Someone on a medieval woodworking group is claiming that the Douglas Fir was native to Europe, until the Ice Ages wiped it out. He provided as a source "The Eternal Frontier: An Ecological History of North America and Its Peoples" by Tim Flannery, which does indeed say that on pages 153 and 154.
The claim is that Douglas Fir was caught between the Alps and the advancing ice and lost it's habitat. My problem with the claim is that the Alps wouldn't block the tree from reseeding itself through France and then south into the hills of Provence
I know there are some real world experts here, thoughts?
My question is : What are Tim Flannery's qualifications to make such a statement? Is he an accepted ecologist or is he a writer of all things interesting ?
I have questions accepting anyone's statements without references. (except John Lucas' )
That's news to me. Pseudotsuga menziesii (Douglas Fir) is, and always has been, native to western North America. Other species of Pseudotsuga are distributed in Mexico and eastern Asia.
There are no articles in the Biosis database that reference a historical distribution of Douglas fir during the Pleistocene (the ice ages). However, there have been numerous introductions of Douglas fir into Europe in modern times.
I wonder if someone found fossil evidence recently that might suggest it grew there at one time. I'm guessing Andi's answer probably rules that out . Interesting question.
"Tim Flannery is an Australian paleontologist who visited the United States during his graduate study for a professional conference. He fell in love with the continent, and particularly with its vast trove of fossilized remains from the past."
The fossil evidence used in determining the flora at any particular spot during the ice age is from pollen. Sometimes it is difficult to determine the actual species that occurred in a locality, but the genus and family characteristics are easily identified.
I've done a fair bit of reading on plant geography, especially as it relates to the Pleistocene, and I don't recall ever seeing a reference to Douglas Fir being present in any part of Europe until recent introductions. There were, however, numerous species of conifers in the region.
The east-west barrier of the Alps and Pyrenees did stop the migration of many organisms from north to south, but the east-west routes were available to the north of these barriers. Gaps in the mountains (passes and river systems) also allowed for migration through a bottleneck of sorts.
The biogeography of this region is very complex and makes for some interesting reading, if you're a biologist ;-)
Andi is correct - Doug. Fir is native to North America (only).
The habitat that this species presently occurs in is considered circumboreal - i.e. found on all available land masses around the northern hemisphere providing the same or similar climate and water availability conditions. At the time of the last [Pleistocene] glacial maximum (ca. 18,000 years ago) all habitat zones (biomes) in the northern hemisphere were shifted south, and I suppose the author's contention is that if the coniferous forest zone (taiga) encountered the Alps, this habitat was "squeezed" out of existence by glacial advance. (This assumes Doug. Fir was there 18,000 years ago, which is questionable at the outset.) The shifting biome model includes the concomitant actions of glacial advance and movement of the biomes southward up until the maximum, followed by glacial retreat and re-colonization of land formerly occupied by the glaciers as they retreated northward. This phenomenon is well documented. During the southward shift, there should have been enough time for northerly species to colonize cooling habitats to the south and become established there; this would create a 'reserve' for northern species to wait out the glacial period and then re-establish their geographic distribution in suitable habitats as the glaciers retreated.
In rare cases there are patches of un-glaciated areas (nunataks) which have served as refugia for plants and animals that encountered glaciers, but were not overcome by them. In my biogeography class I teach about the North American nunataks, however I don't know about European glacial refugia, how they may have effected tree distribution at glacial maximum, or with present day distributions. Regardless, I doubt highly that Doug Fir entered into this region as part of the boreal forest community.
The study of glacial advance and retreat, and the resulting shifts in vegetation in Europe has been going on for many years, and if you'd like to delve into it further, you can search on 'W�rm glaciation', specifically with regard to Europe and the effects of glaciers on/with the Alps. If Douglass Fir were present in Europe (doubtful), the palynological record (fossil pollen) should easily show the presence or absence of this genus/species in Europe, given that its pollen is fairly easily identified. There likely were other conifer species related to Doug. fir (i.e Abies, Cedrus etc.) found in this area before, during, and after the glacial maximum, but I doubt highly they were Pseudotsuga.
The biogeographic data do not support a disjunction between Pseudotsuga's distribution in North America and Europe, although there is some evidence for a N. America to East Asia connection of past contiguous distribution in Pseudotsuga (and in many other species as well).
Thanks Rob, you were other I was hoping to hear from..
This was not the first out-there statement he has made, the other (recent) one was a claim that only Sugar Maple had been tapped for sugar. When I knew (and could prove) that the local (to both of us) Big Leaf Maple had been used up until transport got cheap and local production couldn't compete.