Thanks John... more questions (long)
GaryG in MD
I appreciate you taking the time to write that. Excellent description, as Doug says. But I'm afraid it brings many more questions to mind...
I'm trying to understand the subtleties of the different methods. Bear in mind that my purpose here is not for a general-purpose shaping gouge, but is to have a special tool only for the final sheering/smoothing cut to remove any tear out and permit less sanding.
I know this would be better done at the grinder, but right now I can only "think" about it because it's far too cold to take my grinder outside to actually try grinding on one right now. If you have the time and patience, please explain to me what the differences are in the end results among the following three approaches. (I suspect this will be interesting to many others here, as well, Professor Lucas.)
1) Putting the tool handle in the cup of the v-arm and spinning it all the way from corner to corner while holding it in the middle of the grinding wheel;
2) As you describe, putting the tool handle in the cup of the v-arm and spinning it at the bottom of the flute but moving it sideways on the wings; and
3) Using your "fan" method to produce what you call the "Batty" grind, i.e, simultaneous and coordinated rotating and spinning, on the top of the flat grinder tool rest.
I think some of my "understanding" and assumptions must be wrong -- maybe you an help straighten me out. Here's what I'm thinking:
#1 seems to me to be the easiest and, if I'm not mistaken, gives a constant cutting angle around the entire cutting edge of the tool, as, I believe, #3 is also supposed to, but the latter with much more difficulty. It also leaves the wings completely intact -- when I do this on my broad, U-shaped SRG, it leaves a pure, two-dimensional "U" shape with the cutting edge in a single plane -- no fingernail at all. I thought that's what I wanted -- maybe not? Are the results different with a v-shaped flute?
#2 seems like it would lead to kind of fingernail grind because it looks to me like the stone wouldn't contact the inside of the flute at the wings until the wings were somewhat ground away. Am I seeing this incorrectly, or is this on purpose? I thought the purpose was to keep the wings. What exactly is the desirable trait for the proposed use? It would also seem possible to run the edge off the corner of the wheel that way, with undesirable results. What am I missing?
#3 seems like it would provide the same equal-angle cutting edge as #1. Am I wrong? If this is true, why not just use #1? If it's different, how is it different, both in terms of shape and use?
I know, ... too many questions. One hands-on is worth a thousand words.
Thanks again for your thoughts, Gary