Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

End Grain bowl Question

Posts

End Grain bowl Question

#1

End Grain bowl Question

Barry Irby

I have a piece of ambrosia maple that is about 8" in diameter and 4" long. Its a really short log. Very nicely symmetrical staining. If I turn an end grain bowl out of it with the pith left centered in the bottom of the bowl, what are the chances it will survive the drying process? Would you alcohol dry it or some other process. It was cut today.

Re: End Grain bowl Question

#2

Brad Vietje

Re: End Grain bowl Question

Brad Vietje

Barry,

I see two options:

1. Turn it quite thin, especially across the pith, and turn a very shallow foot -- maybe just a raised ring to steady it. If thin enough, and turned to completion while green, your chances are OK. This is breaking the standard rules of wood turning, but I've done it. I often put a drop of thin CA right on the pith, too. The trick is to get it thin enough that the pith swells outward, instead of cracking, as in an "Ellsworth Football" hollow form. There's probably no way to rough turn and air dry it for finish turning later.

2. Drill out the pith, and turn a glue-in foot or base from another piece of wood. This can be twice turned, and can be thicker than method #1, above.

Good luck and safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: End Grain bowl Question

#3

Re: End Grain bowl Question

Doug Trembath

The best way I know of is to boil it after roughing. Steven D. Russell has a complete protocal study he did years ago. Google him and you should be able to find it. Essentially, put a pot of water over a fire outside, place the roughed out bowl into it, boil it for about an hour per inch of roughed out thickness. Let it air dry for a day or two, then bag it in paper bags, and leave it for a couple of months or so.

I can personnally attest this really reduces degrade. I have boiled Madrone Burl with spectacular results. Movement is reduced, as well.

Doug Trembath

Re: End Grain bowl Question

#4

Re: End Grain bowl Question

john lucas

Brad's second tip will work. I have a friend who turns large platter like pieces from end slices off of logs. the turns them fairly thin and then bores about a 2 1/2" hole in the middle to get the pith out. Then he inserts sort of base pedestal in them. The base is dry wood. I know, it shouldn't work turning a green top and dry base but I've seen about a dozen of these and they don't blow up. Some of them have the slightest gap at the glue joint where the wood moved later.

Re: End Grain bowl Question

#5

Richard Allen

Re: End Grain bowl Question

Richard Allen

You need to come up with a way to relieve the tension of the pith. I doubt that boiling the wood is going to have an impact on the stress in the pith.

If you give a way for the pith to relieve it's stress then it might prevent cracking. If you turn at the pith thin and provide direction for the pith to move then the pith might survive. The pith has a much better chance of survival on the steep side of a bowl.

Your dilemma goes to the heart of woodturning for many of us. That is, we want to get the most out of a piece of wood that we can. Change your thinking to getting the best out of a piece of wood. When you approach woodturning with getting the best out of a piece of wood you may find that you end up with more successful wood-turnings.

Re: End Grain bowl Question

#6

Re: End Grain bowl Question

John Lucas

Your dilemma goes to the heart of woodturning for many of us. That is, we want to get the most out of a piece of wood that we can. Change your thinking to getting the best out of a piece of wood. When you approach woodturning with getting the best out of a piece of wood you may find that you end up with more successful wood-turnings.

Richard That is the best statement I've heard in years. John Jordan shortened it to Life's to short to turn Crappy wood.

It took me a long time to get to that point. We all want to turn the biggest thing we can out of a piece of wood. Consequently you see countless bowls with off center grain and vessels with the pith in them and patched cracks all over. It is better to cut around these things and reduce the size and shape of the piece and end up with an excellent piece.

One thing you notice when you go to the instant galleries and see the top turners work. It's all smaller than you think when you see the photos. I think it's because they use the best part of the wood, and not all of the wood.

Re: End Grain bowl Question

#7

Re: End Grain bowl Question

Doug Trembath

You need to come up with a way to relieve the tension of the pith. I doubt that boiling the wood is going to have an impact on the stress in the pith.

Actually, Richard, Steve has published detailed studies he made with remarkable success in saving bowls with piths included. They were a distinct focus in his investigations. Drying time is usually reduced significantly, as well. I have copies saved of his findings, but will defer to his website for those who would like to read them, as it should be. Also, he discussed his results quite prominently on this forum and others, so much of it will be in the archives and immediately available.

Like John, I applaud your comments about useful wood, and focusing our time and effort on getting the best from a piece of wood rather than the most. Mike Mahoney told me once to always sacrifice wood for shape, not the other way around.

Each of us does, occasionally though, find a special piece of stock and have a vision we wish to achieve with it. Those times are opportunities for discovery, and for those I suggest we challenge conventional wisdom. I firmly believe many of the advancements in embellishment we have seen over the last twenty years or so have come about as a result of this type of determination. Many of the carved pieces we have seen have come about through an OOOPPSSS! that a craftsperson didn't want to give up on. One of the shapes I market is an endgrain large goblet type vase, with a base and pedestal, turned wet from a single tree section, with the pith running directly through the center. I have been successful mostly with immature Black Walnut with these. They are still ramrod straight, contrary to popular wisdom, and folks like to buy them.

Change of direction and discovery can be fun, too...

Doug Trembath

Re: End Grain bowl Question

#8

Here's the link on Boiling Blanks, Barry *LINK*

Doug Trembath

Here's the link to Steve's findings. I have used it a lot, with great success. I think it may help you do the Ambrosia Maple piece you want to do.

Best of luck, and post pics if possible.

Doug Trembath


Tips for Better Boiling