Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

sharpening method?

Posts

sharpening method?

#1

sharpening method?

GaryG in MD

For finishing cuts on the outside and inside of bowls, many of the pros I've seen in demos use a bowl gouge with an old-fashioned straight end on it (not fingernail). I believe Trent Bosch has one cut asymetrically -- the left side for outside and the right side cut back a little more for inside. How are these gouges ground? Are they done like a SRG with the end of the handle in the cup, or by hand only, or with some kind of special setting on a VeriGrind? How much are the corners removed, if at all. Seems to me they were still on there, but now that sounds dangerous to me. I bought a gouge to grind that way, but it's been a long time since I've seen one, and I'm not sure how to get started. Thanks, Gary

Re: sharpening method?

#2

Re: sharpening method?

john lucas

Gary I sharpened mine (when I used that grind) using the V arm in the Oneway system. What I do is to stop rotating it as I get to the wings. Then it's just a sliding sideways sort of motion. If you think of it as a U I lay the U down on it side on the wheel, slide it back and forth to grind this area. Then I rotate it to sharpen the bottom of the U. When I get to the other side of the U I stop rotating and slide it back and forth. This is also how I sharpen my Spindle roughing gouge.

You can rotate it a little if you want a slightly swept back grind. Another way of doing this, which is how I sharpen the Stewart Batty Grind is to use the flat tool rest. Put a mark at 40 degrees in both directions. Set the tool rest so it's 40 degrees to the stone. Now the movement is similar to what I put down above except you start with the U laying on it's side and the tool shaft parallel to one the 40 degree lines.

Let's say you pick the left line to start. The flute will be pointing to the right. Start your grind here and move the tool toward the center while at the same time rotating the flute up. When you get to the center of the tool rest the flute should be straight up. Continue in the same direction until you get swing the tool to the right hand line. At this point the flute should be pointing left. I have trouble doing this in one continuous movement so I start left and go to the middle and then start right and go the middle.

There is a point about 5 oclock and 7 oclock where it's way to easy to over sharpen and you end up with a dip, then you have a beak like nose. Not good. You have to learn to light up the pressure against the stone, or simply rotate faster through this section in order to get a smooth arc going the whole way around.

Your fears about the upper edge are well founded but in you can get a catch even without the corners. The problem with this type of cut is finess. You find the bevel with the flute up and then you rotate the handle ever so slightly until it starts to cut. Too much and you can get a catch. It only takes a hair to make a difference. With the Stewart batty grind you "wings" if you want to call it that, are ground back a little so you are approaching the wood at a slight angle. This makes it more forgiving. Another advantage of his grind is the tool edge is 40 degrees not matter where you are on the blade. This means if you rotate the tool to change the angle of cut you always have the same bevel angle so you don't need to move the handle to find out the new tool angle.

Re: sharpening method?

#3

Re: sharpening method? *LINK*

Greg Haugen

Gary,

Here are a couple of resources. One is the YouTube video of Mike sharpening his gouges. The first half of the video he sharpens the swept back grind, approx. 5:51 in the video he talks briefly about the grind and the motion used to sharpen it. He also talks about its shape.

http://www.youtube.com/user/Bowlmaker10#p/a/u/2/4m8-8MNhpvY

The other is a link Craft Supplies site that has a nice picture of this gouge about half on the page.

This grind is my preferred method for the interior of bowls. I do have a "relieved" or a double bevel on the grind so there's minimal "rub" on the wood from the gouge's bevel heel and it's also easy to change the angle. The shape of the grind is what I use, but my "angle" varies. For an open bowl, 40-50 degrees is fine. But for a closed form, round bottom bowl (aka calabash) I change this angle depending on where I am in the bowl. On a deep, narrow bowl I may finish the very bottom with close to a 60-70 degree angle. The angle depends on the bowl shape and the presentation of the gouge to the wood. Shallow, open bowls provide a lot of room to angle the gouge, the more closed the form or deeper the bowl form is, the less the gouge can be moved so the angle on the tip changes.

I sharpen this grind on the flat platform, and as seen in the picture from CS-USA, the wings are ever so slightly back just to give a little clearance.


Mahoney's Bottom Feeder

Re: sharpening method?

#4

Re: sharpening method?

Doug Trembath

John, that was an excellent description! Clear, concise, well written, and easy too follow.

Well done!

Doug Trembath

Re: sharpening method?

#5

Thanks Greg

GaryG in MD

That's very useful. I'd love to get him as a demonstrator some time... Gotta work on that. ...Gary

Re: sharpening method?

#6

Thanks John...  more questions (long)

GaryG in MD

I appreciate you taking the time to write that. Excellent description, as Doug says. But I'm afraid it brings many more questions to mind...

I'm trying to understand the subtleties of the different methods. Bear in mind that my purpose here is not for a general-purpose shaping gouge, but is to have a special tool only for the final sheering/smoothing cut to remove any tear out and permit less sanding.

I know this would be better done at the grinder, but right now I can only "think" about it because it's far too cold to take my grinder outside to actually try grinding on one right now. If you have the time and patience, please explain to me what the differences are in the end results among the following three approaches. (I suspect this will be interesting to many others here, as well, Professor Lucas.)

1) Putting the tool handle in the cup of the v-arm and spinning it all the way from corner to corner while holding it in the middle of the grinding wheel;

2) As you describe, putting the tool handle in the cup of the v-arm and spinning it at the bottom of the flute but moving it sideways on the wings; and

3) Using your "fan" method to produce what you call the "Batty" grind, i.e, simultaneous and coordinated rotating and spinning, on the top of the flat grinder tool rest.

I think some of my "understanding" and assumptions must be wrong -- maybe you an help straighten me out. Here's what I'm thinking:

#1 seems to me to be the easiest and, if I'm not mistaken, gives a constant cutting angle around the entire cutting edge of the tool, as, I believe, #3 is also supposed to, but the latter with much more difficulty. It also leaves the wings completely intact -- when I do this on my broad, U-shaped SRG, it leaves a pure, two-dimensional "U" shape with the cutting edge in a single plane -- no fingernail at all. I thought that's what I wanted -- maybe not? Are the results different with a v-shaped flute?

#2 seems like it would lead to kind of fingernail grind because it looks to me like the stone wouldn't contact the inside of the flute at the wings until the wings were somewhat ground away. Am I seeing this incorrectly, or is this on purpose? I thought the purpose was to keep the wings. What exactly is the desirable trait for the proposed use? It would also seem possible to run the edge off the corner of the wheel that way, with undesirable results. What am I missing?

#3 seems like it would provide the same equal-angle cutting edge as #1. Am I wrong? If this is true, why not just use #1? If it's different, how is it different, both in terms of shape and use?

I know, ... too many questions. One hands-on is worth a thousand words.

Thanks again for your thoughts, Gary

Re: sharpening method?

#7

Re: Thanks John...  more questions (long)

john lucas

I have the same problem as you, it's just too cold out there and I've already spent my gas heating bill for the shop for this month so I won't be at the grinder.

You are right that the angle on #1 and #3 will be the same. At least I don't think it will be different. All sliding along the stone does for me is to make it easier to get any lumps out of the straight part of the edge. Unless you religiosly flatten your stone any grooves will be transmitted to the edge. By sliding it along I can produce a straight edge.

The difference between only rotating the gouge and the "Fan" method" is how far the wings go back. You have total control of that. If you do the fan more than 40 degrees you get longer wings that sweep back more. Less and you get something between the pure U and slightly swept back wings.

I've been playing with the almost pure U or what some call a traditional grind. With the flute up the cutting angle of wood is very steep. Imagine holding a knife against the wood (tip down)so it cuts at just 5 or 10 degrees. This is what the U shape wing will do. With the same tool, flute up, ground in the Stewart Batty (I'll call that a C instead of U) grind the edge aproaches the wood at more like 35 to 45 degrees. In theory this should give you a rougher cut than the extreme shearing cut of the first one. In reality I'm having trouble telling the difference and it's much more forgiving. The U is close to a catch all the time. The C is safer because you have removed the top of the U since it gently rolls back.

I'm still trying to understand the differences. It seems that I get the same really clean cut with the U, the Batty Grind or my Thompson Detail gouge that is ground to 35 degrees. Maybe on exotics that I never get to turn there is a difference but on all the woods I turn there is very little difference in cut quality. There is more difference caused by the feed rate of the tool and how much the bevel polishes the wood.

Re: sharpening method?

#8

thanks for the update...

GaryG in MD

OK, that helps a lot -- I think I understand it a lot better now. As soon as it warms up, I'm going to get out and play with it. I'm also going to compare thin parting tools -- one with the point on the bottom, as it comes, and one modified into the Firmager shape with the point up on a small taper. That should be interesting too.

As an aside, do you use a parting/beading tool very often?

Thanks, Gary