Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Posts

Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#1

Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Jorge Casta�eda

I am working in a quite unbalanced piece and there is a thump. thump that does not go away, it is not touching the tool rest at any point and turning it by hand does not make a sound, started turning at 60 rpm and by now is at 220, would love to be able to ramp it up to 500, because there is an area where 95% of a revolution is air, but around 300 vibrates bad enough so I back of.

So far the only thing I tried is loosening and tightening the belt, neither one got rid of the thump, thump.


Any suggestions will be appreciated.

I really don't know what wood is it, is a blank I inherited from a turner that went to greener pastures, it was all encased in wax and looks like maple, extremely hard and has a very bitter smell, just like Quassia, (Picrasma excelsa) , a very yellow wood that my grand mother made us drink when we got an upset stomach; but the quassia tree is a small tree and the wood very yellow, this looks like the cap of a large ball, but it is not burl.

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#2

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Malcolm Ray

Hi Jorge....Don't know about the "thump",but the wood looks a bit like yellow birch to me...sometimes it has a sour smell if it sits around a while..........

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#3

Leo Cuellar

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Leo Cuellar

Jorge, never used that model, but a couple of thoughts come to mind.

The blank may be developing a crack that could be causing the noise/vibration.

If your lathe isn't bolted down, you may need to check to see if it is still level & possibly add more weight to compensate for the out of balance piece. If you have it on a face plate, you might be able to add it there opposite the heavy side, such as get some longer screws and add some metal on the backside of the faceplate. Instead of having to weigh down the whole lathe. Just be sure to take the standard safety precautions when spinning it up, not in the flight path, etc.

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#4

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Ed Moore in SW VA

Jorge,

There is a frequent question about noises on a PM 3520. Often, if you tighten the set screws on the pulleys the noise goes away. Someone warned that there may be a double screw so that both the inner and outer screw must be tightened.

Good luck,

Ed

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#5

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Galen Vetterick

This may be a stupid question but I see a tool rest laying on the bed so due to the unbalance is it thumping on the bed?

Whenever I get a noise it usually means I've laid something down on the lathe or shelf below that is vibrating as I turn.

Had the tailstock fall off the lower shelf onto the bridge of my foot. Needless to say I modified the design for storing it below the lathe!

Only a Jet 1220 but it still hurt and made me feel a little stupid for the way I made the stand for it.

Looks like a very good turned piece in the making.

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#6

Keith Tompkins

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

keith tompkins

Hi Jorge and Mac....yeah, probably yellow birch. I've turned yb burl;one of the nastiest woods I ever turned. It was kiln-dried; my gouge got so hot turning it, it gave me blisters.

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#7

Thanks Ed!!

Jorge Casta�eda

Your advice was right on, I listened with a dowel from the back of my ear to the headstock and sure enough it was somewhere inside there, so I loosened the pulley set screw and yes, there was a second one underneath, tightened that and tightened the second one.

The noise went away. I should pay attention when there are discussions of noises...

Thanks anew

Jorge

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#8

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi Ray,

I never thought of yellow birch, because around here the biggest one I've seen was only 14" across, the long and the short of this is 23" and 19".

It smells different from the yellow birch I turned before, sometimes like root beer, sometimes sour as you said, but this is bitter, very bitter, makes me salivate.

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#9

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Jorge Casta�eda

Leo,

The lathe is not bolted down, this is a provisional home for it until I build a proper shop.

I will try adding more ballast and yes, it is mounted on a glue blodk in a face plate, I will scrounge some metal and try your method.

Thanks!

Jorge

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#10

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Jorge Casta�eda

Galen,

Ouch, that must hurt a lot, fortunately the PM has a stop screw to prevent that.

There are no stupid questions...The problem was the set screws, I did follow Ed's advice and the thump went away.

Thank you!

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#11

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

Jorge Casta�eda

Hi Keith,

That must have been a huge tree then if this is yellow birch, but it is really hard, the other wood as hard I ever turned was birds eye sugar maple, that was a job!, spent as much time sharpening as turning.

Thanks

Jorge

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#12

Leo Cuellar

Glad it was a simple fix!

Leo Cuellar

Re: Thmp, thomp in 3520b

#13

Re: Thanks Ed!!

Mike Rubes, Apex, NC

Jorge,

Glad your lathe is running smooth and trouble free again! I would like to see a picture of that piece when you finish it. So far, it looks great!

I hope you are getting some signs of Spring up there, it is a warm 69F and sunny here today! :)

Mike

Perfect turning weather in Apex, NC!