder sparks setting my glove on fire
In short, nothing major but lots and lots of ways that you can ruin your afternoon. If it was up to me, I wouldn't introduce my children to the lathe unless I was an expert teacher and I'd begin with safety.
A lathe looks very safe compared to the spinning tablesaw blade that often are not properly guarded. But it isn't that simple.
Some people think this is over the top, I don't think it is and personally know a couple of turners who have awakened on the floor beside their lathe after a whack on the head:
Most shop power tools can maim you, a lathe can kill you. This is because a large spinning blank that comes free or breaks apart can give you a very severe hit on the head.
Use the tailstock wherever possible. Spindle turning tends to be at much lower risk for flying workpieces since it is supported at both ends and the wood usually is sound. This is not the case with bowl turning.
Never turn the lathe on unless you have face protection.
The lathe, like a tablesaw, also has a "line of fire' where a loose piece is likely to go. Also like the tablesaw it is in the area where the operator may be standing. If possible, try not to stand right in front of the spinning bowl blank.
Always use a respirator ot at least a good N95 or better dust mask while doing any turning, not just the sanding stage. The younger a person starts breathing dust the longer time there is for nasty lung issues to evolve. Also, handle finishes carefully since they can be hazardous especially with long exposures.
Turning tools are sharp and should be treated the same as you would a sharp kitchen knife.
Thank you for all of the great responses. The links provided contained a lot of good information and I especially appreciate the real life examples everybody provided.
I have one question. Many people wrote about avoiding the line of fire. Is this mainly for turning bowls? I can't figure out how to avoid this area when turning cylinderical objects such as pens. I assume this would the the area in front of the lathe and from one end of the piece to the other.
It will largely depend upon your stance when you cut, but you can minimize your exposure to the LOF with the proper stance. It can't be avoided with long spindles like handles and balusters.
What I do is I always cut in shear, which puts the tool at 45 degrees and me behind the steel. Since i am cutting in sheer, everything comes off almost perpendicular and down, minimizing my chances to being hit by cut wood. It also directs the force towards the headstock or tailstock, which keeps the wood from flexing out of the tailstock point or spur moreso than if the cut was perpendicular.
Hard to explain, but it's easy to understand. I just don't stand where I'm throwing wood.
Your question is actually a very timely one for me, because, in MCW, we have decided that it is a good idea to have a short Safety "tip" at each meeting. We're going to have it right before the demo, so, as Program Chair, I get to do it. With my old list, and some of these additional items, I'll be good to go for years!
Club Members: This is something you all can recommend for your own clubs. Just 2-3 minutes is all that's needed, and it will be well worth the time. You'll never know about the accidents you will have averted, but rest assured, they will have happened in that other universe where you didn't do it.
You asked for the worst case - well it is death. Yes there are many confirmed deaths from working on a wood lathe. One just last year in Ontario, Canada.
Tool broke and the wood hit the turner in the head was what we were told. Wood flying off the lathe hitting the turner is more common than most wish to admit.
Some turning tools are only meant for certain functions such as the roughing gouge is for spindle turning not for bowls. A lesson or two from someone you know might be the best time spent.