VOD 300
Mark J. Thill
Dose anyone have a Vicmarc VOD 300 and how well dose it work ? Is it worth the money that they want for it
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
VOD 300
Mark J. Thill
Dose anyone have a Vicmarc VOD 300 and how well dose it work ? Is it worth the money that they want for it
Re: VOD 300
Richard Allen
The device works exactly as it is supposed to work.
If you want to make oval (elliptical) objects then this device will open that possibility for you.
You can make a range of oval shapes from round to a 4" difference between width and length. Actually the difference us also a function of size as the difference can be more than 4" on a larger piece.
You can make platters, bowls, trays, hollow forms, boxes. There is no tailstock support possible, there is no steady rest support possible (you could provide single wheel support on the outside for hollowing a bowl or a hollow form).
The actual process of cutting (or scraping) wood can ONLY be done along the center line. Go above the center line and you will tear-up the turning. Go below the centerline and you will tear-up the turning. The ONLY place where you can cut is along the centerline. This more extreme the oval (the greater the difference between the width and the length) and the more critical this becomes. You may think that you can do this with a hand held tool. This is almost certainly NOT the case. You can make some small cut free hand where you are certain that the cutting point will maintain it's position on the centerline.
You will NOT be able to use a bowl gouge to turn an oval bowl!
You will NOT be able to use a bowl gouge to turn an oval bowl!
You will NOT be able to use a bowl gouge to turn an oval bowl!
Using a captive hollowing rig is about the ONLY method you can use to turn oval shapes successfully. Some folks have tried using a laser to identify the center line so that they have a aiming point for their tool. Your best chance of being successful using hand held cutting tools is with an oval that is less 10% difference between the width and the length. This is because the range where successful cut can be made is as much as 3/8".
If you want to add oval turnings to your turning accomplishments then this device will let you do that.
Turning an oval object with this device requires some effort and planning to be successful. The turning process is slower than turning a bowl. The additional time is the result of setup, learning curve and scraping.
With diligent practice you may be able to compress the time and effort it takes to make oval objects.
The device requires several adjustments to change oval ratios. The device reduces the spindle speed by 1/2.
Practical lathe requirements are for a substantial lathe. The device will not work on a lightweight or low powered lathe. I would not use the device with a Nova lathe. The device should work fine on a Powermatic.
There are a lot of moving parts in the device and the possibility of wear or parts failure is very real.
If you are in the Washington DC area or find yourself visiting the Washington DC area you are welcome to stop by the shop for a few hours to turn something oval.
Re: VOD 300
Walt Bennett
I've had a VOD for over four years and although I've mostly used it to make hat blocks (several hundred), I've also made six or so bowls - the hat blocks sell, the bowls don't for where I've got to price them. Although I agree with a lot of what you've written, I've got a few exceptions.
I use the center line and lightline that Johannes Volmer recommends in his .pdf on oval turning, NOT a captive rig (http://www.volmer---ovaldrehen.de/englisch.htm). When making hat blocks (spindle turning), its easy to just keep level with the VOD case's seam, but a lightline is most needed for bowls. Both Johannes and I agree that laser lights are too bright, and I use an old slide projector with a slide that projects a black line like he does.
I've also found that while I can use just about any type of tool, I mostly use bowl gouges for both spindle oval and bowl oval turning as they leave the smoothest finish. There's no way to 'ride the bevel' while oval turning, but one can come close and that helps.
One thing I've found is that trying to keep the weights really close to correct is almost impossible - you're continually removing wood as you turn which changes the settings. Now I just adjust them when it's needed (my Stubby starts vibrating!). One thing to note is that Johannes believes the charts Vicmarc provides are incorrect for the VOD. I've not been able to prove this one way or not, but he's the mechanical engineer that invented the mechanism.
The device was designed for lathes with a MINIMUM swing of 16". I put riser blocks under my headstock to gain a bit more, but I've demonstrated the VOD on 16" swing lathes several times.
Vicmarc over-engineers everything they make and the VOD is no exception - I've used and abused mine all this time and it's never seemed to notice. I also live in the DC metro area (west of Manassas a bit), and can show you what I mean if you're interested.
Re: VOD 300
Ralph Lindberg
Mark
I've had mine for about 1-1/2 years now and still learning. I don't use a captive tool either, I only use scrapers. But I have built a special tool rest, that is really just a piece of flat-stock. This helps make holding the scraper right, easier. I also use a laser level. But I bought a self leveling one, What I found from that is it bounces when I first start the lathe up, and I have to wait until that dies down
I know from talking to both Walt and Alan Lacer that they both use gouges, but I think this is just too tricky for me, and, for now, I will stay with a scraper. If I recall my conversation with Dale Larson (Portland OR) correctly he uses both scrapers and gouges.
If you do get one, and have a catch. Stop turning and ensure that you can still take your turning off the VOD and the VOD off the lathe. I can tell you for a fact, that getting the Lathe/VOD/Object all jammed together is a formula for problems. You might also try one of those UHM Washers (Nylon).
Lastly, if you want to get your feet wet, with less money, get David Springetts book and or DVD on Eliptical Turning and make his jig. It will only make small, light objects. But it does work