Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

Posts

Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#1

Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

I was not aware of these little tips being available. Back when I made my hollowing tools, I was wishing for something like this, but that was a long time ago.

I was wondering, not only how much faster, not counting sharpening time you can cut. But if you have any idea about how the chips come off the tip. I would imagine that the chip breaker groove would cause the chip to shoot up at a higher angle than a typical scraper tip. What say yee?


http://www.hunterwoodturningtool.com/products/retrofit/

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#2

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits?

Mike Foster

I've got one. Used it some but wasn't terribly impressed with the advantage over regular bits. I love the regular Hunter's for hollowing and use them all the time. If I'm resorting to the boring bar pretty much any tip will do the job.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#3

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits?

Lyle Jamieson

Keith, I use the hunter tools almost all the time for hollowing. It is faster, easier, leaves a better surface behind on the wood, and you never have to sharpen. Down side is there is a small learning curve to understand how and why it works so easy. The slicing action peels off a shaving instead of sawdust accross the end grain that comes from the scraping HSS tools. I think the swivel tip assembly cutting tip is almost manditory to get the full benefits from the Hunter tools.

Look at my web site (www.lylejamieson.com) in the teaching section and look at the article I wrote about the carbide cutter. There are three cuts that can be done with it and rules, things to do, and things not to do, with it. That will help clear up the use questions.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#4

Made My Own

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

Used 1/2" rod with a 3/8" tang cut on one end to put onto the boring bar and a milled step on the other to take the #4 cutter. Doesn't show here, but there are two small pieces of lead foil under each cutter to eliminate any imperfect surface match between the holder and the cutter that might generate vibration and possibly crack the carbide cutter.

This is straight:


This is bent for side work, shown mounted in 3/4" boring bar:


The holders are all milled straight and the bent arm is then heat-bent to hold the cutter at about a 30� angle to the surface. The round tang allows me to rotate the cutter to find the optimum angle for the cut.

I use mine with a pull cut for the finish inside hollowforms. They leave a very nice surface. The bent holder cuts so well on the transition and side walls that I have to be very careful to take very controlled light cuts.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#5

I have an early version of.....

JamieDonaldson

...the Hunter 3/16" square tool that Mike had me test, and it fits right into my old Oland tool holder. That 1/4" cutter can be very aggressive, and a trick to master if you're used to using the original scraper cutters, but it works very well and leaves a nice smooth surface. Pull cuts only! :b

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#6

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits?

Bill Turpin in WNC mountains

We have a #1 square Hunter bit inserted into a Don Derry hand held hollower. It works very well. Wife hollowed ~50 red maple, 2" diameter, end-grain bell Christmas ornaments before rotating the cutter for the first time. Insert hole in tool is at about 45�, which works well with no catches.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#7

Thanks Lyle.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

That was helpful, but I'm not sure it helped with what I was wanting to know. I don't know how many years ago now, I made my hollowing tools from square tube, which transitions into larger round tube, with a vacuum on the other end, sucking the shavings out while they come off the cutting tip.

There are so many dynamics involved in that small space inside a turning, even without adding trying to capture the shaving up a vacuum tube, that I think of it somewhat like walking a tightrope blindfolded. But of course getting the vacuum to work even adds a few more elements.

Having too much tip sticking out beyond the opening is obviously one. Which leads to the main reason for the question. If the chip breaker, which I think is what the metal workers call the groove, causes the chip / ribbon to deflect at too high and angle, rather than more down the shaft, this may keep the vacuum from drawing it in. Then of course, having to shorten the length of extension, starts limiting the range of motion before other tool parts start to bump, keeping me from cutting where I want to go.

I hate to admit, that as long as I have been turning, I have never made it to any of these turning get-togethers that I read about on the forums. So I am sure there is a lot that I could learn, but then, stumbling along my own path, I may have learned a few things worth sharing too.

I guess I ought to get out in the shop, set up the camera on a tripod on timed delay, then take a few shots under a fairly controlled situation just to see what I can learn.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#8

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits?

Steve Worcester

While I haven't yet used the retrofit, i am a Hunter tool addict. I have done several hollowing with his carbide tools.

So let me add this...

If the bit is angled, it only cuts in the direction the angle is facing, whether that be push or pull. Lyle's article is spot on, but I would add this, the cutters cut so efficiently you will have to clear the shavings in half the time you normally would. Clear early and often. The cutter can be self feeding and contrary to how cabide is used in metal turning, instead slow down the speed to avoid the feeding getting out of control.

I use his tools in a captive system and with the vessels I make, you have to have more purpose built tools. Like a hook shape for the undercuts with the cutter facing back. If the openings were bigger Lyle's version would work wonderful.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#9

Thanks Steve for your input.

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

Since I last posted, I have spoken to Mike Hunter on the phone. He will be giving a demo for the turning club in Hot Springs AR this Saturday, and is already down there. I was hoping that he might bring a tip like what I might could use, but he said he can't carry all his inventory everywhere.

It sounds like he has really developed a great product, but if I get one, it will likely mean that I have to re-design another tool just for it, because of what you just stated. It is not so much the turning time, as the clean out time, when working through small openings.

I'm starting to wonder if turning with a standard scraping tip. taking smaller shavings, but not having to turn off to clean out is more time consuming than cutting faster, but having to stop more often to clean out.

I was just wondering how long some of you take to hollow a sphere, say in the range of a cubic gallon, 231" , or 7 5/8" diameter, through a hole say 1.75". Ha ha, Well, we all know, its not how fast you can hollow that much wood. It is how you end up as thin as you would like without blowing out.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#10

Nice,

Keith Newton----Little Rock, Arkansas

OK, so you are apparently riding the bevel, cutting back toward the top?

When you are working through a small opening, do you drill down so far, then start working your way from the middle back toward the top?

I drill down, but then always like to start by thinning the edge from the opening on then carrying it on back. I used to have problems of things getting out of round and deforming, causing a grab, when I tried to come back up to far on the inside of thin walls.

Let me ask. If you were turning an ovoid, or egg with the fat end out. Would you start by drilling in so far, then opening a hollow, that you then expanded, then worked your way toward a small opening?

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#11

Direction

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

OK, so you are apparently riding the bevel, cutting back toward the top?

Wouldn't put it that way because the cut is basically a shear slicing cut.

When you are working through a small opening, do you drill down so far, then start working your way from the middle back toward the top?

I do drill, but no, I will not go that deep to start hollowing. Depending on the form, I'll go a distance in then cut to the outside and back toward the opening when the Hunters are mounted; they will not cut with a push stroke when the cutter is set at an angle to the axis. I tried the straight holder with the cutter rotated up level to finish a bottom; it wasn't pretty. :(

I drill down, but then always like to start by thinning the edge from the opening on then carrying it on back. I used to have problems of things getting out of round and deforming, causing a grab, when I tried to come back up to far on the inside of thin walls.

Since I use a Kobra, I try to establish a wall thickness as I work down to the bottom. I then use the Hunters to clean up the inside ridges and bumps in light pull cuts that start at the bottom and move all the way to the top (opening end) of the vessel in a single pass. I do the same thing with deep bowls. I will most always cut to about a 1/4" thickness on hollowforms so as to prevent most of the flexing that you'd get with very thin walls. I don't lust for translucently thin walls, but can see where that might get to be an issue without some outside pressure to hold the diameter uniform, especially if you don't have a bevel to leverage and control your cut.

Let me ask. If you were turning an ovoid, or egg with the fat end out. Would you start by drilling in so far, then opening a hollow, that you then expanded, then worked your way toward a small opening?

Not sure I understand you, but to do an egg shape, I'd usually put the "heavy end" towards the headstock and hollow from the "small" end. If however, I wanted the egg to sit on the opening, I'd be hollowing from the heavy end.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#12

Jim Evans

Re: Thanks Steve for your input.

Jim Evans

I think it's going to be a real interesting demo tomorrow. I'm most curious as to what the difference is between the Hunter & Easy carbide bits.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#13

Re: Thanks Steve for your input.

john lucas

Keith It's a Wash on the shavings. You are removing the same amount of wood so you either cut faster and remove X amount of wood more often, or you cut slower and remove X amount of wood less often. Somehow you still have to get X amount of wood out so it really doesn't matter.

One of the advantages of the Hunter tool vs the eliminator is that it's easy to rotate the tool to a new angle. You can "back cut" with a hunter if you rotate it so it's flatter to the wood. This makes it a shear scraper instead of a cutting tool. It still cuts pretty clean this way but not as clean as when used in the cutting action.

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#14

Lyle Jamieson

Re: Thanks Steve for your input.

Lyle Jamieson

"I'm starting to wonder if turning with a standard scraping tip. taking smaller shavings, but not having to turn off to clean out is more time consuming than cutting faster, but having to stop more often to clean out." I have seen many people try a vacuum shaving removal system and all have abandonded it. It will not work very well and you have one hand tied behind your back trying to get it to work. One of the obsticles is the shavings fly to the largest diameter of the inside wall from centrifugal force. You have the answer yourself in the above quote.

With that said if you still want to continue to struggle with the vacuum tube, the shavings from a properly used Hunter carbide tool will fly back toward the tailstock. Sometimes they fly right out the entry hole for me.

With the Hunter tool I hollow a gallon size vessel in less then an hour to a 1/8 or 3/16 wall thickness. Most of that speed is due to the laser but the hunter tool takes about a third of the time to hollow then the HSS scraping cutter.

Work the inside wall thickness from the mouth opening down in small stages. Get the first stage done, cleaned up, no tool marks, before you go the second stage and dont go back to the first stage again. Dont go back!!

Re: Anyone using the Hunter Retrofit bits? *LINK*

#15

Speed Kills

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In Jersey

As usual. :D

That said, it takes me, m-o-l, 1-1/2 hours, start to finish, to hollow an 8"x8" volume of good wet wood. More time if I'm working dry, and way, way more time if I start finding "alternate" materials.

BTW carbide cutters really don't like finding steel in the wood; they tend to break. DAMHIKT :(