Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

On the topic of an electric car...

Posts

On the topic of an electric car...

#1

Steven Antonucci

On the topic of an electric car...

steven antonucci

Perhaps it's just me, but why couldn't an electric car have an alternator to keep the bateries charging? I'm not suggesting that it would negate the need for home plug ins, but it would have to extend the range?

Instead of electric/gas vehicles like the Prius, wouldn't it make sense to have a small generator on board as a back-up? Something that supplied enough electricity until you can get somewhere to plug in again, or worst case, a gas station to continue generating electricity until you can plug in again?

This stuff is almost as much fun as woodturning...

S

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#2

Richard Allen

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Richard Allen

That is how the Chevy Volt is designed.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#3

Photovoltaics

Jorge Casta�eda

Another avenue, charge as you are parked, or even in motion.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#4

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Jim DeLaney, Austintown, Ohio

No, it's not. For all the hype, the Volt is essentially a glorified Hybrid. The batteries are only good for about 25~30 miles. After that, the engine is driving the car.

The Volt's engine is pretty much the same engine that's used in the Chevy Cruze.

The only true electric car (so far) is the Nissan Leaf.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#5

Dick Hines

Re: Photovoltaics

Dick Hines

I think I may design a steam car........wait! That was done years ago.

Big V8's rule.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#6

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Galen Vetterick

Steve

When I hear about all the electric cars they want us to drive I just wonder how you decide if you run your air conditioner during the hot summer nights or charge your car so you can drive the next day. Not sure yet either what happens when the wind does not blow here in Iowa on the hot summer night and all the wind turbines are off line too.

Where is all this additional electrical power to come from since we cannot keep up with demand for it now??

Now if they would make a car run on garbage we could go forever!!!

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#7

Keith Tompkins

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

keith tompkins

Hey Steve, I'm not an engineer, but I believe it takes about 10 HP to run a typical auto alternator. If an electric car ran one alternator per wheel, if all were energized at once, the vehicle would come to a halt...we've not invented the perpetual motion machine yet. Modern trains use diesel generators to power electric motors..not very efficient. One problem with the electric vehicle is recharging...one one hand, politicians want to heavily regulate coal fired electic generating plants, which would dramatically increase operating costs, while, on the other hand, flooding the market with electric vehicles would tax our ability to produce enough electricity for both our homes and vehicles. We need nuclear plants built NOW. I think more research should be done with fuel-cell generators to power electric vehicles, or even better, fuel-cell techology to super-heat specific quanties of water, which would then be direct-injected as steam into a cylinder....no need for a pressure tank. Remember the Stanley Steamer..two pistons, about 750 cc's of displacement, which produced approx. 750 horsepower. Also, a steam engine produces full torque @0 rpm. In layman's terms "yahoo!!"

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#8

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Wayne Kuhn

If you discover a way to put 1 watt in and get 2 out please let me know, I will invest my life savings.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#9

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Bill Howatt

While Stanley Steamers did hold early land speed records, they were rated around 20-30HP not 750. 750HP would have twisted it into a pretzel.

Fuel cells are interesting but in the common type which is hydrogen these days, it is necessary to produce hydrogen and the common method is using electricity.

A major problem in petroleum alternatives is stored energy density combined with cost and so far nothing gives the same bang for the buck as oil.

Bill

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#10

Leo Cuellar

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Leo Cuellar

Steve, you could of course put a portable generator in your trunk for emergencies or for a long commute. You'd have to carry gas, or at least a gas can, which you could fill up en route. Every extra pound you carry decreases your range.

Back in the late 70's a ford engineer developed the Internal Storage Transmission. An auto with a pressure tank. A hyd. pump driven by the engine @ constant rpm supplied the tank. It had a regenerative braking system as well. These changes allowed the vehicle to double its gas mileage as the engine actually shut off for roughly 50% of the time and the car ran on the stored hydraulic pressure. At the time it was estimated that these changes would add roughly $300 to the price of a new car. One can only wonder why this was never pursued.

I read about this in Popular Science or Mechanics magazine when I was in high school.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#11

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Bill Jacksonville, NC

Nissan Leaf

http://www.nissanusa.com/leaf-electric-car/index?dcp=ppn.39666654.&dcc=0.216878497#/leaf-electric-car/index

For around town driving total electric cars make sense only with government subsidies. Charging stations outside the home being targeted in a few places, not sure, how that is working out.

Cost of the car + home inspection, charging dock installation, electric code inspection make car buying expensive.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#12

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

charlie belden

"so far nothing gives the same bang for the buck as oil. "

You do realize that some of the "bangs" for your buck are literally BANG! - accompanied by flying body parts - and all the effects after that. It's not just the BUCK you pay at the gas station, It's also some or most of the cost of an army, navy, air force and marine corps, to say nothing of the medical costs of the unpleasant medical effects of burning fossil fuel - be it oil or coal - or wood. We'll overlook the cost of the other environmental impacts. The existing "Energy Industry" is heavily goverment subsidized - Corporate Welfare. You just don't see the actual cost of our current energy use - at the pump or on your utility bill. But the cost of doing business is ALWAYS passed on to the consumer eventually. You don't get something for nothing - unless of course your a major corporation - that's Too Big To Fail.

I had no idea that my original post about seeing a Tesla car up close and in person would trigger discussion of our energy policy - but I'm glad it did. Clearly this is an issue on the minds of a lot of "ordinary folk" - as if the folks here on WC are "ordinary" ; ).

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#13

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

charlie belden

When they were putting in a new Light Rail line (read "electric trolley") up First Street, they had to excavate to create the bed for the rail lines. Guess what they hit. The OLD light rail line buried under the existing road. Turns out San Jose had a fairly extensive and profitable trolley system - that was electric. L.A. also had an extensive and profitable trolley system.

In the mid thirties and early forties, two new and growing industrial giants - Standard Oil and Goodyear Rubber and Tire were looking to expand their markets. Trollies moved a lot of people - and didn't need regularly replaceable tires - or the higher profit margin gasoline. Figuring that If You Can't Beat 'Em - BUY 'Em - they did just that. And once they bought all the trolly companies out - they paved over the trolley lines - to make more roadway for cars and buses to run on - and use gas and rubber to do so. When their collusion was discovered, the two companies were prosecuted under the Anti Trust laws and found guilty. Each company was fined- wait for it - $50,000! The two companies saw this as an excellent investment - the return on the investment being BILLIONS of dollars in the ensuing years.

I suspect that this business strategy was not applied only in California.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#14

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Scott Hurley in N VA

Wednesday night, during the snowstorm here in Washington, the Fed. Gov't let everybody out early - just as the worst of the snow was hitting. The main highways were parking lots by 4:30. It took some people 10-12 hours to get home that night. I wonder how long the battery in an electric car would last while you were sitting in traffic with the heater on? I doubt it would get many people home. As it turned out, there were abandoned cars all over the place, anyway. They either ran out of gas or drained their battery as they idled in traffic with the lights and heater both on. I'm afraid that all electric cars would just add to the total...

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#15

Jim Evans

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Jim Evans

In the 90's GM marketed the EV-1 electric car. Then they reclaimed all of the cars except a few in museums, and had them destroyed. GM would not let any of the vehicles survive even though the people who had them loved the EV-1. Oh, and GM never sold the EV-1, but leased them out.

I guess time will tell which direction the US goes, but it will be after the big money folks figure out a way to maximize their profits and not let a new business or technology in.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#16

Steven Antonucci

Some further discussion...

steven antonucci

Good thoughts so far...

As an undergraduate engineering major with a degree in electrical engineering from a top 3 school, I realize that there is no such thing as perpetual motion or free energy. What I was thinking was a little more out of the box.

Most people's daily routine would be perfectly fine in an electric vehicle. Running around town or even commuting to work (even in traffic) is probably comfortably within the range of "electric vehicle technology" (even if the car has yet to be mass produced -affordably!)

As I see it, the barriers are not technical, nor are they logistical. The barriers are big companies will have to change the model of what a "car" is and how we use it. 50 years ago, people would have looked at you as if you were crazy if you suggested leasing a vehicle, but I will bet that almost half of the new vehicles sold in the US are leased. Why not lease batteries or other "properties" of a vehicle?

If you look back to the late 1960's when the muscle cars ruled, car's were basically stripped down "engine holders" with a goal of going 0-60 in as fast as possible. The truth is that most cars probably cruise at 40 HP, and weigh 2X what they should. We are not designing cars with a goal of economy or weaning off of our foreign oil dependency because those companies make their profits based upon them!

It would take someone from outside the auto/oil cartel to make something like this because they would not start with the same requirements. When cell phones first came out, the phone company didn't see them as a threat because "everyone needed a phone in addition to the cell phone" anyway. In 20 years, people will not have "home phones" anymore (a generation will have to die off, but the next generation already is mobile only...I'm in the middle). The story with gas powered cars will not be very different.

If I only had access to a metal shop...

S

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#17

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Mark

Why not just put an electrical turbine on the car? The faster the car moves, the faster the turbine spins creating more electrical energy. It's too simple.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#18

Re: Some further discussion...

Bill Howatt

There is enough blame to be shared among the oil companies and the car manufacturers but I'll put more blame on the consumer.

Perhaps you aren't old enough but we already had the 40HP car, it was the Volkswagen beetle and other small cars of the time, typically the 60s and a bit later. I had a 40HP Anglia 105E which is the Harry Potter car. OK car for driving to work but you waited for large gaps when merging onto the freeway and if you lived in hilly country you rowed up the hills with the gearshift lever.

Nobody forced people to stop desiring these cars but being North Americans the desire and market was for more power and bigger size. Did the big oil companies force my neighbour to buy a quad-cab pickup truck that rivals a Mack truck in size that he has yet to haul much of anything in the back? No, he just wanted it and he isn't alone. And IMO, that's the issue people buy what they want. There are plenty of small cars for sale today but they only get attention when the price of gas goes up. It is known that big car/truck sales drop off when the price of gas goes up and small car sales drop off when it goes down.

If you want to get people to buy cars that use less oil then the price of oil has to go higher. Here in Canada, there probably is a higher percentage of smaller cars than in the US and that's likely a reflection of the price of gas which is about $4.37/US gal and the US and Cdn dollar are pretty much at par.

Bill

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#19

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Jorge Casta�eda

Charlie,

That strategy is and was used on many different ways and places. Towards the end of last millennium, I did witness a marvel. a greyhound bus going cross country demoing hydrogen fuel cells, we have the technology and was demonstrated in different places quite successfully, all that came out of the exhaust pipe was some water vapor and drops, that the driver collected in a glass and drank it. Quite a show!

But they killed it, as long as there is still oil being produced, they will kill anything that does not use it.

There has been many versions of electric cars since the 50's, all of the killed by Detroit.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#20

Re: Some further discussion...

Jorge Casta�eda

Steve,

I am of the old guard by age, but the only reason I still have a land line at home is because here in this town we have no coverage. This message is reaching you via a satellite, we don't need the wires anymore. Maybe we could start a business "mining" the old wires.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#21

Keith Tompkins

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

keith tompkins

Hey Bill, I may have exaggerated the hp rating, I remember that figure from several years ago. However, I checked up on some info. on the steamer...they were available in 10, 20, and 30 hp versions. However, their racing vehicle, which held the world land speed record in 1906 @ 127 mph had in excess of 100 hp. The 1907 attempt, with even more horse power crashed at nearly 150 mph, ending the Stanley bro's racing career. Seems there's untapped potential here.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#22

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

Charlie Drake

I always marvel at all the energy industry experts but I finally must reply. The most economical form of transportation is and likely always will be the internal combustion engine. Big Oil pays FAR more in taxes than any subsidy they get for R&D, exploration, etc. No big deal go take away all the subsidies-like has been said, ultimately, the consumer pays-either by his taxes or at the pump. Hydrogen cars sound nice but will never compete with internal combustion--hydrogen comes from only two sources--hydroforming petroleum products (lots of polution associated with that) or from electricity (unless nuclear, lots of polution associated with coal). Electric cars sound nice but where will all the electricity come from? How avbout a coal fired power plant-unless we go nuclear and I won't live long enough for the government to allow many new plants. And how about that new government marvel-ethanol. not only will mileage decrease by 30%, but corn has gone from about $3 per bushel to about $7 per bushel-what a boondoggle. I better quit-blood pressure is rising rapidly-have a good day.

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#23

Steven Antonucci

See my post below

steven antonucci

30 HP gets you to 100mph, perhaps a more slowly, but still 100mph...

S

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#24

100MPH?

Bill Howatt

30 HP won't necessarily get you to 100 MPH no matter how long you run. It can on a car that has excellent aerodynamics but put 30 HP into something else and it will stop accelerating out as soon as the forces balance.

Bill

Re: On the topic of an electric car...

#25

Still around ... *LINK*

Bill Howatt

Hydrogen busses were used at the Vancouver Olympics and I think London England is considering them too. I also think there are still some pilot projects using them in some cities.

Bill


Vancouver Hydrogen Busses