Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

Box-making demo. What would ...

Posts

Box-making demo. What would ...

#1

Box-making demo.  What would ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

YOU like to see in a box-making demo? A good demo on boxes is not necessarily easy to do. I have seen a lot of them and the most spell-binding was watching Jimmy Clewes turn his oriental box at 3300 RPM and wondering if that speed was sufficient for lift-off of a Powermatic 3520.

Just for fun I will list my answer for that question, but I want to know YOUR list.

What do I want from a box demo?

1. I want to see the entire sequence and understand the reasons for the order of things.

2. I want to know where the potholes are and how to avoid them.

3. I want to know what tools to select and how to present them to the wood, in particular how to hollow the box.

4. I want to know about wood selection and why some woods are good for boxes and some are not.

5. I want to understand that making a box with an outer lid is different from making a box with an inset lid and why the female part should be done first.

6. I want to know how to finish the box.

I am hoping for lots of responses to this one.

Ed

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#2

Re: Box-making demo.  What would ...

Dale Bright

Ed, I think your list has covered everything that I would expect to see. I know you missed the VA symposium back in Oct. and I hope you have had a chance to see Alan Lacer demo boxes. I think his demo covered everything on your list and was one of the very best I have seen on boxes.

Dale

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#3

George Taylor

Re: Box-making demo.  What would ...

George Taylor

If it is a time constrained demo, I would want 2 thru 5, otherwise I am greedy, I would want to see it all. What I wouldn't want to see is:

1. Roughing it to a cylinder

2. Making the tenons

3. Extensive time hollowing.

The demonstrator does not have to do a complete box. That is why many demonstrators have the project completed in several stages to move it along.

George

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#4

Brad Vietje

Re: Box-making demo.  What would ...

Brad Vietje

George,

Good idea on having demo pieces in various stages of completion -- it worked for Julia Childs, and I'll bet all I have that she's more famous than any turner anywhere.

I also look for very specific information on:

* chucking options

* "Grain" / figure match, and making lid & body from a single piece of wood

* Wood movement (end grain vs. side grain)

* Starting with green wood and air drying blanks (see above, too)

* Design and proportions

That makes for a LOT of information, so having multiple boxes in various pre-turned stages is even more critical.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#5

A coupla other things...

Jennifer Indy.USA

Ed, everything you've listed is much needed in a box making demo. Not being a true box maker myself....I will say that having assisted both Alan Lacer and Matthew Hill on many occasions at Marc Adam's School I've learned a lot by watching their demos over and over. One thing that I think is very important is to offer ways to fix boo-boos. There are so many opportunities to goof something up when box making. Miss fit lids, too shallow a mortise, too long of a tennnon, way mismatched grain as a result of these things etc. I think a good box maker has lots of tricks to resolve these problems that can be frequent trouble spots for beginning box makers. Offering these tricks and work arounds is a comfort to those just starting to delve into box making. Another thing that I think is incredibly important is to stress attention to details. A box is a different object than a bowl or a hollow form. It's almost like "jewelry" for something else to reside in so every detail needs to be crisp and look like it was intended. People pick up a turned box and bring it close and look at the details prior to opening it. They are precious objects that deserve attention to details. One of the details that I think is most important in boxmaking is teaching or demonstrating how to make what is probably the most difficult cut with the skew chisel and that (for me anyway) is the shoulder cut. It is so important in box making so that there is never any torn endgrain exposed on the shoulder heading into the tennon that fits into a lid, nor on the end of that tennon. If attention isn't payed to these cuts that end grain is like a glaring neon light when the box is open. It's the first thing I look at when I open a turned box.

So there's my two cents worth :)

Jen

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#6

Re: Box-making demo.  What would ...

charlie belden

Turning lidded boxes is a lot of fun - IF - you don't put yourself in a box canyon before the box is done.

There's a holding/chucking sequence that'll make turning the box easy - and a ton of other approaches that will make it tricky - if not impossible. In order to turn it - you've got to be able to hold it - and turn the area you need to work on. If you can't hold it - you can't turn it.

Providing a handout of the holding/chucking sequence of the box to be turned in a demo - that attendees have in their hands BEFORE the demo begins is, IMHO, essential. And the handout should leave room for adding notes.

See what's going to be done, talk about it and answer questions, see it done - and ask questions along the way.

Cindy Drozda does a demo for an inlayed rim lidded box with her patented (kidding) finial. I took good notes and photographed what I thought were the critical steps. Immediately after her demo I went home and drew up and annotated her procedure - with annotation. I then followed the procedure and turned a similar inlayed rim lidded box - but with an add on rather than integral finial. As I turned that piece I added notes to the first draft of the procedure and used them to revise the instructions. I then put these instructions on our club's website - so others can use it - and where I can find it again - and use it.

Even if you've done a few lidded boxes. it's easy to forget a critical step - and get in trouble. But if I have printed illustrated instructions next to the lathe, I'm less apt to find myself wondering "How the hell am I going to hold this part in order to turn The Next Step?

Illustrated handouts - with some text . . . invaluable.


img

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#7

Re: Box-making demo.  What would ...

mjonesrdg

Charlie, your drawings are excellent and show the methods better than a whole chapter of descriptive words. Posted here, they are a real gift to the woodturning community. Thanks!

Mike Jones in Redding, CA

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#8

Brad Vietje

Break It Into TWO Demo's ?

Brad Vietje

As Jennifer states, there are a LOT of small details to getting a box just right. That's why there are entire books on the subject.

Thinking over all the comments and the little but critical details (and how to address the problem areas), it seems to me you'd really be rushing things to squeeze that into a 60- or 90-minute demo slot. It might be a lot better to have one session on the basics (mechanics) of inset and over-fitting lids and the sequence of steps; and a more advanced session on design and all the little details.

In my experience, going too fast and/or trying to cover too many things can detract from the quality of the demo.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#9

Demo VS Teaching

Jennifer Indy.USA

Brad has a valid point. I really feel that demonstrating and teaching are two totally different things. Some people are much better demonstrators than they are instructors and some are better at instructing a week long class than working with the time constraints of a demo. To pack all of this into an hour and half demo may not go over too well. Most things might be merely skimmed over and not "taught" so to speak. A Fundamentals of Box Making demo and a Details of Box Making demo in the same weekend might be a way to go.

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#10

Re: Break It Into TWO Demo's ?

Ed Moore in SW VA

Brad,

It was not my intention to demo two boxes, but it is important to point out the contrast between doing the two forms.

Principle: When making a box, always do the female part first.

When doing an outside lid box, the lid should be done first.

When doing an inset lid box, the base should be done first.

The male part is essentially a tenon and it is easier to adjust a tenon than it is to adjust an opening. Or, maybe I should say that it is easier to err when adjusting an opening.

Ed

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#11

Brad Vietje

Re: Break It Into TWO Demo's ?

Brad Vietje

Ed,

The more I think about it, the more I like your general rule. That's a very economical way to state it.

I also think Jen's right -- there's a difference between demonstrating "how to make an inset lid box" or "Turning a suction-fit box", and a detailed course, covering all aspects of box making. The trick is to economize on details and tangents to accomplish the former, while avoiding an attempt at the latter.

Safe spinning,

Brad Vietje

Newbury, VT

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#12

Well Illustrated Procedure Handout -Before Turning *LINK*

charlie belden

Had a physics prof who drove me nuts. He'd have four blackboards worth of diagrams and equations ready at the beginning of a class. He then lectured on what was on the boards for an hour. At the end of the class he'd handout everything that was on the blackboards. If you spent the hour copying what was on the blackboards there wasn't time to take notes on the lecture. So the next time, you'd figure he'd be giving you what was on the blackboards so you take notes on his lecture. At the end of the lecture he'd give you his lecture notes - and you'd missed the diagrams and equations.

If you distribute the handouts first, then go over them quickly pointing out key things to be aware of and pay attention to, have some time for Q&A - and THEN - do the turning, then attendees know where you're going, how you're going to get there and WHY for each step along the way. Better yet, e-mail the handouts in .pdf format, to attendees a week or two before the demo so they have a chance to print and study the content before the demo and have questions ready as you go through the handouts.

I did these instructions for myself - but may be a starting point for a set of illustrated instructions.


Example of Lidded Box Illustrated Instructions

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#13

Re: Well Illustrated Procedure Handout -Before Tur

mjonesrdg

Charlie, please give some thought to the potential for adding a "legend" and keep your use of color and line weight consistent so I would not have to learn what "red" means,or the difference between dotted line from dashed line, from one lesson to the next.

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#14

There is a way of explaining how to ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

teach a good class.

1. Begin by telling them WHAT you are going to teach them.

2. TEACH them what you are going to teach them.

3. End by telling them what you just taught them.

Ed

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#15

Re: There is a way of explaining how to ...

Randy Gleckler

Ed,

You must have been a teacher, or close to one. I've heard that mantra for years from my Mother who taught her whole career.

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#16

Randy, you are correct, ...

Ed Moore in SW VA

I was a teacher. My first job was one year at St Andrews School in Middletown, Delaware, where they filmed Dead Poets Society. Then, after grad school, I taught Mathematics at the U. S. Naval Academy. Now I am Professor Emeritus from USNA.

I did a LOT of evaluation of junior faculty members and was the first Director of Tutoring Programs at USNA.

Now, I thoroughly enjoy teaching woodturning at John C Campbell Folk School. The next class will be Ornaments in May.

Ed

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#17

Mike Stafford

"Perfessor" Moore....

Mike Stafford

is an excellent instructor. I took his ornaments class and went from making large bumpy sticks to making smaller bumpy sticks..... :b

Ed is one of the most well prepared instructors I have encountered. Good teacher and a good guy!

Re: Box-making demo. What would ...

#18

Re: Well Illustrated Procedure Handout -Before Tur

charlie belden

I use RED to indicate the area being turned in a specific step

I used BLUE lines to indicate Control Points for curve transitions

Long Dash - Dot - Long Dash lines are typically used for CenterLines

Short Dashed lines or Dotted Lines are used to show a cross section outline that is either inside something or an area that will be removed. When the area in question is small I go with Dotted Lines, if larger, Short Dashed lines.

In any event, your point is well taken. I should be more consistent throughout a set of illustrated instructions and including a legend would be a good idea.

I do my illustrated instructions using an application called Aldus SuperPaint 3.5 - last updated in - 1993. Adobe bought out Aldus and the program was discontinued. But I know SuperPaint like the back of my hand and have yet to find an equivalent current application that's as quick to learn and very easy to use.